Posts: 994
Threads: 36
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
3
10-30-2020, 12:57 PM
(This post was last modified: 10-30-2020, 01:00 PM by baggiebuckster.)
How many Covid deaths are included that mirror this situation?
It sounds like people are tested after they die. Why would you do that? Or they included the earlier test that was since superseded by the negative test? Either way it appears to be looking for statistics to me.
https://www.bbc.com/news/uk-northern-ire...t-54731262
(10-30-2020, 12:52 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: (10-30-2020, 10:55 AM)billybassett Wrote: England and Wales total mortality from ONS online: https://www.ons.gov.uk/peoplepopulationa...ndandwales
7 weeks from Start Sep to w/c 18 Oct.
Total mortality 2020 7739, 9811, 9523, 9634, 9945, 9954, 10534: 67140
Total mortality 2019 9795, 9513, 9440, 9517, 9799, 9973, 10156: 68093
Show me the excess deaths
No excess deaths total mortality the same.
(10-29-2020, 08:44 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: (10-29-2020, 06:15 PM)billybassett Wrote: (10-29-2020, 09:30 AM)baggy1 Wrote: Would it be easier if we all said we agreed with you?
Typical vacuous snidey remark Dekka. Well done bet you got off on that. Although this is a more sensible post than the usual.
Let’s rewind this discussion to where it began with you wanting to ‘go back to normal’. A more vacuous proposition given the circumstances you won’t find. I discussed your opinion with you politely but you have become more like a missionary expounding your ‘truth’ to everyone and setting yourself up as more enlightened. Now your suggesting that others are having a dig at you when you’ve questioned people’s intelligence, ability to make informed decisions, complicity with the governments handling of the situation etc. You have your opinions but don’t state them as the truth that others who are less enlightened cannot see.
I do want to go back to normal. We are living in a normal respiratory season. If you can't see that then fair enough.
I'm not trying to convince you anymore Dekka you're locked in. And yes if I have to say it you've yet to provide any enlightened view here. I respect baggy1 for his assiduousness in reading and presenting information and supposition and opinion. I disagree with much but not all. When you're able to do the same rather than posting from Boris' BBC feed I will reassess my respect for you.
As for a missionary I quite like that - but without the religious connotation because you would really have me as a lunatic if you thought I believed in that shit. But yes a missionary dropped into a savage wasteland treating their ills mental and physical. Thanks I'll use it as my signature
Posts: 1,403
Threads: 12
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
4
(10-30-2020, 12:44 PM)billybassett Wrote: I'm not denying it's had some impact. But if the lockdown Mar-Jun was actually a method of combatting transmission why are we seeing it now. Point is it's respiratory and transmission will not go away because people hide. It will go away when the virus has no more hosts to infect and it will die of and become endemic. So hiding again will just kick the can down the road.
In terms of an impact by a respiratory illness it's actually more likely to impact more severely people locked up in warm houses over autumn and winter - has an especially difficult impact on the old because they become less mobile and sit more. This is common of all respiratory illnesses. The last thing we should be doing is staying in confined warm spaces with diminished airflow. Go outside enjoy yourself, catch covid, keep moving, eat well take precautions like every winter.
I'm not trying to say the virus isn't something we shouldn't be careful of or protect the vulnerable etc.
Hospital admissions increase this time of year full stop and ICUs are built to run at 90% capacity because there's few facilities and ill people get to use them. I'm also not saying that there may not be more this winter. But if you're drawing correlation directly between covid and admissions and ICU beds then I'm not comfortable with that. With the way the PCR tests are the 28d lag, other illnesses now being caught late because nobody went in summer etc...
To conflate all of those issues into lets lock everybody down to protect the nhs is in my opinion a poor decision and will undoubtedly leave us over Christmas and Spring in similar situations because if you make decision now on the basis of these types of correlations now all you are doing is delaying the inevitable further lockdowns later because unfortunately people have completely lost perspective on what this is.
(10-30-2020, 12:34 PM)baggy1 Wrote: Again stop with the population figures they are an estimate based on the 2011 census increased each year, they are not exact so using them to make exact statements is just daft. It's simple, we've had a period of time where excess deaths have been negligible (as strawman says in very different conditions), hospitalisations are increasing week on week in a uniform manner, excess deaths have started to creep up again (even with a two week lag on figures), and we are heading into winter.
