04-25-2019, 09:55 PM
As posters on here will know, I follow FFP very closely. Unfortunately I fear that I am wasting my time because there seems to be no desire for the EFL to enforce the rules that they created, and it is increasingly evident that there is no incentive in complying with them if others can ignore them with no consequences. Some clubs have been hammered for breaches, while others seem to get away with it.
It is time for the EFL to make a decision. Either enforce it properly and consistently or scrap it, at least in its current format.
FFP may well minimize the number of clubs going bust, but let’s be honest, in the Premier League at least it’s got nothing to do with that. It’s solely about the big 6 creating a cosy cartel which other clubs cabbie break.
So, what’s the future?
In my view some form of FFP is required. I don’t think anybody is likely to argue that protecting clubs from reckless owners who risk a club’s future existence isn’t a good thing. But why should clubs with wealthy owners not be allowed to spend their wealthy owners’ money, provided that the clubs doesn’t get burdened with debt?
I would strip FFP right down, and say that a club should be allowed to freely spend up to 75% of its income on wages, and that all losses must be covered by the owners contributing capital. If the owner does not do that within (say) 6 months of the club’s year end, then sanctions should apply. But if the owner covers all losses and bears all the risks, with no risk to the club, then they should be able to spend whatever they like.
In order to cover the death or change in financial circumstances of a wealthy owner, who cannot then meet his obligations, I would stipulate that if any club has a wage bill which exceeds 75% of its projected income for the season, then they should have to inject capital equal to two seasons worth of that excess wage bill. So, assume that you are an established Championship club like Bristol City with £30m of income. A cap of 75% of that for the wage bill is £22.5m. Assume that it’s billionaire owner, Landsdown, wants to bankroll a promotion drive. He increases the wage bill to £50m, £27.5m over the limit. He therefore has to put in £55m as capital, so it is his risk, not the club’s risk. In addition, if the club loses £20m in a season, he has to put in a further £20m of capital to cover those losses.
The effect of this is that Championship clubs suddenly become very attractive investment propositions. Investors, not reckless speculators, can freely buy a club and bankroll a promotion to the Premier League. If it succeeds, his investment produces a good return for him. If it fails, he wears all the losses. The club’s future is never out at risk, and there is then no limit to clubs going up and threatening to break the big 6 cartel. Much as though I’d hate to see it, why shouldn’t Wolves or Villa with their wealthy owners then “go for it”?
FFP is designed to stop clubs going bust by spending money that they haven’t got, and which their owners cannot cover. It should not be there to stop wealthy owners spending their own money, at their own risks. Add in a couple of safeguards as outlined above and a “light” FFP (which is already now known as Profit & Sustainability”, a far more appropriate name), would achieve its objectives.
The “big 6” wouldn’t like it but “screw them”. The Premier League is already broken as a true competition because of the ceiling on spending which is far lower than for the other 14 clubs.
Something has to change.
It is time for the EFL to make a decision. Either enforce it properly and consistently or scrap it, at least in its current format.
FFP may well minimize the number of clubs going bust, but let’s be honest, in the Premier League at least it’s got nothing to do with that. It’s solely about the big 6 creating a cosy cartel which other clubs cabbie break.
So, what’s the future?
In my view some form of FFP is required. I don’t think anybody is likely to argue that protecting clubs from reckless owners who risk a club’s future existence isn’t a good thing. But why should clubs with wealthy owners not be allowed to spend their wealthy owners’ money, provided that the clubs doesn’t get burdened with debt?
I would strip FFP right down, and say that a club should be allowed to freely spend up to 75% of its income on wages, and that all losses must be covered by the owners contributing capital. If the owner does not do that within (say) 6 months of the club’s year end, then sanctions should apply. But if the owner covers all losses and bears all the risks, with no risk to the club, then they should be able to spend whatever they like.
In order to cover the death or change in financial circumstances of a wealthy owner, who cannot then meet his obligations, I would stipulate that if any club has a wage bill which exceeds 75% of its projected income for the season, then they should have to inject capital equal to two seasons worth of that excess wage bill. So, assume that you are an established Championship club like Bristol City with £30m of income. A cap of 75% of that for the wage bill is £22.5m. Assume that it’s billionaire owner, Landsdown, wants to bankroll a promotion drive. He increases the wage bill to £50m, £27.5m over the limit. He therefore has to put in £55m as capital, so it is his risk, not the club’s risk. In addition, if the club loses £20m in a season, he has to put in a further £20m of capital to cover those losses.
The effect of this is that Championship clubs suddenly become very attractive investment propositions. Investors, not reckless speculators, can freely buy a club and bankroll a promotion to the Premier League. If it succeeds, his investment produces a good return for him. If it fails, he wears all the losses. The club’s future is never out at risk, and there is then no limit to clubs going up and threatening to break the big 6 cartel. Much as though I’d hate to see it, why shouldn’t Wolves or Villa with their wealthy owners then “go for it”?
FFP is designed to stop clubs going bust by spending money that they haven’t got, and which their owners cannot cover. It should not be there to stop wealthy owners spending their own money, at their own risks. Add in a couple of safeguards as outlined above and a “light” FFP (which is already now known as Profit & Sustainability”, a far more appropriate name), would achieve its objectives.
The “big 6” wouldn’t like it but “screw them”. The Premier League is already broken as a true competition because of the ceiling on spending which is far lower than for the other 14 clubs.
Something has to change.


