My thoughts, both barrels.
#1
City scored with both of their only efforts on goal first half. The defending was beyond terrible, there isn't even just one error, both goals were a result of multiple mess ups. How much better off would we be if we didn't concede with almost every opposition attack? What to do? Endless defensive drills a la Pulis. Or better, a Hodgson approach where everyone knows both their's and everyone else's job. Not difficult but repetitive,monotonous training.

Much vaunted on here I notice, the ineffective attack. Two wingers either side of a small centre forward, wing backs that can't cross, Why so?  Last night was screaming out for something different, a lob over the top, some shooting on sight, running with the ball into the box. Mix it up! What to do? Some SKP style coaching. At least one day a week get a specialist forward coach in, get an understanding. Bloody Hell, play closer to each other, our forwards can barely see each other let alone play off a man. Set pieces, I won't go over that again it has been done to death by everyone except those able to do something about it.

That said, Matt Phillips buries that sitter 1st half, different game. Hitting the woodwork twice, the handball that VAR would have called a penalty. Small margins, and THAT is what well run clubs work on.

Regardless of squad limitations (and other than lacking a proper no.9), I'm not sure our squad is weak. Quite the opposite I'd say. Although mentally they aren't good we have enough to be much higher in the table. In the absence of proper leadership there is a malaise that crept in and it's taken over. The pea heartedness of many of our players needs to go or those players have to be exiled. We're paying them anyway so just let them go play with Ken in the corner. I saw no lack of effort last night, simply a lack of ideas, some of it down to having no confidence and some due to having no ideas. Again, this could be remedied with leadership, hard work and application. Beale can't do this overnight,  and no one can do it on their own. Our new boss needs to ascertain how much he will be backed to knock what we have into shape. There won't be any "He needs to get his own men in". He'll have to manage what he has and for that he needs the club to back him. No more repeats of the post covid slackness or the players downing tools because they don't like hard work, a player publicly happy with an opponents goal because they have been rightly dropped. Above all, The CEO assuming total responsibility for his appointments and explaining why he chose the new manager, how much he will back him, and why it will be the right choice. If that sounds difficult it is because it may well be, it is just the way people become successful, even in the often mad world of football. Rant over!
Reply
#2
Good read and doubt anyone would disagree.
Reply
#3
probably needed a hyphen in pea-heartedness, otherwise perfect.
Reply
#4
(10-19-2022, 07:37 PM)Tom Joad Wrote: City scored with both of their only efforts on goal first half. The defending was beyond terrible, there isn't even just one error, both goals were a result of multiple mess ups. How much better off would we be if we didn't concede with almost every opposition attack? What to do? Endless defensive drills a la Pulis. Or better, a Hodgson approach where everyone knows both their's and everyone else's job. Not difficult but repetitive,monotonous training.

Much vaunted on here I notice, the ineffective attack. Two wingers either side of a small centre forward, wing backs that can't cross, Why so?  Last night was screaming out for something different, a lob over the top, some shooting on sight, running with the ball into the box. Mix it up! What to do? Some SKP style coaching. At least one day a week get a specialist forward coach in, get an understanding. Bloody Hell, play closer to each other, our forwards can barely see each other let alone play off a man. Set pieces, I won't go over that again it has been done to death by everyone except those able to do something about it.

That said, Matt Phillips buries that sitter 1st half, different game. Hitting the woodwork twice, the handball that VAR would have called a penalty. Small margins, and THAT is what well run clubs work on.

Regardless of squad limitations (and other than lacking a proper no.9), I'm not sure our squad is weak. Quite the opposite I'd say. Although mentally they aren't good we have enough to be much higher in the table. In the absence of proper leadership there is a malaise that crept in and it's taken over. The pea heartedness of many of our players needs to go or those players have to be exiled. We're paying them anyway so just let them go play with Ken in the corner. I saw no lack of effort last night, simply a lack of ideas, some of it down to having no confidence and some due to having no ideas. Again, this could be remedied with leadership, hard work and application. Beale can't do this overnight,  and no one can do it on their own. Our new boss needs to ascertain how much he will be backed to knock what we have into shape. There won't be any "He needs to get his own men in". He'll have to manage what he has and for that he needs the club to back him. No more repeats of the post covid slackness or the players downing tools because they don't like hard work, a player publicly happy with an opponents goal because they have been rightly dropped. Above all, The CEO assuming total responsibility for his appointments and explaining why he chose the new manager, how much he will back him, and why it will be the right choice. If that sounds difficult it is because it may well be, it is just the way people become successful, even in the often mad world of football. Rant over!

That sort of training is exactly what we need.

The Championship has moved on from last year. Team's may lack quality, but they all tend to be well-coached.

Blues, Swansea, Luton and Bristol all knew their jobs and played as a team, regardless of differences in footballing style.
Reply
#5
(10-19-2022, 07:37 PM)Tom Joad Wrote: City scored with both of their only efforts on goal first half. The defending was beyond terrible, there isn't even just one error, both goals were a result of multiple mess ups. How much better off would we be if we didn't concede with almost every opposition attack? What to do? Endless defensive drills a la Pulis. Or better, a Hodgson approach where everyone knows both their's and everyone else's job. Not difficult but repetitive,monotonous training.

Much vaunted on here I notice, the ineffective attack. Two wingers either side of a small centre forward, wing backs that can't cross, Why so?  Last night was screaming out for something different, a lob over the top, some shooting on sight, running with the ball into the box. Mix it up! What to do? Some SKP style coaching. At least one day a week get a specialist forward coach in, get an understanding. Bloody Hell, play closer to each other, our forwards can barely see each other let alone play off a man. Set pieces, I won't go over that again it has been done to death by everyone except those able to do something about it.

That said, Matt Phillips buries that sitter 1st half, different game. Hitting the woodwork twice, the handball that VAR would have called a penalty. Small margins, and THAT is what well run clubs work on.

Regardless of squad limitations (and other than lacking a proper no.9), I'm not sure our squad is weak. Quite the opposite I'd say. Although mentally they aren't good we have enough to be much higher in the table. In the absence of proper leadership there is a malaise that crept in and it's taken over. The pea heartedness of many of our players needs to go or those players have to be exiled. We're paying them anyway so just let them go play with Ken in the corner. I saw no lack of effort last night, simply a lack of ideas, some of it down to having no confidence and some due to having no ideas. Again, this could be remedied with leadership, hard work and application. Beale can't do this overnight,  and no one can do it on their own. Our new boss needs to ascertain how much he will be backed to knock what we have into shape. There won't be any "He needs to get his own men in". He'll have to manage what he has and for that he needs the club to back him. No more repeats of the post covid slackness or the players downing tools because they don't like hard work, a player publicly happy with an opponents goal because they have been rightly dropped. Above all, The CEO assuming total responsibility for his appointments and explaining why he chose the new manager, how much he will back him, and why it will be the right choice. If that sounds difficult it is because it may well be, it is just the way people become successful, even in the often mad world of football. Rant over!

We have no settled formation or team at the moment with many who should be in the team not.  It's a shambles.  

Hopefully our new manager will have a clear formation and gradually get our best team out there, It'll be post world cup however before we see any improvement.  It's definitely a massive positive that a new Manager will have a month to work on fitness, shape and tactics.  

Hopefully the new man will also have the opportunity to bring in a couple of new faces.  

As we're currently 3 points from safety (with teams below us having games in hand) the first priority this season is to stay in the division and set the foundations for next season.
Reply
#6
That's right, Squid, I was particularly impressed with Blues. No stars, no players better than ours, but an organisation that saw us off. Journeyman footballer turned manager, doing a great job with a basketcase club.
Reply
#7
After last night’s non-performance, it made me think - for the first time - that relegation is a real possibility
Reply
#8
We have no idea how to win ugly in this division, there ae no leades, nobody giving bollockings to their team mates, no over my dead body defending

All drilled into us by Bruce's casual approach to training, exactly why a Dyche is exactly the manager we need

So many of these cunts on easy street, drives me insane, in my day, as captain as I was, you would have half of them around the throat for going through the motions, makes your blood boil

Cuzer
Fisheatingdeludedsealwankers
Reply
#9
(10-19-2022, 09:47 PM)Cuzer Wrote: We have no idea how to win ugly in this division, there ae no leades, nobody giving bollockings to their team mates, no over my dead body defending

All drilled into us by Bruce's casual approach to training, exactly why a Dyche is exactly the manager we need

Many would regard Allardyce as being similar to Dyche and he continues to receive praise from some for having identified the wasters, yet he ended up with the 3rd worst win percentage of all Albion's permanent managers. This suggests that the problem isn't straightforward for anyone to sort out, whether they're very experienced or not. However, as I mentioned earlier, we spent nearly two-thirds of last season in at least a play-off position so, agreeing with Tom's original post, I don't think things are completely without hope.

For me, I'd rather have a manager who wants us to play on the front foot and exploit the creativity of players like Wallace, Diangana, Swift and Rogic. We were good at defending at the start of last season when we had a style of play and a plan, but Bruce decimated all of that and we're currently weakened in the back line because of it. Consequently, playing defensively might not be a great idea and I think we'll have more success if we're seeking to give the opposition something to worry about.
Reply
#10
I think you've got to think of the division Fat Sam was in Worcs and what was at his disposal, it didn't take him long to bin the likes of Jake, Grant, Phillips etc and bring in Okay, AMN etc

I was no Sam fan and I agree more long term would be a better appointment, Jake is gone in the summer, as is Bartley, maybe now most of us have thought this season is now all about staying up we can think a bit long term. I'm not sure Ron has a clue what he wants personally

Cuzer
Fisheatingdeludedsealwankers
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)