So, how long does Moore have?
#1
Not advocating sacking him, more just gauging opinion.

On the positive side, I think he's brought unity and pride back after the mess of last season, and when I look at how Swansea and Stoke are doing, it's far too easy to forget we were as much of a state - if not more in Stoke's case - as both of these clubs, yet we look the most likely to return of all 3. Further, he picked up an unbalanced squad that needed to combine both a change in mentality and style with picking up results, which for the most part he's managed. 

The negative is that we're under-achieving. When I look at the sides above and around us, we have far more in the tank. Yes our squad lacked balance, but I still feel we're too reliant on individual moments to win games and that I can count on one hand the number of genuinely quality performances we've put in this season and as the games progress we don't seem to be evolving or progressing any discernible way of playing. 

I didn't expect promotion this season, and still don't if I'm honest, so to sack him for not taking us up would be incredibly harsh, but having looked at the standard of sides around us, if we do drop out of the top 6 in the next few weeks, I'd be asking questions.
Reply
#2
I think we are playing at 75% capacity and only hit the hights what i would expect a few times which was leeds and sheff utd second half .
Reply
#3
Seasons end for me.

We go up and it's job done. We fail and he has to go. He's the sort of man that will realise failure and walk away and if he fails to get us up with this squad, so he should.
Reply
#4
He’s still well in credit for me, given the state we were in when he first took over we could easily have done a awolves and crashed down through the Championship too. That he has picked up a squad destroyed by Pulis and Pardew, rebuilt their belief and got us challenging is a remarkable job.

Is he perfect, of course not. He’s shown himself to be too inflexible tactically when he finds something that works, and less said about his subs the better, but he’s still a young coach and will improve over time.

Ultimately I’m enjoying Albion again for the first time in years and that is all down to the work DM has done. Long may it continue.

(Oh and we won’t drop out of the top 6)
Reply
#5
eh!??!!

Look at the predictions for the start of the season (well, actually you can't now that the board has changed), the majority said that we would finish between 7th and 12th. Most people were rabbiting on about how weak our squad was in the first half of the season.

In fact I distinctly remember one of your posts saying "We aren't good enough to get promoted with this squad". Well the squad has only improved a week ago, and we're just as likely to go up the table as down at this point. So which is it? Are we underachieving with a great squad, or overachieving with a "squad that's not good enough to get promoted"? It can't be both.

Asking "how long does Moore have?" at this point makes no sense. If we lose the next few then we can start to talk about borrowed time, if keep up our average PPG or better than that in the next few games then the question will continue to not make sense, and we review at the end of the season.
Reply
#6
He's got the next 10 years for me.

Doing well this season.

Young manager still learning.

Some stability would do wonders for us in the long run.
Reply
#7
(02-07-2019, 11:08 AM)SW4Baggie Wrote: Not advocating sacking him, more just gauging opinion.

On the positive side, I think he's brought unity and pride back after the mess of last season, and when I look at how Swansea and Stoke are doing, it's far too easy to forget we were as much of a state - if not more in Stoke's case - as both of these clubs, yet we look the most likely to return of all 3. Further, he picked up an unbalanced squad that needed to combine both a change in mentality and style with picking up results, which for the most part he's managed. 

The negative is that we're under-achieving. When I look at the sides above and around us, we have far more in the tank. Yes our squad lacked balance, but I still feel we're too reliant on individual moments to win games and that I can count on one hand the number of genuinely quality performances we've put in this season and as the games progress we don't seem to be evolving or progressing any discernible way of playing. 

I didn't expect promotion this season, and still don't if I'm honest, so to sack him for not taking us up would be incredibly harsh, but having looked at the standard of sides around us, if we do drop out of the top 6 in the next few weeks, I'd be asking questions.

I would like to think he would get next season to have another crack at promotion if we don't do it this season. 

Realistically though, if it is looking like we are nowhere near around xmas next season, or we have a disastrous end to this season and miss out on the play-offs, the board will get twitchy. 

If it was up to me I'd be happy giving him a long period in charge no matter how well he does in the short-term. He almost pulled off a miracle last season and in his first full season as a manager is in with a chance of promotion in a tough league. There are signs that he is going to be a top manager. And he is Albion through and through which always helps.
Reply
#8
(02-07-2019, 11:17 AM)MGalea Wrote: He's got the next 10 years for me.

Doing well this season.

Young manager still learning.

Some stability would do wonders for us in the long run.


Agreed.

Mooro won't be going anywhere. Let him build something here.
Reply
#9
(02-07-2019, 11:15 AM)Sliced Wrote: eh!??!!

Look at the predictions for the start of the season (well, actually you can't now that the board has changed), the majority said that we would finish between 7th and 12th. Most people were rabbiting on about how weak our squad was in the first half of the season.

In fact I distinctly remember one of your posts saying "We aren't good enough to get promoted with this squad". Well the squad has only improved a week ago, and we're just as likely to go up the table as down at this point. So which is it? Are we underachieving with a great squad, or overachieving with a "squad that's not good enough to get promoted"? It can't be both.

Asking "how long does Moore have?" at this point makes no sense. If we lose the next few then we can start to talk about borrowed time, if keep up our average PPG or better than that in the next few games then the question will continue to not make sense, and we review at the end of the season.
There is a balance between the 2 that now he isnt getting the best out whats available its like the clock gets 75 mins and he goes into panic mode ,i like DM but as ive said before we are playing at 75 % at what we are capable of .
Reply
#10
For me the only thing he needs to get better at are his subs-when to use them and who to change. It’s hard to criticise him though as 6 months in to any new job is hard for anyone, but as long as he learns he and we will be fine.

I’d much prefer this scenario to maybe applying a ‘rowett’ Only to find out it’s nit working by Xmas.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 2 Guest(s)