Cheers Tony, off you go.
(04-07-2025, 08:53 AM)WorcsWBA Wrote: They do say that you can't have sentiment in football and that's true to some extent. Nevertheless a balance is still needed. Too many fans are now eager to make sweeping judgements, as evidenced in the title of this thread and the support its received, based on just a few months. It should be obvious to anyone that an approach of changing managers every few months is completely unsustainable, but some can't help themselves but to spread dissatisfaction at every turn all the same.

My view is simple - moreso than any other former manager who's still working, Mogga deserves greater respect and tolerance for what he achieved here before (although even that wasn't good enough for some). He is generally fondly remembered at the vast majority of clubs he's been at and, prior to coming here, went through a personal hell with his illness. Consequently, I find the disrespect being shown towards him by some to be frankly nauseating.

As for what he says, he's no different to the vast majority of managers. Once managers become publicly critical of the players, they start being accused of losing the dressing room, so they can't win really. Here, the players are behind him - no-one can accuse them of a lack of effort or infighting, both of which would be signs of internal discontent.

There are some things to put right, but all the evidence from training shows he's trying to do that, which is a far cry from Bruce's approach for example, who was cut far more slack here for far longer, when he was doing far worse. Mogga continues to have my full support.

There is no place for sentiment in football. Mowbray didn't show any when he walked out after he got us tamely relegated without landing a blow in the PL.

The 07-08 season was fun but let's not pretend we didn't have a significant advantage and still ended up going right to the wire with a points total that would more often than not see us finishing around 4th place. He's clearly a well liked footballing bloke, but so was Steve Bruce. I'm delighted he's well, but his illness should have no bearing on our assessment of the job he's doing. He's either fit enough to be our manager or he isn't. I'm not sure it has any relevance here.

He doesn't need to publicly come out and tell us Wildsmith is shit, we've known that since the second game the bloke has played. He just needs to drop him and the problem goes away. 

For all the good we've seen (Burnley, Leeds) where there was a clear plan, we've also seen a lot of self-indulged shit. Comments about wanting to "win 4-3 rather than 1-0", the obsession with turning John Swift into Alexis Mac Allister, the removal of arguably our most consistent performer in Grant, the refusal to use Dike who is crying out for minutes and sticking with Armstrong who is both out of form and not playing in his best position and most worryingly for me the drop in standards - red cards for Bartley and Furlong that have cost us across the last six games.

He's a good guy and I hope he turns it round but based on what I've seen so far I'm not as optimistic as others.
Reply
(04-07-2025, 06:08 AM)Lurker#3 Wrote: There seems to be the same narrative aimed at some fans who have pointed out that ToMo has under performed after CC as was directed at those that called out Brucey early on after Val.

When some of us pointed out our concerns originally - "You are just obsessed with CC, his football was negative and was holding us back..."

When performances regressed originally - "You can't expect a coach to turn it around that quickly, especially when the team has been so over coached and had all the attacking intent coached out of them... You need to be patient and forget about CC"

When performances haven't improved - "You have always had it in for him and are loving the fact we are losing, so you can claim to be right..."

The reality is, some of us just saw the issues straight away and pointed out the obvious. Now I can't speak for others, but I am on record on here stating how much I am fond of ToMo and was desperate for him to make it work, but the problem is, most of the issues we had weeks ago, we still have. Now the tide is turning, much quicker than it did for Bruce it must be said, which is probably learned behaviour as a set of fans.

It was a bleak, desperate and bizarre appointment. This despite so much hype that the owners know what they are doing with lists upon lists, the evidence doesnt hold up with with the manager appointment.

It is going how I expected. I take no pleasure in that. 

The abuse isn't warranted and posters saying that I ever want Albion to lose are just deluded.

I haven't called for him to be sacked, just didn't want him appointed. I've already said he should have another season
Reply
I’m not all in behind Mowbray, I had and have some reservations, I just think he deserves a chance and a bit of respect. There’s already some revisionism happening.

CC was a quality coach and he had us just outside the play-offs. We’re still right in the mix, despite the injuries and coming in mid season. So I don’t see why Mowbray should be “expected” to make the play offs when CC was struggling to keep up.

I’ve read that TM doesn’t know what he’s doing as he played Price as a full back at Burnley. How quickly do people forget that Furlong was banned and Holgate was covering injuries. Ajayi may be 3rd choice and he was injured to.

And now it’s that we’ve lost our discipline. What bollocks. Bartley has done that sort of thing before and was a harsh red card. Similar to Furlong, that was harsh. If they were arguing with the ref or each other then fair enough, but as a stick to beat Mowbray with? Nah.

It’s this behaviour along with “I told you so” 2 or 3 games in that makes me end up defending a guy who I’m not sure of entirely myself. We can’t just keep sacking managers because the team aren’t quite good enough, eventually you have to stick.
Trump is a Cunt
Reply
(04-07-2025, 12:58 PM)CA Baggie Wrote: I’m not all in behind Mowbray, I had and have some reservations, I just think he deserves a chance and a bit of respect.  There’s already some revisionism happening.

CC was a quality coach and he had us just outside the play-offs. We’re still right in the mix, despite the injuries and coming in mid season.  So I don’t see why Mowbray should be “expected” to make the play offs when CC was struggling to keep up.

I’ve read that TM doesn’t know what he’s doing as he played Price as a full back at Burnley.  How quickly do people forget that Furlong was banned and Holgate was covering injuries.  Ajayi may be 3rd choice and he was injured to.

And now it’s that we’ve lost our discipline.  What bollocks.  Bartley has done that sort of thing before and was a harsh red card.  Similar to Furlong, that was harsh.  If they were arguing with the ref or each other then fair enough, but as a stick to beat Mowbray with?  Nah.

It’s this behaviour along with “I told you so” 2 or 3 games in that makes me end up defending a guy who I’m not sure of entirely myself.  We can’t just keep sacking managers because the team aren’t quite good enough, eventually you have to stick.

As I said to Worcs. He's a decent bloke, but that shouldn't come into play when we're discussing his contribution as our manager.

Again, why bring Carlos into it? Those of us who were fans of his are hammered when we talk about him. He left, it was unfortunate because at the point he left we looked like we'd turned a corner. We beat Bristol City just before he left with absolute ease, we're now talking about our game down there tomorrow night as if we're going to play 1970s Brazil. Fact remains that we'd starting scoring more, we didn't let any in (metrics we're now performing worse in) and a lot of posters on here have since acknowledged that with the January additions we were more likely to have made a spot in the POs our own as opposed to falling further back. All irrelevant anyway, his childhood club came calling and made him an offer he couldn't refuse.

It is a lack of discipline. For example, under the previous regime that was criticised for being overbearing and too intense, we had one red card, red cards cost you and they're an important detail of the game that can be managed. In a handful of games under the new manager we've had two needless ones for senior players. When you add that to stupid quotes in the media about "winning 4-3 rather than 1-0", "I'm not telling you where to pass", "falling back in love with the game" and the Jed Wallace interview with WM where he talked about how "relaxed" everything was. I do think that hints at giving a squad too much leeway, to me that lies with the man in charge. It's all fine and dandy when results are good, but not when they're getting worse.

The "I told you so" is purely a reaction to being shouted down when legitimate concerns were raised at the time. Legitimate concerns that have proven to be well founded in recent weeks and that many others are starting to agree with.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: