10-09-2023, 09:46 AM
(10-09-2023, 09:40 AM)Brentbaggie Wrote:(10-08-2023, 05:31 PM)Runaroundandgroovelikeabaggie Wrote:(10-07-2023, 04:28 PM)Albionmad Wrote: Anybody on here ever see Duncan Edwards play?I'm too young to have seen him play, but one of my late Dad's mates grew up in Manchester in the 50s and lived on the next street to Edwards digs. He saw him play and to this day maintains he would have coped with modern football cos he was quite simply, that good and would have just graced the game even more with better pitches, balls, boots, training etc. Was a top lad by all accounts and would happily spend the afternoons/evenings on the streets playing footy with the local lads.
Just wondered how they compare in the way of skill, physique, tackling etc.
Of course we're talking about totally different eras. Footballs, kit, pitches, training methods, sports science are all completely different or didn't exist in Edwards' day.
Only ever saw my father cry twice. Once when his beloved Boxer dog had to be put down - the other when I came across a picture of Duncan Edwards (whom I didn't know) in the Sam Buchan 1954 year book, (which dad had of course because we'd won the cup). He was sat in his armchair and I sat next to him on the arm and showed him Edwards's photo. My dad turned away at once and I didn't understand so I bent round to try to see his face and there were huge tears rolling down his cheeks. I was so shocked - my dad literally couldn't speak. IT was only a good while later that he could bring himself to tell me about him and said quite simply he was the greatest player he'd ever seen - and we turned Edwards down at 13 or 14 I think, because he was too small.
I used to love going through my Dads old Charles (?) Buchan annuals. Must get them down from the loft at some point.


