“Experts” on Albion Youth
#21
(05-28-2019, 08:04 PM)baggie_ray Wrote: I've mentioned before that I first saw Leko in one of his first reserve games (if not his first) when the reserves played their home games at the Ricoh and the bloke behind me said he was shit. I thought that was a bit harsh based on less than a half of a match but I've come to the same conclusion myself.

Everybody can see his faults. Never looks up to play a pass and gives up if the ball doesn't run for him. He has had four years or so for those faults to be rectified so I can't see that they will now.

Harper I have never rated. He has never looked like he knew what to do on a football pitch. Again, coaching has failed to rectify this.

Regarding the opening post, Edwards I've always felt could make it at some level and I have been impressed with Soule. Rogers has talent but has been a bit up and down (no surprise considering his age).

Clayton-Phillips started the season well, looking every inch a prospect but he has fallen off the radar of late.

How old would Leko have been there Ray?
Also thoughts on Field?
Reply
#22
Leko was still a school kid. Which adds to the unjust (at the time) comment.

Field I can't get enthused about. He looked brilliant in the two games under Megson but, basically, every time I've seen him in the reserves he's played as a holding player and hasn't really impacted the game in any meaningful way.

In general, our reserves have been shit for as long as I've watched them on a semi-regular basis (1985/86)
Reply
#23
For me the one they should take a punt on is Rogers, he needs a chance, next season may be too soon but with a manager playing good football he would be good enough at this level playing off a striker whether in the number 10 role or any of the three behind a lone forward

I can see Edwards and Field being around the 18 most weeks

I shall put Leko in that list, the most naturally gifted player at the club in carrying the ball and beating his man, hence why the club have so much faith in him, work to be done on final ball, finishing, awareness, off the ball mentality............hell yes, but that you can teach, his natural ability with the ball you can not

Field, I'd love to see him succeed as nobody wants it more than him but for me he just looks too one paced for somebody his age to play centre midfield, deep holding tidying up role he could get by in this division but will ultimately depend on how the manager wants to set up

Tulloch needs a season out on loan for me

Cuzer
Reply
#24
(05-28-2019, 08:59 PM)Cuzer Wrote: For me the one they should take a punt on is Rogers, he needs a chance, next season may be too soon but with a manager playing good football he would be good enough at this level playing off a striker whether in the number 10 role or any of the three behind a lone forward

I can see Edwards and Field being around the 18 most weeks

I shall put Leko in that list, the most naturally gifted player at the club in carrying the ball and beating his man, hence why the club have so much faith in him, work to be done on final ball, finishing, awareness, off the ball mentality............hell yes, but that you can teach, his natural ability with the ball you can not

Field, I'd love to see him succeed as nobody wants it more than him but for me he just looks too one paced for somebody his age to play centre midfield, deep holding tidying up role he could get by in this division but will ultimately depend on how the manager wants to set up

Tulloch needs a season out on loan for me

Cuzer

Generally agree from what I've seen. I like Field a lot, mostly because I have a lot of time for players who can pass and keep the ball well, problem is until mid 20's they haven't got the intelligence to make the most of it. It's why Pirlo and Carrick peaked so late.

If the management develop him well, trust him and coach him, cover his weaknesses he could be one a good player for us, even in the prem. Problem is he lacks something to excite people now.
Reply
#25
(05-28-2019, 08:59 PM)Cuzer Wrote: For me the one they should take a punt on is Rogers, he needs a chance, next season may be too soon but with a manager playing good football he would be good enough at this level playing off a striker whether in the number 10 role or any of the three behind a lone forward

I can see Edwards and Field being around the 18 most weeks

I shall put Leko in that list, the most naturally gifted player at the club in carrying the ball and beating his man, hence why the club have so much faith in him, work to be done on final ball, finishing, awareness, off the ball mentality............hell yes, but that you can teach, his natural ability with the ball you can not

Field, I'd love to see him succeed as nobody wants it more than him but for me he just looks too one paced for somebody his age to play centre midfield, deep holding tidying up role he could get by in this division but will ultimately depend on how the manager wants to set up

Tulloch needs a season out on loan for me

Cuzer

I think Rogers is still some way off at present Cuzer, hell of a talent, but not ready for the first team yet. He should be training with them, and given exposure in the cups and some time on the bench, but think next season may be a little too soon for him. He definitely needs to be eased into the first team fold however and not sent out on loan.

I'd like to see Fitzwater and O'Shea involved around the match day squads next year, and for sheer pace and unpredictability alone, both Burke and Leko should be on the bench as they're both young and have talent, they just need some faith. For all the criticism he received, Burke scored 4 in 13 for Celtic.

Edwards and Field both need to be given the chance to stake a claim in the first team. I've been impressed every time I've seen Edwards, and Field is the best passer we have now that Barry has gone and Brunt's legs wont hold up over 46 games again.

With Burke, Leko, Edwards, O'Shea and Fitzwater coming into the fold, and potentially Harper still here, it's imperative whatever manager we appoint has some faith in the youth set-up we've spent so much time and money on. We then need Dowling to work some magic in adding 5-6 players who can make a difference at this level. Norwich have shown that with a few well scouted players, a canny manager and a couple of old heads you can work wonders at this level.
Reply
#26
No mention here on Field's ability to score goals. On what little I have seen (Bolton & Newcastle) he has the ability to "ghost2 into the penalty area (very old readers will recall a member of the '66 team renowned for this).
Reply
#27
(05-28-2019, 09:07 PM)SW4Baggie Wrote:
(05-28-2019, 08:59 PM)Cuzer Wrote: For me the one they should take a punt on is Rogers, he needs a chance, next season may be too soon but with a manager playing good football he would be good enough at this level playing off a striker whether in the number 10 role or any of the three behind a lone forward

I can see Edwards and Field being around the 18 most weeks

I shall put Leko in that list, the most naturally gifted player at the club in carrying the ball and beating his man, hence why the club have so much faith in him, work to be done on final ball, finishing, awareness, off the ball mentality............hell yes, but that you can teach, his natural ability with the ball you can not

Field, I'd love to see him succeed as nobody wants it more than him but for me he just looks too one paced for somebody his age to play centre midfield, deep holding tidying up role he could get by in this division but will ultimately depend on how the manager wants to set up

Tulloch needs a season out on loan for me

Cuzer

I think Rogers is still some way off at present Cuzer, hell of a talent, but not ready for the first team yet. He should be training with them, and given exposure in the cups and some time on the bench, but think next season may be a little too soon for him. He definitely needs to be eased into the first team fold however and not sent out on loan.

I'd like to see Fitzwater and O'Shea involved around the match day squads next year, and for sheer pace and unpredictability alone, both Burke and Leko should be on the bench as they're both young and have talent, they just need some faith. For all the criticism he received, Burke scored 4 in 13 for Celtic.

Edwards and Field both need to be given the chance to stake a claim in the first team. I've been impressed every time I've seen Edwards, and Field is the best passer we have now that Barry has gone and Brunt's legs wont hold up over 46 games again.

With Burke, Leko, Edwards, O'Shea and Fitzwater coming into the fold, and potentially Harper still here, it's imperative whatever manager we appoint has some faith in the youth set-up we've spent so much time and money on. We then need Dowling to work some magic in adding 5-6 players who can make a difference at this level. Norwich have shown that with a few well scouted players, a canny manager  and a couple of old heads you can work wonders at this level.

I’ve yet to see anything in Leko or Burke to indicate that they have any attribute other than raw pace.  No footballing brains, and neither has improved in the past 2-3 seasons.  The non-league structure is full of players just like them.
Reply
#28
I think a lot of our problems are due to the standard of coaching,it cannot be a coincidence that so many of our promising players come to a standstill once they get near the first team,harper in particular looks like he needs some direction,also I don’t understand the glee of some of the posters on here who continually deride them
Reply
#29
Not just us, a lot of clubs struggle to bridge that gap with young payers, and most fans are cunts about youth, they want instant finished project. Fact is most young ayers need a season or two in the first team being quite average, maybe worse to really develop, and therefore need to be used well, not every game, unless they are really good enough, but regularly enough to develop match intelligence.

They will make mistakes, a lot. They need to be supported and not yelled at or moaned at by fans, but fans want instant success, they want a wondekid like Rooney who looked a first teamer at 17, not realising that's the rarity, not the norm. Hence a lot drop down a division or two before making back at the top later.

We can do better but it's hard when instant success is required.

There are players hidden in Burke and Leko, Burke may be too hard to fix now, but Leko can still be worked on imo.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: