Posts: 17,072
Threads: 614
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
114
02-14-2025, 09:13 AM
(This post was last modified: 02-14-2025, 09:16 AM by Derek Hardballs.)
Ultimately a manager is judged by results within the parameters of resources. We aren’t a nursery for richer clubs to buy our best young players from, after we’ve carefully nutured them. We are a professional football club, with a decent squad that first and foremost should be looking to win promotion. Some seem to have forgotten this, with talk of developing young players and selling them on as a prime concern… that should be by-product of the clubs success on the field it certainly shouldn’t be the main ambition for the next few seasons.
We are the only club in the West Midlands who show this complete lack of ambition for ourselves and it’s distinctly small time. I find it so irritating that sons are happy to languish in Championship purgatory season after season in the hope we suddenly produce a complete young hungry squad capable of competing in the Prem… it’s never going to happen, you need to buy when you’re there rather than in the way.
Posts: 1,960
Threads: 80
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
26
(02-14-2025, 09:13 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: Ultimately a manager is judged by results within the parameters of resources. We aren’t a nursery for richer clubs to buy our best young players from, after we’ve carefully nutured them. We are a professional football club, with a decent squad that first and foremost should be looking to win promotion. Some seem to have forgotten this, with talk of developing young players and selling them on as a prime concern… that should be by-product of the clubs success on the field it certainly shouldn’t be the main ambition for the next few seasons.
We are the only club in the West Midlands who show this complete lack of ambition for ourselves and it’s distinctly small time.
We are the only club close to getting points docked for PSR, not sure a comparison is fair. Villa are in a different financial world to us, Wolves have been having to sell to survive, Blues are having a free shot outside the PSR constraints.
Posts: 9,641
Threads: 411
Joined: Aug 2024
Reputation:
33
(02-14-2025, 09:13 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: Ultimately a manager is judged by results within the parameters of resources. We aren’t a nursery for richer clubs to buy our best young players from, after we’ve carefully nutured them. We are a professional football club, with a decent squad that first and foremost should be looking to win promotion. Some seem to have forgotten this, with talk of developing young players and selling them on as a prime concern… that should be by-product of the clubs success on the field it certainly shouldn’t be the main ambition for the next few seasons.
We are the only club in the West Midlands who show this complete lack of ambition for ourselves and it’s distinctly small time. I find it so irritating that sons are happy to languish in Championship purgatory season after season in the hope we suddenly produce a complete young hungry squad capable of competing in the Prem… it’s never going to happen, you need to buy when you’re there rather than in the way.
I can't agree with this at all. How does it lack ambition? It shows a clear plan, and long term thinking.
We sign a young talented player that can help us in any given current season, which leads to relative success, a bigger club comes in for them, due to their talent, pay us a fee, which we invest in the squad and more talented young players, which further increases our chances of success, and hopefully sell on more talented young players and continuously build that way.
Unfortunately, our stature within the pyramid makes it impossible to hold onto anyone half decent for a sustained period, including coaches, as we have seen.
It sounds like a very good plan, and one I'm happy at the club for taking.
Posts: 8,841
Threads: 315
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
78
(02-14-2025, 09:13 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: Ultimately a manager is judged by results within the parameters of resources. We aren’t a nursery for richer clubs to buy our best young players from, after we’ve carefully nutured them. We are a professional football club, with a decent squad that first and foremost should be looking to win promotion. Some seem to have forgotten this, with talk of developing young players and selling them on as a prime concern… that should be by-product of the clubs success on the field it certainly shouldn’t be the main ambition for the next few seasons.
We are the only club in the West Midlands who show this complete lack of ambition for ourselves and it’s distinctly small time. I find it so irritating that sons are happy to languish in Championship purgatory season after season in the hope we suddenly produce a complete young hungry squad capable of competing in the Prem… it’s never going to happen, you need to buy when you’re there rather than in the way.
When you say we as a club lack ambition are you referring to the fans or the board? Because Nestor was quoted as saying that 4th was the aim at the start of the season and from his evaluation of the transfer window was very focused on points tally per money spent.
There's no way we would have got Armstrong in (who won't have been cheap) if the board weren't pushing for promotion this season.
And yes, we absolutely do need a overall plan for getting in transfers with proper scouting. Years of Hotch-Potch Who's Available was a major contributor to our calamitous relegation under Pulis/Pardew and wasting ludicrous sums of money on the likes of Burke and Chadli.
Posts: 10,272
Threads: 694
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
32
02-14-2025, 09:51 AM
(This post was last modified: 02-14-2025, 09:52 AM by Spandaubaggie.)
(02-14-2025, 09:17 AM)richbaggie Wrote: (02-14-2025, 09:13 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: Ultimately a manager is judged by results within the parameters of resources. We aren’t a nursery for richer clubs to buy our best young players from, after we’ve carefully nutured them. We are a professional football club, with a decent squad that first and foremost should be looking to win promotion. Some seem to have forgotten this, with talk of developing young players and selling them on as a prime concern… that should be by-product of the clubs success on the field it certainly shouldn’t be the main ambition for the next few seasons.
We are the only club in the West Midlands who show this complete lack of ambition for ourselves and it’s distinctly small time.
We are the only club close to getting points docked for PSR, not sure a comparison is fair. Villa are in a different financial world to us, Wolves have been having to sell to survive, Blues are having a free shot outside the PSR constraints.
This in spades.
Patel and his crew are having to work in difficult circumstances. It's nothing to do with ambition.
Blues completely cocked up when in a similar position and then made a stupid Hollywood managerial appointment, which landed them in the crap.Villa got almightily lucky to avoid FFP, whilst Wolves are now going backwards, but are helped by the chasm between the Prem and Champ probably saving their skins.
Now, playing the likes of Exeter and Cambridge Blues look in a good position again without the FFP hampering them.
With a more careless approach Nestor etc could have had us relegated this season, but as things are we are still top 6.
I understand we have to cut our cloth accordingly again next season so in the meantime have to carefully mould the squad and culture of the team.
I really can't be too upset with what we've seen so far off TM. He can't take any blame for the Boro defeat. We had a great performance v Pompey, showed character v Sheff W, to win in the last min, whilst results like Plymouth and Blackburn are part of the transition.
Under CC I wouldn't have expected any better a points haul.
I think TM deserves a free hit this season, even if we finish outside the play-offs, so long as we see something better evolving, like what he developed at Sunderland.
Posts: 8,841
Threads: 315
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
78
(02-14-2025, 09:51 AM)Spandaubaggie Wrote: (02-14-2025, 09:17 AM)richbaggie Wrote: (02-14-2025, 09:13 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: Ultimately a manager is judged by results within the parameters of resources. We aren’t a nursery for richer clubs to buy our best young players from, after we’ve carefully nutured them. We are a professional football club, with a decent squad that first and foremost should be looking to win promotion. Some seem to have forgotten this, with talk of developing young players and selling them on as a prime concern… that should be by-product of the clubs success on the field it certainly shouldn’t be the main ambition for the next few seasons.
We are the only club in the West Midlands who show this complete lack of ambition for ourselves and it’s distinctly small time.
We are the only club close to getting points docked for PSR, not sure a comparison is fair. Villa are in a different financial world to us, Wolves have been having to sell to survive, Blues are having a free shot outside the PSR constraints.
This in spades.
Patel and his crew are having to work in difficult circumstances. It's nothing to do with ambition.
Blues completely cocked up when in a similar position and then made a stupid Hollywood managerial appointment, which landed them in the crap.Villa got almightily lucky to avoid FFP, whilst Wolves are now going backwards, but are helped by the chasm between the Prem and Champ probably saving their skins.
Now, playing the likes of Exeter and Cambridge Blues look in a good position again without the FFP hampering them.
With a more careless approach Nestor etc could have had us relegated this season, but as things are we are still top 6.
I understand we have to cut our cloth accordingly again next season so in the meantime have to carefully mould the squad and culture of the team.
I really can't be too upset with what we've seen so far off TM. He can't take any blame for the Boro defeat. We had a great performance v Pompey, showed character v Sheff W, to win in the last min, whilst results like Plymouth and Blackburn are part of the transition.
Under CC I wouldn't have expected any better a points haul.
I think TM deserves a free hit this season, even if we finish outside the play-offs, so long as we see something better evolving, like what he developed at Sunderland.
Absolutely not.
We got a Championship-experienced manager to avoid the "getting used to the Championship" time period.
People said the "free hit" nonsense about Bruce and look how that turned out.
Posts: 13,256
Threads: 468
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
45
A free hit?! We've got the top assister in the league, we had the top scorer in the league until he got injured so we've now brought in last years second highest scorer as a replacement and that's the one position that everyones been saying is where we're worst off!
Absolutely ZERO excuses for not getting in the playoffs now.
Posts: 1,960
Threads: 80
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
26
TM shouldn't get a free hit. If we don't get play offs, we'll have gone backwards despite adding probably the best striker in the Championship and strengthening elsewhere all whilst we were already in the play off positions.
Posts: 10,272
Threads: 694
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
32
(02-14-2025, 10:00 AM)Squid Wrote: (02-14-2025, 09:51 AM)Spandaubaggie Wrote: (02-14-2025, 09:17 AM)richbaggie Wrote: (02-14-2025, 09:13 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: Ultimately a manager is judged by results within the parameters of resources. We aren’t a nursery for richer clubs to buy our best young players from, after we’ve carefully nutured them. We are a professional football club, with a decent squad that first and foremost should be looking to win promotion. Some seem to have forgotten this, with talk of developing young players and selling them on as a prime concern… that should be by-product of the clubs success on the field it certainly shouldn’t be the main ambition for the next few seasons.
We are the only club in the West Midlands who show this complete lack of ambition for ourselves and it’s distinctly small time.
We are the only club close to getting points docked for PSR, not sure a comparison is fair. Villa are in a different financial world to us, Wolves have been having to sell to survive, Blues are having a free shot outside the PSR constraints.
This in spades.
Patel and his crew are having to work in difficult circumstances. It's nothing to do with ambition.
Blues completely cocked up when in a similar position and then made a stupid Hollywood managerial appointment, which landed them in the crap.Villa got almightily lucky to avoid FFP, whilst Wolves are now going backwards, but are helped by the chasm between the Prem and Champ probably saving their skins.
Now, playing the likes of Exeter and Cambridge Blues look in a good position again without the FFP hampering them.
With a more careless approach Nestor etc could have had us relegated this season, but as things are we are still top 6.
I understand we have to cut our cloth accordingly again next season so in the meantime have to carefully mould the squad and culture of the team.
I really can't be too upset with what we've seen so far off TM. He can't take any blame for the Boro defeat. We had a great performance v Pompey, showed character v Sheff W, to win in the last min, whilst results like Plymouth and Blackburn are part of the transition.
Under CC I wouldn't have expected any better a points haul.
I think TM deserves a free hit this season, even if we finish outside the play-offs, so long as we see something better evolving, like what he developed at Sunderland.
Absolutely not.
We got a Championship-experienced manager to avoid the "getting used to the Championship" time period.
People said the "free hit" nonsense about Bruce and look how that turned out.
If we don't make the play-offs but see progress in style and the blooding of new players I'm happy enough. There's a 1 in 4 chance of getting promoted anyhow.
I do think if we notably go backwards then it's a different story.
I trust those who will make the decision far more than myself to make that call.
Constrained by FFP I think it's time for calm heads
Posts: 7,994
Threads: 188
Joined: Jul 2019
Reputation:
37
Coventry have won 5 of the last 6, perhaps we should have gone for Frank.
The rest of the top half are much of a muchness, in the same 6 game period.
Us - 7 points
B'burn - 6
Bristol - 8
Wed - 8
Norwich - 7
Watford - 4
QPR - 9
It's a tough league.
|