Posts: 5,322
Threads: 356
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
16
In the light of Watford sacking yet another manager, is it a fair question to ask.
Whoever manages Watford they always seem the same, strong in the Championship, struggling in the premiership.
Same with Chelsea they change managers constantly, but they also win trophies constantly.
Even us. In the last 20 years we have had, I think, 14 managers/head coaches, and in that time, our highest finish was 8th in the premiership and 4th in the championship,, not a huge spread.And it's easy to pick out our weakest managers in that time. Mel, Irvine and Pardew, but they managed exclusively in the premiership, maybe they would have had more success in the championship.
I'm sure who the manager is, makes some difference, but how much I am far from sure.
Posts: 13,017
Threads: 1,260
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
6
10-05-2021, 07:12 AM
(This post was last modified: 10-05-2021, 07:14 AM by Cunninghamismagic.)
Massive difference. Compare us from Howe to Giles. Gould to Ardiles. From Little to Megson.
Posts: 27,984
Threads: 1,168
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
64
Of course managers make a difference. Just look at the way Ferguson turned United into one of the biggest forces in world football, and then how much they’ve struggled since he retired. Ditto for Wenger at Arsenal.
Posts: 2,953
Threads: 67
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
12
Good question, one I've pondered.
Obviously some, at the extremes I think, do make a difference. Ferguson at Man U stands out.
But I believe that there are plenty of managers in the lower leagues who could, for instance, manage the current Man City squad to titles.
It's not tricky, it's about encouraging, supporting, bollocking if necessary young men with little life experience. Invariably the tactics are discussed and sorted with experienced coaching staff who've been round the lower leagues, recruitment are others' choices (probably shouldn't be), so the manager at the highest levels is often a "name" - who has the players' respect. A useful but not essential attribute I think. (Ferguson was only a moderate player).
A successful league 1 or 2 manager could succeed anywhere as well as the big names.
But could pep do it at Brighton. Or Scunthorpe?
Posts: 3,652
Threads: 119
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
7
10-05-2021, 08:38 AM
(This post was last modified: 10-05-2021, 08:39 AM by MGalea.)
In the traditional structure - all of the difference - they literally choose the players to sign, how they train and what the style is.
In the modern day perhaps a bit less - especially if the club has a style they want to carry through - however even so if the manager is terrible there's no chance - look at Tony Adams at Grananda!
Posts: 3,848
Threads: 97
Joined: Feb 2019
Reputation:
7
A chair could manage teams like Chelsea and Man City to a top 6 finish
Posts: 4,258
Threads: 263
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
25
(10-05-2021, 07:01 AM)Shabby Russian Wrote: In the light of Watford sacking yet another manager, is it a fair question to ask.
Whoever manages Watford they always seem the same, strong in the Championship, struggling in the premiership.
Same with Chelsea they change managers constantly, but they also win trophies constantly.
Even us. In the last 20 years we have had, I think, 14 managers/head coaches, and in that time, our highest finish was 8th in the premiership and 4th in the championship,, not a huge spread.And it's easy to pick out our weakest managers in that time. Mel, Irvine and Pardew, but they managed exclusively in the premiership, maybe they would have had more success in the championship.
I'm sure who the manager is, makes some difference, but how much I am far from sure.
Harsh to lump Irvine in with those two clowns. Mel, Pardew and Allardyce are below 20% win rate, Irvine's in the 20 - 25% range along with Bryan Robson and (going back a bit further) Saunders and Ronnie Allen (2nd spell). Note that Brian Talbot and Tony Pulis also fell short of the 30%, which for me is the threshold of respectability.
Posts: 19,492
Threads: 824
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
60
I think it depends entirely on the level of manager you’re employing and the structure of the club.
There are a lot of managers out there who are much of a muchness, and will do the same standard job for 12-18 months before it goes sour. Being honest, there’s probably very little difference between these guys and in this case, a 7/10 manager with a middle of the road budget will probably do a mid table job. These are your Steve Bruces… or people like Jokanovic, Marco Silva, Gary Rowett, Dean Smith etc etc, and being honest; there’s probably little difference between employing one of these and your final result, other thwb style of play. It’s why most managers seem to hover around a 35-40% win record.
Meanwhile there are genuinely excellent managers out there who improve teams and clubs singlehandedly, but they are few and far between, and tend to end up in big jobs pretty quickly… with more clubs than decent managers that’s why the club structure, DoF, analyst, recruitment teams, academy structure, CEO, and overall culture has become more and more important as this can boost and compensate for an average manager.
I think much like Serie A, we’re now heading into a spell where DoFs will move for bigger and bigger money, and will become just as crucial an appointment as the manager.
Posts: 7,371
Threads: 181
Joined: Jul 2020
Reputation:
27
Very few 'managers' around now. First Team Coach or Head Coach is what they are, and they can only do so much, dependent on time given and how good the DofF is at recruiting. Old style managers could influence a club far more as they did the recruiting, scouting, contracts, training. Now its just as much about the office staff as the coach.
Posts: 13,407
Threads: 402
Joined: Jul 2019
Reputation:
14
Good question. Chelsea, spunk millions and still don't always win stuff, so is that down to the manager? Or the outgoing players, or even the recruitment department?
A good manager can get lower quality players punching above their weight for a while, and then can add the quality that is needed to improve them long term. Even a poor manager can give that new manager bounce though that then vanishes.
However, it's a much larger back room team rather than the traditional manager though, although he and his assistant(s) always carry the can.
|