Tonight’s ratings
#21
(02-22-2022, 10:59 PM)clem4england Wrote:
(02-22-2022, 10:56 PM)Everything Zin Wrote: Grant a big fat zero for me. He spent the whole game in hiding, presumably in the basis that if he never got the ball, he couldn’t fuck anything up. Others were poor but at least they tried.
Karlan Grant is pound for pound the worst signing by the club ever. He is utter garbage - no pace, weak as piss, crap in the air, can't hold it up, poor finisher apart from his one trick. And to think we can enjoy him for another four years. I'd be trying to get rid of him for anything over £2m.

Zohore beats him by miles for that accolade. Half the price, but not even half the goals.
Reply
#22
(02-22-2022, 10:43 PM)Mish Wrote: Astonished how Reach and Tulloch get a 6, but it's all onions I guess.

Reach actually pressed well as the higher midfielder, and put a shift in first half.

However - fair to say he was technically poor though so I’ll revise to a 4.
Reply
#23
Johnstone 6 MOTM (as he was the only one who wasn’t garbage)

Townsend 2 Worst display of a distinctly poor season
Bartley 4 Doesn’t look over his illness but better than the weekend
Ajayi 4 Physicality almost compensates for the fact he’s thick as shit on the field
O’Shea 4 Should be lower but bonus point for being first game back and him getting no support from dugout

Mowatt 3 Passing is wasted in the hole, and he doesn’t offer much else without a high press
Molumby 5 One of his better games - says it all
Reach 3 15 min spell in first half where he was turning the ball over and running, 75 minutes where he was shit

Grant 0 The worst forward display I’ve seen in years
Carroll 6 Probably MOTM but I forgot about him when I gave it to Johnstone and much like our players, I can’t be arsed to track back, and much like our manager I can’t be arsed to change it
Grady 5 Best work was done defensively

Not going to lie, can’t rate subs as I’d turned it off at 2-1 so didn’t see them.
Reply
#24
(02-22-2022, 10:43 PM)Mish Wrote: Astonished how Reach and Tulloch get a 6, but it's all onions I guess.

Me too. Reach was bloody awful first half especially.
Reply
#25
(02-23-2022, 08:58 AM)MassDebater Wrote:
(02-22-2022, 10:59 PM)clem4england Wrote:
(02-22-2022, 10:56 PM)Everything Zin Wrote: Grant a big fat zero for me. He spent the whole game in hiding, presumably in the basis that if he never got the ball, he couldn’t fuck anything up. Others were poor but at least they tried.
Karlan Grant is pound for pound the worst signing by the club ever. He is utter garbage - no pace, weak as piss, crap in the air, can't hold it up, poor finisher apart from his one trick. And to think we can enjoy him for another four years. I'd be trying to get rid of him for anything over £2m.

Zohore beats him by miles for that accolade. Half the price, but not even half the goals.
Burke, Anichebe, Snodgrass 

They highlight how poor (and thoughtless) our recruitment has been for many years
Reply
#26
(02-22-2022, 10:45 PM)Cunninghamismagic Wrote: SJ 5
O’Shea 4
Ajayi 5
Bartley 5
Townsend 2
Mowatt 3
Reach 2
Molumby 6
Grady 6
Grant 1
Carroll 6

Tulloch 4
Robbo 4
Furlong 5
I'd give Dara a 5 or 6, but other than that, agree CIM.

It's unlikely that you're ever going to win games if no one is 7 or above, and so many are 5 and lower. Individual players need to take accountability for their own performances. They're allegedly professional footballers on big money. They need to earn that money. That said Reach & Grant should not be starting for the foreseeable future, as they've both done absolutely nothing in Bruce's first four games.
Reply
#27
I am beginning to hate ratings threads.

They are increasingly being used to over criticise individual players. 

Football is and always will be a team game. There is always a belief that if a particular player wasn't picked everything would be rosey in the world. Doubt that's ever the case, but it's particularly true with us right now.

What I would say is that I don't think Bruce is deploying his midfielders effectively 
Mowatt is too deep, think he would be better playing the role Reach is currently playing. Molumby might be better suited to the holding midfield role, which would better suit his ability.
Reply
#28
And yet there will be moaning aplenty when Livermore is first name on the teamsheet again.
Reply
#29
(02-22-2022, 10:59 PM)clem4england Wrote:
(02-22-2022, 10:56 PM)Everything Zin Wrote: Grant a big fat zero for me. He spent the whole game in hiding, presumably in the basis that if he never got the ball, he couldn’t fuck anything up. Others were poor but at least they tried.
Karlan Grant is pound for pound the worst signing by the club ever. He is utter garbage - no pace, weak as piss, crap in the air, can't hold it up, poor finisher apart from his one trick. And to think we can enjoy him for another four years. I'd be trying to get rid of him for anything over £2m.

Ismael got the best out of him. 10 goals
Reply
#30
For me only 4 players came out of this game with any credit. Johnstone nothing to do Molumby worked hard and scored Grady who at least tried things and did one great piece of Defending. Carroll he has been very impressive since joining. Will also give O’Shea some slack as he’s yet to be match fit. The rest can borrow Barry’s Taxi except don’t come back unless there attitude changes. Told you I can’t stick up for this rabble of shit anymore
It could be fun on Monday if we lose again.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: