Phillips
#21
I'm sure the stats will paint a different picture, and I'm certainly not pretending we're suddenly defensively sound. Our main issues with conceding sloppy goals remain. However, I do feel more comfortable with Mepham playing alongside Campbell than I do when it's Phillips.

As I always maintain, I'm not claiming to be an expert or anything of the sort, but from what I'm seeing, we appear more organised and defensively solid with Mepham rather than Phillips.

Bizarrely, it was the other way around last season, wasn't it?!
Reply
#22
(11-04-2026, 10:11 PM)Josh1873 Wrote: I'm sure the stats will paint a different picture, and I'm certainly not pretending we're suddenly defensively sound. Our main issues with conceding sloppy goals remain. However, I do feel more comfortable with Mepham playing alongside Campbell than I do when it's Phillips.

As I always maintain, I'm not claiming to be an expert or anything of the sort, but from what I'm seeing, we appear more organised and defensively solid with Mepham rather than Phillips.

Bizarrely, it was the other way around last season, wasn't it?!

I'd say last season Phillips' errors were about poor positioning, dodgy decision-making and failure to spot opponents' runs. He was OK with the game in front of him. Semi Ajayi's level of concentration and Kyle Bartley's sharpness.

Mepham looked a quality defender, then started making unforced errors, flicks, tricks, backheels, clever stuff instead of "boot through the ball" defending. Two very different players whose weaknesses undermined each other. They still don't look right together, even with better coaching and a less wobbly keeper behind them.

Mepham has spent a lot of his career on the bench, which might indicate a lack of consistency or maybe a bit of attitude. Phillips has spent more time in the hydropool. On the evidence of this season so far, Mepham is the better player for us, with more potential to improve. He is also taller, despite the popular notion that you need Phillips to deal with big centre-forwards.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: