10-21-2026, 09:41 AM
(10-21-2026, 07:13 AM)AnelkasBeard Wrote:(10-20-2026, 05:04 PM)SW4Baggie Wrote: After posting this morning, I've been thinking on this, and it simply has to be a long term, staggered punishment. It can't be a quick fix that's over inside a couple of years, and it can't be something that distorts the entire pyramid by moving their wealth and infrastructure into a much lower league through relegation.
I would say:
- Strip them of all trophies won and expunged from record books. Symbolic but necessary.
- Enforced sale similar to how Chelsea was sold, with the process handled by an independent authority.
- Lifetime football ownership and directorship ban for all executives involved in this conspiracy - criminal charges at His Majesty's discetion.
- Ban them from competing in League Cup and FA Cup for 5 seasons - we won't be able to control what UEFA do so pointless asking for a Euro ban.
- A steadily decreasing points deduction over the next 6 seasons (36 points this season, 30 next, 24 following etc) - this could be halved should they be relegated. Reason for this was that no Champion deducted 36 points would ever qualify for Champs League historically.
- Appropriate financial reparations to be made to all clubs over the next 6 seasons, which are included in their PSR/SCR calculation.
This way those who were involved are punished and removed from the game and all impacted clubs receive financial compensation but the money doesn't arrive in one go and distort club revenues in one season.
The gradually reducing points deduction should in theory maintain a level of punishment for a prolonged period, whilst also allowing the PL to remain competitive - they do not want one team automatically relegated due to a deduction from August, and it prevents an automatic relegation distorting the other leagues.
The SCR inclusion of their reparations to other clubs ensures their budget remains tight and they can't just write a blank cheque. It will also mean they will have to sell off their prized assets but doesn't allow them to suddenly go all guns blazing spunking the cash again.
A good, well thought out realistic solution. Sadly what most of us what just isn't realistic, but this would fit the bill I think.
Incidentally regarding UEFA, there was a leak 3/4 days ago about Citeh getting a 7-10 year ban from European competitions. Let's hope it comes to fruition.
How is it realistic?
Forced sale = given to one of the Sheik's family members (owners get banned, just handed to another Sheikh... )
36 points deduction = keeps them in the Prem, why is Euro exclusion the only punishment that so e think is acceptable? It's not, UEFA lost their case against City before, this 114 charges has nothing to do with Euro competitions.
Strip titles = noone really cares... Their fans celebrated at the time... For me it's the weakest of all punishments.
FA / league Cup ban - yep agree
Other club reparations - needs to be based on the BBC figures we get £9m, but it's more than the Seals and Dungs... Swansea will do well out of it though.
This would fall into the big slap on the wrist territory for me. No relegation (36pts last season would still have them safe), a couple of seasons out of Europe... Doesn't seem to have done Man U much harm.
Sadly this is probably the sort of thing that will happen, though