Covid exists whether you like it or not, whether it impacts on your life or not, it exists. It also has a higher mortality rate than any other virus that we have encountered in a century, and it is on the rise again - I'm not measuring cases, I'm measuring people in hospital (something that even you can't dispute with any actual figures)
You mention 2009 and 1968 - what were the actual deaths in those years (I'd ignore 1968 if I were you because the population, healthcare, demographics aren't comparable but seeing as you mentioned them it's up to you)
I see no reason to use population figures as estimate. They are no doubt an under estimate for many reasons. In the same period you say is different influenza and other non-covid respiratory deaths have disappeared. Also it's a clear indicator that wearing masks and over sanitising has no affect. It's also clear that lockdowns now have zero affect. You only have to look at boroughs who've effectively been locked down for weeks on end to see "covid cases" not diminishing.
The 1968 flu pandemic saw an estimated 1m deaths around the world : https://www.cdc.gov/flu/pandemic-resourc...demic.html. I haven't got a second source yet for the uk. A much higher impact in population terms and the H3N2 seasonal virus has many covid similarities.
It’s not, there is no way of combatting transmission. As long as one person has the virus and unless enough people build up an immunity so they don’t become spreaders. A vaccine may help with that but flu vaccines are only so effective (40-60% I believe) and even less in those with weaker immune systems.
So the lockdowns are to prevent even more hospitalisations and deaths and as you correctly say, once they are eased, then cases will increase again and round and round we go.
Maybe we could have covid parties with all the under 45’s (those least at risk) attempting to catch it like they used to have measles and chickenpox parties. (That's a joke BTW)
Not sure what the alternatives are because if we just go back to normal then there will be many deaths amongst those most at risk. We could ask those at risk to shield, but for how long? What if there is never a vaccine? Do you want them to shield indefinitely. I suspect if you asked that then people with a limited time to live anyway, would just say ‘bollox to that, I’ll take my chances’ the hospitals would be flooded and those with other diseases would still not get treatment.
And you can call it what you want, covid, flu, sorearseitis - the bottom line is there is a virus that is making people ill enough to require hospital treatment, ventilation and causing deaths
I’m afraid it’s going to be a long time before there is any exit from this.
Posts: 1,058
Threads: 51
Joined: Feb 2020
Reputation:
3
(10-30-2020, 12:52 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: billybassett
(10-29-2020, 06:15 PM)billybassett Wrote: Typical vacuous snidey remark Dekka. Well done bet you got off on that. Although this is a more sensible post than the usual.
Now your suggesting that others are having a dig at you when you’ve questioned people’s intelligence, ability to make informed decisions, complicity with the governments handling of the situation etc. You have your opinions but don’t state them as the truth that others who are less enlightened cannot see.
That's a bit hypocritical.
" Exactly and the forelock tugging, cerebrally challenged working class Tories".
https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/showthread.php?tid=13451&page=5
Posts: 8,954
Threads: 166
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
77
Any opinions on how we move forward with Covid JOK?
Posts: 17,074
Threads: 614
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
114
10-30-2020, 01:59 PM
(This post was last modified: 10-30-2020, 02:12 PM by Derek Hardballs.)
(10-30-2020, 01:00 PM)billybassett Wrote: (10-30-2020, 12:52 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: (10-30-2020, 10:55 AM)billybassett Wrote: England and Wales total mortality from ONS online: https://www.ons.gov.uk/peoplepopulationa...ndandwales
7 weeks from Start Sep to w/c 18 Oct.
Total mortality 2020 7739, 9811, 9523, 9634, 9945, 9954, 10534: 67140
Total mortality 2019 9795, 9513, 9440, 9517, 9799, 9973, 10156: 68093
Show me the excess deaths
No excess deaths total mortality the same.
(10-29-2020, 08:44 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: (10-29-2020, 06:15 PM)billybassett Wrote: Typical vacuous snidey remark Dekka. Well done bet you got off on that. Although this is a more sensible post than the usual.
Let’s rewind this discussion to where it began with you wanting to ‘go back to normal’. A more vacuous proposition given the circumstances you won’t find. I discussed your opinion with you politely but you have become more like a missionary expounding your ‘truth’ to everyone and setting yourself up as more enlightened. Now your suggesting that others are having a dig at you when you’ve questioned people’s intelligence, ability to make informed decisions, complicity with the governments handling of the situation etc. You have your opinions but don’t state them as the truth that others who are less enlightened cannot see.
I do want to go back to normal. We are living in a normal respiratory season. If you can't see that then fair enough.
I'm not trying to convince you anymore Dekka you're locked in. And yes if I have to say it you've yet to provide any enlightened view here. I respect baggy1 for his assiduousness in reading and presenting information and supposition and opinion. I disagree with much but not all. When you're able to do the same rather than posting from Boris' BBC feed I will reassess my respect for you.
As for a missionary I quite like that - but without the religious connotation because you would really have me as a lunatic if you thought I believed in that shit. But yes a missionary dropped into a savage wasteland treating their ills mental and physical. Thanks I'll use it as my signature
Missionaries spoke of fairytales dressed up as the unequivocal truth... your welcome.
A few points...
normal is not fixed and changes with circumstances. So your hankering after a normal that whether you like it or not has changed for the foreseeable future is a false premise.
I have linked to ONS figures and local public health figures and a couple of articles from MSM but even then they are stating figures from medical and scientific sources from respected experts. You may not like them as they don’t fit into your beliefs, that doesn’t make them wrong. If you search hard enough you can find stats and experts that will back up your argument no matter how skewed it is.
Posts: 17,074
Threads: 614
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
114
10-30-2020, 02:03 PM
(This post was last modified: 10-30-2020, 02:07 PM by Derek Hardballs.)
(10-30-2020, 01:21 PM)JOK Wrote: (10-30-2020, 12:52 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: billybassett
(10-29-2020, 06:15 PM)billybassett Wrote: Typical vacuous snidey remark Dekka. Well done bet you got off on that. Although this is a more sensible post than the usual.
Now your suggesting that others are having a dig at you when you’ve questioned people’s intelligence, ability to make informed decisions, complicity with the governments handling of the situation etc. You have your opinions but don’t state them as the truth that others who are less enlightened cannot see.
That's a bit hypocritical.
"Exactly and the forelock tugging, cerebrally challenged working class Tories".
https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/showthread.php?tid=13451&page=5
No it’s not I never said I wasn’t having a go back or that I don’t think I’m right with regards to this government and working class Tories (I may have gone fishing I admit  )  Others are free to disagree.
(10-30-2020, 01:07 PM)strawman Wrote: (10-30-2020, 12:44 PM)billybassett Wrote:
I see no reason to use population figures as estimate. They are no doubt an under estimate for many reasons. In the same period you say is different influenza and other non-covid respiratory deaths have disappeared. Also it's a clear indicator that wearing masks and over sanitising has no affect. It's also clear that lockdowns now have zero affect. You only have to look at boroughs who've effectively been locked down for weeks on end to see "covid cases" not diminishing.
The 1968 flu pandemic saw an estimated 1m deaths around the world : https://www.cdc.gov/flu/pandemic-resourc...demic.html. I haven't got a second source yet for the uk. A much higher impact in population terms and the H3N2 seasonal virus has many covid similarities.
It’s not, there is no way of combatting transmission. As long as one person has the virus and unless enough people build up an immunity so they don’t become spreaders. A vaccine may help with that but flu vaccines are only so effective (40-60% I believe) and even less in those with weaker immune systems.
So the lockdowns are to prevent even more hospitalisations and deaths and as you correctly say, once they are eased, then cases will increase again and round and round we go.
Maybe we could have covid parties with all the under 45’s (those least at risk) attempting to catch it like they used to have measles and chickenpox parties. (That's a joke BTW)
Not sure what the alternatives are because if we just go back to normal then there will be many deaths amongst those most at risk. We could ask those at risk to shield, but for how long? What if there is never a vaccine? Do you want them to shield indefinitely. I suspect if you asked that then people with a limited time to live anyway, would just say ‘bollox to that, I’ll take my chances’ the hospitals would be flooded and those with other diseases would still not get treatment.
And you can call it what you want, covid, flu, sorearseitis - the bottom line is there is a virus that is making people ill enough to require hospital treatment, ventilation and causing deaths
I’m afraid it’s going to be a long time before there is any exit from this.
[/quote]
Don't disagree and without entering into hyperbole it's going to be 10 years or more. Those people dying who've not had treatment, effect on businesses, jobs, economy, health and education. It's an unimaginable cost way out of proportion in my opinion and deeply/unfairly loaded onto the least well off, the less well educated, the young and the infirm.
Those most at risk should live their lives as they would in any seasonal flu period. You take precautions. Your family and friends help you. If a vaccine comes a long take it - it may help it may well not. Take responsibility for your own health.
Those not at risk at all. Get on with your lives and help reduce any future impact. Don't demand a test don't take a vaccine. Take responsibility for your own health and that of others where you can.
I know this is supposedly heretical because what gets thrown back is you're just letting the weak and old die. My response to that is you've done that for the past 50 years of seasonal respiratory viruses.
Posts: 17,074
Threads: 614
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
114
(10-30-2020, 02:07 PM)billybassett Wrote: (10-30-2020, 01:07 PM)strawman Wrote: I see no reason to use population figures as estimate. They are no doubt an under estimate for many reasons. In the same period you say is different influenza and other non-covid respiratory deaths have disappeared. Also it's a clear indicator that wearing masks and over sanitising has no affect. It's also clear that lockdowns now have zero affect. You only have to look at boroughs who've effectively been locked down for weeks on end to see "covid cases" not diminishing.
The 1968 flu pandemic saw an estimated 1m deaths around the world : https://www.cdc.gov/flu/pandemic-resourc...demic.html. I haven't got a second source yet for the uk. A much higher impact in population terms and the H3N2 seasonal virus has many covid similarities.
It’s not, there is no way of combatting transmission. As long as one person has the virus and unless enough people build up an immunity so they don’t become spreaders. A vaccine may help with that but flu vaccines are only so effective (40-60% I believe) and even less in those with weaker immune systems.
So the lockdowns are to prevent even more hospitalisations and deaths and as you correctly say, once they are eased, then cases will increase again and round and round we go.
Maybe we could have covid parties with all the under 45’s (those least at risk) attempting to catch it like they used to have measles and chickenpox parties. (That's a joke BTW)
Not sure what the alternatives are because if we just go back to normal then there will be many deaths amongst those most at risk. We could ask those at risk to shield, but for how long? What if there is never a vaccine? Do you want them to shield indefinitely. I suspect if you asked that then people with a limited time to live anyway, would just say ‘bollox to that, I’ll take my chances’ the hospitals would be flooded and those with other diseases would still not get treatment.
And you can call it what you want, covid, flu, sorearseitis - the bottom line is there is a virus that is making people ill enough to require hospital treatment, ventilation and causing deaths
I’m afraid it’s going to be a long time before there is any exit from this.
Don't disagree and without entering into hyperbole it's going to be 10 years or more. Those people dying who've not had treatment, effect on businesses, jobs, economy, health and education. It's an unimaginable cost way out of proportion in my opinion and deeply/unfairly loaded onto the least well off, the less well educated, the young and the infirm.
Those most at risk should live their lives as they would in any seasonal flu period. You take precautions. Your family and friends help you. If a vaccine comes a long take it - it may help it may well not. Take responsibility for your own health.
Those not at risk at all. Get on with your lives and help reduce any future impact. Don't demand a test don't take a vaccine. Take responsibility for your own health and that of others where you can.
I know this is supposedly heretical because what gets thrown back is you're just letting the weak and old die. My response to that is you've done that for the past 50 years of seasonal respiratory viruses.
[/quote]
Thus isn’t a normal flu again you’re arguing from a false premise.
Posts: 3,594
Threads: 27
Joined: Apr 2019
Reputation:
14
10-30-2020, 02:51 PM
(This post was last modified: 10-30-2020, 02:54 PM by Brentbaggie.)
Billy, I don't dispute your central tenet that we can't carry on like this forever. You're absolutely right, the world or this country can not do so, but you've not responded to either of my posts - I don't take it personally - a) Why regarding why these measure are taken; i.e. in the hope a vaccine is available and b) The amount of ICU unit beds now in operation.
What do you think regarding the idea that the government is simply gambling (and I don't mean that in a pejorative sense) on the basis that this semi-short term measure is in effect until a vaccine becomes available? It may not work but it seems to them (and I'm no fan of this government) that such strict, even possibly injurious measures, may be worthwhile in the longer term; i.e. when a vaccine becomes available, rather than allowing the virus free rein. Their measures are not counter-productive in the sense that they don't make sense, it is only the lack of desire to abide by strict measures that allow the virus to spread.
I take your point that it flourishes more powerfully indoors, but you can't live outdoors no matter how much you'll feel better for having done so. Once you're out you have to come back in, and if you abide by the measures that almost all experts agree can counter the spread (hand-washing, masks, social distancing). By mixing and not abiding by the strict measures your chance of contracting and then spreading the virus increases, albeit more virulently, when inside again.
If these measures don't work it's more likely because individuals ignore them, not because the virus will spread anyway. And if infection rates aren't reduced it is all-but certain hospital staff will be unable to cope, it's medics who are saying this, not just politicians or 'experts'. Hope is not always blind and I am led to believe that the chances of a vaccine are good. It is this plan (if you want to call it that) that is directing the current strategy I am sure. Of course it could all go shit-shaped but it seems to me to this is what lies behind what we are having to undergo.
|