Foster and Dawson
#31
I wouldn't have Foster back. Johnstone just needs a pandemic disrupted preseason.
Reply
#32
(07-26-2020, 05:58 PM)Cheshire East Baggie Wrote: We never learn do we? Here we are proposing to sign Foster and Deeney in the same thread. No, no, no.

So many on here wanted to keep GMac as he approached 40. Loads of posters waffled on about what a good idea it was to offer walking wounded Gareth Barry another new contract. Does the spirit of Pulis still haunt this board? Let's develop the players we have and bring in some under-30s with a bit of shelf life left.

+1
Reply
#33
(07-27-2020, 06:45 AM)4-hero Wrote:
(07-26-2020, 05:58 PM)Cheshire East Baggie Wrote: We never learn do we? Here we are proposing to sign Foster and Deeney in the same thread. No, no, no.

So many on here wanted to keep GMac as he approached 40. Loads of posters waffled on about what a good idea it was to offer walking wounded Gareth Barry another new contract. Does the spirit of Pulis still haunt this board? Let's develop the players we have and bring in some under-30s with a bit of shelf life left.

+1

I agree with that.
But... the harsh reality of prem life means that part of our strategy means we look at the class players who are approaching the end of their shelf life. That's the only way we can afford the top players.. Chadli, Anelka, didn't work.
But I guess Barry did. Odemwingie was 30ish from memory. 
It's not easy.
Give me hungry young players who want to play for the Baggies.
But there's no one simple route.
Reply
#34
(07-27-2020, 12:10 AM)SausEggBaton Wrote: I wouldn't have Foster back. Johnstone just needs a pandemic disrupted preseason.

What Johnstone needs is to attend a few Under 11s “basics of goalkeeping” coaching sessions about how to deal with crosses from the flanks and how to dominate his 6-yard boxes.  The very basics are lacking and I find that astonishing.  If the club’s goalkeeping coaches are not able to sort out that those fundamental deficiencies then what exactly are we paying them for?
Reply
#35
(07-27-2020, 07:05 AM)Johnnykayeengland Wrote:
(07-27-2020, 06:45 AM)4-hero Wrote:
(07-26-2020, 05:58 PM)Cheshire East Baggie Wrote: We never learn do we? Here we are proposing to sign Foster and Deeney in the same thread. No, no, no.

So many on here wanted to keep GMac as he approached 40. Loads of posters waffled on about what a good idea it was to offer walking wounded Gareth Barry another new contract. Does the spirit of Pulis still haunt this board? Let's develop the players we have and bring in some under-30s with a bit of shelf life left.

+1
Odemwinge was 29 (and a month!) when he made his debuted. It was a move up for him because he came from the Russian league. For both Barry  and Anelka we were a move down as they (like it or not) had played for better teams


 


I agree with that.
But... the harsh reality of prem life means that part of our strategy means we look at the class players who are approaching the end of their shelf life. That's the only way we can afford the top players.. Chadli, Anelka, didn't work.
But I guess Barry did. Odemwingie was 30ish from memory. 
It's not easy.
Give me hungry young players who want to play for the Baggies.
But there's no one simple route.
Reply
#36
Dawson - no chance. Was poor in 2018/19 in his preferred position and has hardly been a roaring success at Watford.

Deeney - old and doesn’t actually score goals. I’d prefer Andre Gray.

Foster - still a wonderful goalkeeper. If we have two hot goalkeeper prospects who aren’t yet ready to be number one having Foster for 1-2 seasons could be a solution. If he is a big earner Watford May want rid so a 1-2 season loan could work.
Reply
#37
Dawson played all his best games for the Albion as a right back under Pulis. Mainly because he was TP’s archetypal full back. Whenever he moved inside he was bang average and he doesn’t offer most coaches what they are looking for at full back. Move on
Reply
#38
If Dawson comes back I'll ripping up my season ticket (once I get it anyway!)
Reply
#39
(07-27-2020, 07:05 AM)Johnnykayeengland Wrote:
(07-27-2020, 06:45 AM)4-hero Wrote:
(07-26-2020, 05:58 PM)Cheshire East Baggie Wrote: We never learn do we? Here we are proposing to sign Foster and Deeney in the same thread. No, no, no.

So many on here wanted to keep GMac as he approached 40. Loads of posters waffled on about what a good idea it was to offer walking wounded Gareth Barry another new contract. Does the spirit of Pulis still haunt this board? Let's develop the players we have and bring in some under-30s with a bit of shelf life left.

+1

I agree with that.
But... the harsh reality of prem life means that part of our strategy means we look at the class players who are approaching the end of their shelf life. That's the only way we can afford the top players.. Chadli, Anelka, didn't work.
But I guess Barry did. Odemwingie was 30ish from memory. 
It's not easy.
Give me hungry young players who want to play for the Baggies.
But there's no one simple route.

No he really didn't. He didn't play enough games. He didn't seem to have any positive impact on the squad. He played on when clearly unfit and cost us several crucial points with weak performances when we were well-placed to challenge for automatic promotion in 2018-19 (losing possession from kick-off to allow Leeds to score in the first 15 seconds will take some living down IMO). He did nothing whatsoever for his new contract this season.

Darren Fletcher showed how it can work. Gareth Barry proved it doesn't always work.
Reply
#40
I can't see us being interested in bringing either of them back or looking at Deeney (off for a knee operation so could be out for a bit).

Wonder if Dawson and Foster will go on Pre-season?
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 2 Guest(s)