So what do we make of this squad and summer’s work?
#31
Garlick's background was never scouting and football ability, he's a qualified lawyer by trade and deals with negotiations in contracts etc. He was appointed as successor to Ashworth and did his best in that regard. We should have appointed someone more skilled in that specific field that could continue the work Ashworth had done, but we struggled to identify and appoint iirc. 

Garlick is a Baggies fan, he still attends games (not all though) and has a box with his family, and lives in the area still I know this personally. While his ability in that remit may have not lived up to hope and expectation, it certainly wouldn't have been without the required level of care and effort. 

I think the accounting of players has improved significantly recently, as it has had to. However, with the Norwegian players particularly, I feel we've over paid, particularly for Heggebø. I'm not sure (from memory) how often we could say that of the players we signed during Garlick's stint.
Reply
#32
Interesting to hear that. Re Heggebo, IIRC the fee was undisclosed or reported at £3M. I wouldn't say we overpaid. In the football world there are numerous examples of overpaying. Albion have a few too, Ideye, Luke Moore, David Mills even.
Reply
#33
I wasn’t putting Garlick in the same bracket at Ashworth as DoF, it was absolutely the wrong move to give him footballing operations but in terms of a business and football industry operated there were few better. When we had Ashwrorh on football matters, Garlick on all things contracts and business, we had a phenomenal set up for a club of our size. There was also huge amounts of talent both in our coaching set up and academy - lots of very good coaches currently working at top clubs were in our set up during that period.

The point I was making is going back 15 years or so, we didn’t realise just how good our set up was. Whilst things look to be improving with the current organisation, it will be a damn long time before we have talent at that level again sadly
Reply
#34
I do have sympathy with Garlick, because Peace would have directed all football decisions to be made by Pulis with a view to Premiership stability to sell the club. It wouldn’t surprise me once the club was sold if Pulis received a bonus and was then keen to leave.

Garlick contractually would have to remain in place for a 2 year transition. I can’t imagine it was easy dealing with Ken and any of Lai’s people once the Chinese communist party declared that investing in football was not what they wanted.

Garlick is clearly a talented bloke as his subsequent career has proven.

Whether Price is as good as Ashworth only time will tell but if he’s anywhere near as good it will be great for West Brom.

The irony is that Peace fell out with Sir Gary Megson over scouting for players which resulted in Megson leaving and Ashworth being recruited. Peace employing Pulis effectively killed the idea of the club owning or even contributing to who they wanted to recruit or sell.

Transfers can be good and bad as Rich has listed above regarding Ashworth. Under Garlick’s tenure we bought Brown Ideye £10m, Oliver Burke £13m, Darren Fletcher free, Jonny Evan’s £6m a mixture as always.

I think it’s too early to tell if we overpaid for Heggebø. He scored 9 last year and one in the Carabao cup plus 4 assists. Not bad for a first season in the championship playing for a team who were nearly relegated. Hopefully he can add to his one goal so far this season and beat last years total. The first thing he needs to do is get back in the team.
Reply
#35
I'm relatively pleased with our business. Unlike many I wasn't sure on the real pressing need for another striker, I think with JJ, Heggebo and Stewart we have a good mix and with the addition of FHM and knowing what Price can do we have 3-4 players all capable of potentially chipping in with a double-figures goal return.

Galves and Pereira leave us far more balanced in defence and Collyer on the face of things seems and ideal Mowatt replacement and has plenty of potential.

The only area I of our team I still have question marks about is in goal, I know people will be along to tell me MOL is "fine" and he is, but watching the goal we've conceded on Wednesday night I can't help but think that a Palmer comes and claims that ball on the six yard line, or at very least tries and ends up winning a freekick. Only time will tell, but it's a nagging doubt and there is a reason why Bristol City were willing to let him leave for nothing.
Reply
#36
(09-04-2026, 08:28 AM)Ted Maul Wrote: I'm relatively pleased with our business. Unlike many I wasn't sure on the real pressing need for another striker, I think with JJ, Heggebo and Stewart we have a good mix and with the addition of FHM and knowing what Price can do we have 3-4 players all capable of potentially chipping in with a double-figures goal return.

Galves and Pereira leave us far more balanced in defence and Collyer on the face of things seems and ideal Mowatt replacement and has plenty of potential.

The only area I of our team I still have question marks about is in goal, I know people will be along to tell me MOL is "fine" and he is, but watching the goal we've conceded on Wednesday night I can't help but think that a Palmer comes and claims that ball on the six yard line, or at very least tries and ends up winning a freekick. Only time will tell, but it's a nagging doubt and there is a reason why Bristol City were willing to let him leave for nothing.

Completely agree. I'm unconvinced by our goalkeeping options.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: