Best Keeper
#11
(02-12-2019, 12:35 PM)Sandking Wrote: The first keeper I ever took real notice of was Dino Zoff at Espana 82.

Agree with what EG wrote about Schmeichel.
Personal favourite Francesco Toldo.

In that period of the late 90s early 2000s Italy had so many quality keepers. Buffon, Toldo, Peruzzi, Pagliuca
Reply
#12
Im 43 so never saw Banks play. My old man said he's the best he saw so that's good enough for me

Growing up it was Southall for me. He had 4 or 5 years where he was immense. After that Schmeichel was imperious.
Reply
#13
(02-12-2019, 12:31 PM)Duffers Wrote: In my lifetime: Schmeichel

Same.

Fancy De Gea will surpass him before he retires, though.
Reply
#14
(02-12-2019, 12:48 PM)Malcolm Tucker Wrote:
(02-12-2019, 12:31 PM)Duffers Wrote: In my lifetime: Schmeichel

Same.

Fancy De Gea will surpass him before he retires, though.

For athleticism De Gea has probably already done that, Schmeichel was more imposing and commanding, but then again the big Dane had far
better and perhaps more intelligent CB's in front of him that De Gea has had of late.
Reply
#15
Never saw Banks as I'm 40 but in my lifetime is has to be Schmeichel. There is a picture of him making a save, he's full length ,arm out about 6ft of the ground. Remarkable keeper.
Reply
#16
I know memories fade of who did what but Nigel Martin was one of the finest 'keepers of recent decades. He had the misfortune of being on the top of his game at the same time that someone from a London club was in Seaman (bit like Statham and Sansom) but always seemed the better of the two. Could have held onto the shirt for years if it wasn't for Seaman, I reckon.
Reply
#17
Was bought up in the early sixties as a keeper when Banks and Yashin were on a par both brilliant and remember they did not wear gloves in them days. Pat Jennings along with DeGea brilliant at shot stopping with their feet .But the best has to be the big Dane ,Schmeichel changed goalkeeping forever for me his sheer presence put a lot of strikers off. But DeGea catching up fast.
Reply
#18
Banksey had different qualities to Jennings and Schmeichel. IMO he was the better shot stopper.
He was just unbelievable at times, some of his saves, even when you watched them over you still thought how the hell did he save that? He knew how to catch a ball and was never glued to the goal line. He made it look easy, which is always a sign of a class player.
He wasn't the tallest or built like a giant keeper either. The humblest of the humble people, loved the game and even his opponents.
Pat looked like he owned the area and very similar to Schmeichel they would just go and get the ball and players got out of his way.
Reply
#19
Schmichael, Buffon, Jennings, Southall, Foster.

There, I've said it.

EDIT: Neuer is decent. Wink
Reply
#20
(02-12-2019, 12:07 PM)Cunninghamismagic Wrote: Shilton for me.

Still can't forgive Shilton for not swalling his pride and standing down during Italia 90. The sight him flayling for the German equaliser & his woeful dives for the penalties is the stuff of nightmares.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)