VAR
#1
That corrupt bastard has really shown his true colours tonight.Nothing we didn't already know but hes shown it to a much,much bigger audience tonight.
Reply
#2
The handball decision was the right call.

I totally disagree with the rule, but following this season’s rule change it is a foul. Blame the rules, not the system that’s there to pick them up.

Scott remains an epic cunt though.
Reply
#3
What about the penalty.
Reply
#4
(08-17-2019, 07:14 PM)SW4Baggie Wrote: The handball decision was the right call.

I totally disagree with the rule, but following this season’s rule change it is a foul. Blame the rules, not the system that’s there to pick them up.

Scott remains an epic cunt though.
Completely ruins the passion of the game.  Goal line technology is fine, but subjective decisions aren't. What about the Man City pen in the first half, that wasn't given or even discussed?
People must realise that a football match with every decision as perfect as possible would take a day to complete. Football is not the same as cricket, or even rugby, which have natural breaks in play. Get rid of it
Reply
#5
(08-17-2019, 07:14 PM)SW4Baggie Wrote: The handball decision was the right call.

I totally disagree with the rule, but following this season’s rule change it is a foul. Blame the rules, not the system that’s there to pick them up.

Scott remains an epic cunt though.

My understanding of how VAR is supposed to work is that it is there to amend clear and obvious refereeing errors.

So it is entirely possible for a ref to have made an error but for var not to change the original decision. I have to disagree with you it is very much the system not the rules. Because what is deemed to be a clear and obvious error just introduces another layer of subjectivity into refereeing decisions.
Reply
#6
My big concern with VAR at the moment is that it isn’t just being applied to “clear and obvious errors”. Seems to me that refs are reluctant to use their own judgement anymore, they’re happy not to make a decision and let VAR decide for them.

This isn’t how it should be.
Reply
#7
Could they not do an appeal system like cricket and tennis?
Reply
#8
(08-17-2019, 09:56 PM)Big Daddy Cool Wrote: Could they not do an appeal system like cricket and tennis?

Review system in football doesn’t work as there are so few decisions compared to cricket and tennis... every goal that got scored would be reviewed and it would take away the fans’ enjoyment... further it takes away the authority of the ref, which current VAR rules have been formulated to maintain.

I’m a little confused about the complaints around the City game... the penalty in the first half wasn’t a clear and obvious error so it wasn’t flagged. VAR May have said to the ref to review it but he will have decided not to, or the VAR team decided it wasn’t clear enough to review... penalties are still subjective. People complain when decisions are reviewed and when they’re not... 

The goal that was correctly ruled out wasn’t subjective. There was a handball (albeit accidental) in the buildup to the goal which by the letter of the law was a foul. As soon as we start deciding “oh this objective foul isn’t a foul” it opens a load of new inconsistency.

I’m not a fan of the new handball rule, but that’s not VAR’s fault.
Reply
#9
(08-17-2019, 09:20 PM)Shabby Russian Wrote:
(08-17-2019, 07:14 PM)SW4Baggie Wrote: The handball decision was the right call.

I totally disagree with the rule, but following this season’s rule change it is a foul. Blame the rules, not the system that’s there to pick them up.

Scott remains an epic cunt though.

My understanding of how VAR is supposed to work is that it is there to amend clear and obvious refereeing errors.

So it is entirely possible for a ref to have made an error but for var not to change the original decision. I have to disagree with you it is very much the system not the rules. Because what is deemed to be a clear and obvious error just introduces another layer of subjectivity into refereeing decisions.
I went on a West Ham fans site to see how they rated Diangana (sad, I know, but there were lots of them, well before yesterday, bemoaning the fact that he'd been allowed to go out on loan)
I came across this post which lays out one bloke's opposition to VAR far better than I did:

One of the reasons football is the biggest sport in the world is the value of its scoring currency. There is nothing in sport more valuable than a goal. A try, a wicket, a touchdown, a birdie. None of them are as instant or as precious as a goal. In rugby you can score an unconverted try or you can score two penalties. Two penalties are worth more than the try. There is nothing that is equal to a goal. They score a goal. You have to score one back. One goal can win an entire tournament and it can happen in an instant. The magic of that moment is what makes us love the game and spend our money and revolve our lives around attending games. If goals lose their magic and we no longer have those seconds of pure bliss after the ball hits the back of the net the game is ruined forever. The trade off is simply not worth it in my opinion.
Reply
#10
Very well put.A lot more eloquent than my original rant.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: