Posts: 10,859
Threads: 497
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
23
Both my girls schools down here in Poole have been great and I'm certain teachers have worked extremely hard adapting everything to online lessons etc but if anyone thinks that the kids just switch it on and work as normal then they are blinking mad!
Learning in a home environment, without seeing friends for months and trying to remain focused is impossible. They have gone stir crazy as have we as parents. My wife still works a few days and I'm flexi furloughed and we take it seriously but my youngest has some real learning delays and it's been a bloody nightmare for us.
I think the work they have been set is fine but the level of learning, and their absorption of it, is only 30% of what they would get in a classroom environment imo.
Posts: 15,277
Threads: 273
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
57
My son is devastated to be fair. He left school fir Christmas holidays, and will probably go back to a different school by the time restrictions are eased, meaning he won't see his friends before he leaves.
His teachers have been great tbf, set him work to do, but they've made it clear, there is no point causing trouble at home for the sake of school work. They're in year 4, plenty of time to catch up.
Posts: 5,201
Threads: 197
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
14
Topman/Sol
Question
Our daughter (ironically goes to school in Solihull) and we've had a right battle with home learning via Teams. I fully appreciate the teachers must be at their wits end at times, as are the parents mind, biggest head scratcher for me is why aren't teachers enforcing the pupils to turn their cameras on at all times in lessons? Our daughter with her camera off just doesn't engage anything like enough with the lesson which is badly affecting her education. We've tried all sorts and now we're enforcing she has the camera on but this should be coming from the teachers, not the parents. Once on she's way more focused on the class because she has to be, massive trick missed for me and took weeks before a communication from the school came out and even then it was "requesting" children turn on their cameras
Cuzer
Fisheatingdeludedsealwankers
Posts: 158
Threads: 2
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
0
My daughters really want to be back at school.
My eldest (in year 6) finds it easy and manages her time well. My youngest (in year 3) needs to be in a classroom setting. It sometimes takes her more time to get started on a piece of work, than it does to do the actual work.
Pre-recorded and live Teams lessons seemed to have helped. It's certainly taken some of the pressure off me.
There was a parents' revolt at the start of this lockdown as the school were just going to keep sending PDFs every day, which they did in the first lockdown, and have no provision for video lessons (because some of the teachers didn't want to do it).
Having said that, they have really stepped up since introducing video lessons.
Because my daughters spend 50% time with me and 50% with their mum, we've set up a Trello project planning board so we can make sure daily and weekly assignments are being done.
Posts: 287
Threads: 17
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
2
(02-18-2021, 02:36 PM)Solihull Throstle Wrote: With respect, all significant data for schools is pre-Christmas and, therefore, pre new variants. These are far more tranmissable and kids (especially teens) seem to be strong vectors.
By the nature of the job teachers, and all other school staff, are likely to be exposed far more to the virus than those in other jobs.
Before Christmas I was regularly teaching over 100 different kids a day, in fairly confined rooms with no masks being worn.
I'm not sure that the desire to protect oneself and family could really be classed as "incessant whinging"!
I was being a little facetious there, apologies. However, I'm not entirely sure why a 35 year old teacher should get vaccinated say, before my mum, in her 60s. You probably also touched a nerve by saying that we can just sit our little darlings in front of the computer and let them get on with it. My son, in year 5, has 15 minutes of Teams per day. I probably spend 2-3 hours per day with him... on top of my day job (which probably involves 10 hours per day, all of which are spent on a computer/Teams).
I sympathise with you, I really do and the teachers are doing a stellar job balancing online prep/working with being in school supporting those children physically in school but this is difficult for all of us and teachers are by no means the worst off.
Posts: 1,211
Threads: 119
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
3
(02-18-2021, 04:22 PM)Cuzer Wrote: Topman/Sol
Question
Our daughter (ironically goes to school in Solihull) and we've had a right battle with home learning via Teams. I fully appreciate the teachers must be at their wits end at times, as are the parents mind, biggest head scratcher for me is why aren't teachers enforcing the pupils to turn their cameras on at all times in lessons? Our daughter with her camera off just doesn't engage anything like enough with the lesson which is badly affecting her education. We've tried all sorts and now we're enforcing she has the camera on but this should be coming from the teachers, not the parents. Once on she's way more focused on the class because she has to be, massive trick missed for me and took weeks before a communication from the school came out and even then it was "requesting" children turn on their cameras
Cuzer
There are safeguarding issues as well as practicalities.
On pure practicalities it would be tricky to monitor 20+ video screens at once, for a start. Even if they are sat there it's no definite indicator that they are really engaging.
I use live audio, share powerpoints and as lots of questions of individuals, as I would in class. They usually then work through tasks I've posted on the Showbie platform, whilst I keep the audio open and real with any questions / chip in with help.
They tend to insert images of their work when completed for me to view / mark.
There are also potential risks of asking the kids to have their cameras on if working in bedrooms / in house alone etc which may not be obvious. Teachers do need to protect themselves against potential allegations that might rarely occur.
Occasionally I do put my video on to say hello to them.....I have a cute dog they like to see and an elephant and dragon head I sometimes surprise them with!
Posts: 1,211
Threads: 119
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
3
(02-18-2021, 04:42 PM)waffle Wrote: (02-18-2021, 02:36 PM)Solihull Throstle Wrote: With respect, all significant data for schools is pre-Christmas and, therefore, pre new variants. These are far more tranmissable and kids (especially teens) seem to be strong vectors.
By the nature of the job teachers, and all other school staff, are likely to be exposed far more to the virus than those in other jobs.
Before Christmas I was regularly teaching over 100 different kids a day, in fairly confined rooms with no masks being worn.
I'm not sure that the desire to protect oneself and family could really be classed as "incessant whinging"!
I was being a little facetious there, apologies. However, I'm not entirely sure why a 35 year old teacher should get vaccinated say, before my mum, in her 60s. You probably also touched a nerve by saying that we can just sit our little darlings in front of the computer and let them get on with it. My son, in year 5, has 15 minutes of Teams per day. I probably spend 2-3 hours per day with him... on top of my day job (which probably involves 10 hours per day, all of which are spent on a computer/Teams).
I sympathise with you, I really do and the teachers are doing a stellar job balancing online prep/working with being in school supporting those children physically in school but this is difficult for all of us and teachers are by no means the worst off.
And I was being a little facetious with my "sit them down and off they go"! 
I think it's certainly easier in secondary than primary.
I'm lucky that I teach relatively small classes of relatively motivated kids. I know it's not easy for parents but just wanted to dispel a common myth that parents are doing all of the teaching. Again, it might be very different in other schools, especially in primary education.
I'm certainly pleased my kids are way past school age in these times!
Posts: 11,311
Threads: 419
Joined: Feb 2020
Reputation:
18
I know none of you take any notice of the government, but they have stated they will be rolling out mass testing for children and parents.
Posts: 251
Threads: 10
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
3
02-18-2021, 05:44 PM
(This post was last modified: 02-18-2021, 05:45 PM by steviedm.)
I teach at a sixth form college and from December 10th we moved to teaching lessons online to give students a clear two weeks to self-isolate if necessary so they could be with extended family/friends at Christmas. We've obviously continued with this ever since so it means adapting all lessons (and when I say adapting, I mean spending hours and hours rewriting everything so it can be taught online) and then delivering these lessons as we would in the 'real' world.
We have two hour lessons and it's been a massive struggle to get students to complete work - they'll turn up but that's about it. While I can't blame them (no matter how much we tell second years it's important they continue to engage fully as we don't yet know how we will determine their grades, they're hardly going to be chomping at the bit when they know external exams aren't happening), it does make life difficult all round and I have absolutely hated every second of this lockdown and can't wait for it to end.
As far as I'm concerned, the lockdowns have shown how important face-to-face teaching is and how online teaching is a completely inadequate substitution for so many reasons. The amount of work it takes is insane and I just don't think those who are not involved in preparation and delivery of online teaching have any idea about the level of work and stress involved. I also have no idea about work levels and stress in so many other occupations. The difference is I don't go around offering my uninformed views on things I know nothing about while plenty of people are prepared to do that when it comes to education.
Posts: 1,211
Threads: 119
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
3
02-18-2021, 06:12 PM
(This post was last modified: 02-18-2021, 06:16 PM by Solihull Throstle.)
(02-18-2021, 05:32 PM)Protheroe Wrote: I know none of you take any notice of the government, but they have stated they will be rolling out mass testing for children and parents.
Clearly, you didn't take any notice of my earlier post when I mentioned it.
I have concerns that the testing won't be done in many homes for a multitude of reasons.
I also understand that it would not be logistically possible in schools, after an initial test on return.
(02-18-2021, 05:44 PM)steviedm Wrote: I teach at a sixth form college and from December 10th we moved to teaching lessons online to give students a clear two weeks to self-isolate if necessary so they could be with extended family/friends at Christmas. We've obviously continued with this ever since so it means adapting all lessons (and when I say adapting, I mean spending hours and hours rewriting everything so it can be taught online) and then delivering these lessons as we would in the 'real' world.
We have two hour lessons and it's been a massive struggle to get students to complete work - they'll turn up but that's about it. While I can't blame them (no matter how much we tell second years it's important they continue to engage fully as we don't yet know how we will determine their grades, they're hardly going to be chomping at the bit when they know external exams aren't happening), it does make life difficult all round and I have absolutely hated every second of this lockdown and can't wait for it to end.
As far as I'm concerned, the lockdowns have shown how important face-to-face teaching is and how online teaching is a completely inadequate substitution for so many reasons. The amount of work it takes is insane and I just don't think those who are not involved in preparation and delivery of online teaching have any idea about the level of work and stress involved. I also have no idea about work levels and stress in so many other occupations. The difference is I don't go around offering my uninformed views on things I know nothing about while plenty of people are prepared to do that when it comes to education.
But surely you have very limited 'secure' data on this cohort so they know that internal assessments, under exam conditions, when they return will be vital in determining grades.
That's certainly the approach we are taking with our 11s and 13s.
|