£40bn Taxes & Spending Cuts in the Budget
#1
As I posted at the time, during the election campaign both main parties were entirely complicit in refuting what would be necessary to increase government spending by the rate of growth. 

Labour's "Fully Costed" (arf) Manifesto only demanded VAT on Private Schools and more taxes on Non-Doms to fund its commitments. Reeves herself also ruled out changing the fiscal rules. 

So I'm guessing that no-one voted for this? 

And what does it say about Labour's "Fully Costed" Manifesto? Lies, or just self-delusion?
Reply
#2
I think it says everything about the world of pain you created. When lies and denial of obvious points become acceptable, see Brexit, Farage, Trump, Johnson, then you have to suffer the consequences. When this was pointed out to you at the time your standard response was something along the lines of ‘get over it’.

Before you can ask the question about Labour’s fully costed manifesto, you will need to explain the bullshit around Brexit 2015/16, then Johnson 2019. All of those examples don’t appear to have urged you to ask whether or not that was self delusion.
Reply
#3
(10-16-2024, 12:34 PM)baggy1 Wrote: I think it says everything about the world of pain you created.

That Labour apparently didn't know anything about until 5th July.

I don't have to add anything to the answers I've given about the past B1, they have no bearing on the question which is, in the face of all the evidence presented to you prior to the election did YOU believe the Labour Manifesto was "fully costed"? 

I think you're as damned as I've ever been whichever answer you give.

Welcome to government.
Reply
#4
I’d answer but I’m too busy building 40 new hospitals
Would rather talk to ChatGPT
Reply
#5
(10-16-2024, 12:47 PM)CarlosCorbewrong Wrote: I’d answer but I’m too busy building 40 new hospitals

Which is precisely the point; you can't expect to make Manifesto commitments and not expect to be judged against them less than six months later.
Reply
#6
That bridge to Northern Ireland ain’t gonna build itself
Reply
#7
I would say that you are 'self-deluded' Proth, The Labour manifesto said this: "Labour will not increase taxes on working people, which is why we will not increase National Insurance, the basic, higher, or additional rates of Income Tax, or VAT."

Splitting hairs here but they only promised not raising national insurance on working people, were just going to have to disagree on the meaning of working people, I'd see it as individuals that are employed and not entities that employ.
Reply
#8
(10-16-2024, 02:03 PM)baggy1 Wrote: I would say that you are 'self-deluded' Proth, The Labour manifesto said this: "Labour will not increase taxes on working people, which is why we will not increase National Insurance, the basic, higher, or additional rates of Income Tax, or VAT."

Splitting hairs here but they only promised not raising national insurance on working people, were just going to have to disagree on the meaning of working people, I'd see it as individuals that are employed and not entities that employ.

I haven't taken issue with the mealy mouthed semantics of that point B1. I'll let you and the other red shirts weasel your way out of that one.

I'm far more interested in the claim that Labour's manifesto was "fully costed". Here it is in case you haven't read it: https://labour.org.uk/change/labours-fiscal-plan/

Labour's "fully costed" manifesto detailed tax raising measures estimated to bring in £10.5bn of which:

1. £5.23bn from Non-dom loopholes which everyone now agrees is unlikely to raise anything like that, and may end up costing the Treasury.

2. £1.51bn from VAT on private schools, which has spawned a new industry of advisors to private schools seeking clawback of up to a decades worth of VAT on capital investment and 10,000 kids leaving into the state sector already - so unlikely to raise anything like the amount. 

3. £0.56bn from closing the carried interest loophole which is unlikely to be raised as PE-investors will simply alter behaviour or domicile, probably fewer PE-backed deals so less CGT payable etc.

So given that what was IN THE MANIFESTO is going to raise the thick end of fuck all where are these £40bn in tax rises going to fall then? Well, that'll be on all or us. And as Labour stupidly ruled out increasing personal Income Tax and VAT, then they'll have to find new and ingenious ways of penalising us thinking that we won't notice (like Employers NI).

Labour dressed itself in a fiscal straitjacket of its own making by refusing to simply to reverse Hunt's ridiculous NI bear trap. They've compounded it by ruling out other increases.

I'm awaiting 30th October with a morbid fascination, and I'm spending the evening of 31st with Paul Johnson from the IFS. I seem to be in lock step with him at the moment about the honesty of Labour during the election campaign.

So, tell me B1 - did you ever think Labour's Manifesto was "fully costed"?
Reply
#9
As you are fully aware it was fully costed on the knowledge that was available. Hardly Labour’s fault that the Tories hadn’t been as honest and open with the finances as they claimed.

And the brass balls to talk of honesty during election campaigns must put a real strain on your y-fronts I’m guessing.
Reply
#10
(10-16-2024, 04:31 PM)baggy1 Wrote: As you are fully aware it was fully costed on the knowledge that was available. Hardly Labour’s fault that the Tories hadn’t been as honest and open with the finances as they claimed.

And the brass balls to talk of honesty during election campaigns must put a real strain on your y-fronts I’m guessing.

Arf, the irony meter has just reached critical. Proth wanting honesty during an election campaign is quite something.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 3 Guest(s)