Derby - Ratings
#1
Wildsmith - 6 - Nothing to do all game, got beat by a worldie strike from an impossible angle. ( Controversial start  Big Grin )

Williams - 6 - Solid debut for the lad. Some good strong tackles and one or two decent runs forward. Needs to work on his decision making on the ball and when to press/get tight or not. Definitely some ability to work with. 

Taylor - 6 - When under no pressure did the simple stuff well, cleared it, kicked it, headed it. But struggled in possession when derby were deep, and got caught with balls down the side of him 3 times, once which lead to the goal. Not sure he's going to be good enough for the foreseeable. Derby definitely target our right as the game wore on. 

Campbell - 7 - Really solid full debut. Got good pace but most of all played some really penetrative passes through the lines and also carried the ball 2 or three times into midfield, and once into the final third. A skill we are massively short in. 

Styles - 7 - Defensively he's superb. Wins his tackles, makes the correct decisions when to get tight. Clocked up a GCA with his pass to price for knock down, and for a period of time in the second half, started getting himself into the positions he needs to more often, those half spaces between the midfield and opponents fullback/winger. 

Fellows - 7 - Much livelier than at the weekend. Mixed up his movements well and stretched their back line which gave space for Price to operate in, but didn't really impact the game in the final third as we know he can. Sure it will come though. 

Diakite - 6 - Good solid midfield performance. Won a couple of good tackles and made 2 really good interceptions. Got caught a couple of times trying to over play and didn't pass progressively enough given he was playing further forward for the most part. 

Mowatt - 8 - Completely controlled the tempo and flow of the game for 65 mins from deep and still offered us the most penetration from CM going forwards.

MJ - 8 - Showed why he simply has to play. Limited stat pack for cup games. But most dribbles, most fouls against, only player to play a through ball, plenty of; key passes, shots and constantly on the ball. The best we've got creatively. 

Price - 8 - Just class.

Heggebo - 7 - Good goal, good graft, good link up play.

Subs - No positive impact
"IMO of course..."
Reply
#2
Largely agree but you've marked Wildsmith about five marks too high.

I'd have backed myself to he'd their free kick away, let alone have a professional keeper simply catch the fucker.
Reply
#3
(08-13-2025, 07:45 AM)Ted Maul Wrote: Largely agree but you've marked Wildsmith about five marks too high.

I'd have backed myself to he'd their free kick away, let alone have a professional keeper simply catch the fucker.

I've watched it 10 times this morning and am still backing slippery Joe on this this occasion. 

Fwiw. I think he's shit generally. But not blaming him for this one.
"IMO of course..."
Reply
#4
(08-13-2025, 07:51 AM)Lurker#3 Wrote:
(08-13-2025, 07:45 AM)Ted Maul Wrote: Largely agree but you've marked Wildsmith about five marks too high.

I'd have backed myself to he'd their free kick away, let alone have a professional keeper simply catch the fucker.

I've watched it 10 times this morning and am still backing slippery Joe on this this occasion. 

Fwiw. I think he's shit generally. But not blaming him for this one.

If it was the first time he'd done it and it didn't cost us winning the game then I might agree but nothing about it was convincing. Poor starting position, genuinely didn't move, got a hand nowhere near it. Whatever subs are made or dodgy free kick is given, you can't legislate for a goalkeeper who simply cannot catch.
Reply
#5
He should have got that ball.

He knew exactly where it was most likely to go and just put a weak hand up and then berated a defender.

Him and Button both had decent seasons elsewhere but have absolutely shit for us. Odd.
Reply
#6
(08-13-2025, 08:02 AM)baggiebloke Wrote: He should have got that ball.

He knew exactly where it was most likely to go and just put a weak hand up and then berated a defender.

Him and Button both had decent seasons elsewhere but have absolutely shit for us. Odd.

Is it that odd?

Both goalkeepers early on in their Albion careers started getting criticism and after that every goal they conceded is super analysed until they can be found to be at fault.
The criticism doesn't come from nowhere, both goalkeepers were at fault for goals conceded, but then the criticism becomes somewhat over the top.
For what it's worth, I tend to agree with Lurker about the goal last night (not the Taylor part), I think many on here are underplaying the quality of the strike.
Reply
#7
(08-13-2025, 08:14 AM)Shabby Russian Wrote:
(08-13-2025, 08:02 AM)baggiebloke Wrote: He should have got that ball.

He knew exactly where it was most likely to go and just put a weak hand up and then berated a defender.

Him and Button both had decent seasons elsewhere but have absolutely shit for us. Odd.

Is it that odd?

Both goalkeepers early on in their Albion careers started getting criticism and after that every goal they conceded is super analysed until they can be found to be at fault.
The criticism doesn't come from nowhere, both goalkeepers were at fault for goals conceded, but then the criticism becomes somewhat over the top.
For what it's worth, I tend to agree with Lurker about the goal last night (not the Taylor part), I think many on here are underplaying the quality of the strike.

I have seen no criticism of either Button or Wildsmith that is in anyway over the top. Wildsmith came into the team and before the idiot in charge dropped him cost us seven goals in ten games.
Reply
#8
6 for crisp packet hands Huh He tried, one-handed, to punch over the bar a shot straight at him. Bizarre choice from him. It was the only thing he had to do all night. And he totally fugged it up.
Clever by the Derby player to move the ball for the free kick. The foul was right by the byline
Reply
#9
(08-13-2025, 07:37 AM)Lurker#3 Wrote: Wildsmith - 6 - Nothing to do all game, got beat by a worldie strike from an impossible angle. ( Controversial start  Big Grin )

Williams - 6 - Solid debut for the lad. Some good strong tackles and one or two decent runs forward. Needs to work on his decision making on the ball and when to press/get tight or not. Definitely some ability to work with. 

Taylor - 6 - When under no pressure did the simple stuff well, cleared it, kicked it, headed it. But struggled in possession when derby were deep, and got caught with balls down the side of him 3 times, once which lead to the goal. Not sure he's going to be good enough for the foreseeable. Derby definitely target our right as the game wore on. 

Campbell - 7 - Really solid full debut. Got good pace but most of all played some really penetrative passes through the lines and also carried the ball 2 or three times into midfield, and once into the final third. A skill we are massively short in. 

Styles - 7 - Defensively he's superb. Wins his tackles, makes the correct decisions when to get tight. Clocked up a GCA with his pass to price for knock down, and for a period of time in the second half, started getting himself into the positions he needs to more often, those half spaces between the midfield and opponents fullback/winger. 

Fellows - 7 - Much livelier than at the weekend. Mixed up his movements well and stretched their back line which gave space for Price to operate in, but didn't really impact the game in the final third as we know he can. Sure it will come though. 

Diakite - 6 - Good solid midfield performance. Won a couple of good tackles and made 2 really good interceptions. Got caught a couple of times trying to over play and didn't pass progressively enough given he was playing further forward for the most part. 

Mowatt - 8 - Completely controlled the tempo and flow of the game for 65 mins from deep and still offered us the most penetration from CM going forwards.

MJ - 8 - Showed why he simply has to play. Limited stat pack for cup games. But most dribbles, most fouls against, only player to play a through ball, plenty of; key passes, shots and constantly on the ball. The best we've got creatively. 

Price - 8 - Just class.

Heggebo - 7 - Good goal, good graft, good link up play.

Subs - No positive impact

Not a fan of scoring individual players, but if I was I would give Mowatt and Diakite the same score.
You are right Diakite isn't very adventurous going forward, but he is neat and tidy in possession and defensively reads the game well. If he is to play he should be the holding midfielder.
Mowatt is better going forward, but I feel he gets deeper and deeper as the game goes on. I don't think this is a misperception on my part, and I can't work out whether he doesn't have the stamina to play the full 90 or he is getting deeper because the rest of the team is getting deeper. I know I just notice it more with him.
Reply
#10
I thought Fellows had a poor game and MJ while better wasn’t as good as we needed him to be. All that possession and their keeper didn’t have that much to do. We know we,re not going to get defence splitting passes / assists from a midfield of Mowatt, Molumby and Diakite and so we’re heavily reliant on the Fellows MJ and Grant to provide service to the Striker (s) they simply didn’t do that last night.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: