Posts: 13,568
Threads: 492
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
40
(08-02-2026, 09:18 AM)HawkingsHalfpint Wrote: NI should be split in two so it doesn’t hurt employers anymore than it already does. I know it already is split, but the personal element should be split further. The social care element should be a simple levy on the personal element. And the amount of that levy should be means-tested; not a one-off percentage for all. We all might need social care at some point, or simply drop dead; but not everyone can afford to pay much more tax. Not when we already have one of the highest tax burdens in Europe (if not globally).
I do think too many care managers/providers earn far too much out of all this though, while their staff scratch about on zero-hours, minimum wage. The whole system is fucked to me.
NI should be abolished and the rates for employee NI should be folded into income tax, employer NI should be renamed to a payroll tax.
And we don't have one of the highest tax burdens in Europe, it's one of the lowest. Denmark has the highest with a proportion of tax to GDP close to 10% higher than the UK, though the quality of their public services and their fiscal discipline is much higher than us.
Posts: 8,078
Threads: 201
Joined: Feb 2019
Reputation:
55
08-02-2026, 11:02 AM
(This post was last modified: 08-02-2026, 11:13 AM by HawkingsHalfpint.)
Fair point on the subject of tax burdens; perhaps I’m getting mistaken between our own history and internationally.
But we’re still in the upper-mid quartile according to this:
https://ifs.org.uk/taxlab/taxlab-key-que...nationally
And it will have increased since. Unless you can find more recent, contradictory evidence! I’d also argue that - with some very notable exceptions - countries like Denmark get good value from that burden.
It also needs to be weighed against who can afford to pay it, also. Like many stats it tells little on its own.
My point above still stands about offshoring of corporation tax for those who can. Sort that loophole and you can afford to fix a lot. We’re probably not alone in having that issue, however (although the papers won’t tell you that).
Posts: 13,568
Threads: 492
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
40
(08-02-2026, 11:02 AM)HawkingsHalfpint Wrote: Fair point on the subject of tax burdens; perhaps I’m getting mistaken between our own history and internationally.
But we’re still in the upper-mid quartile according to this:
https://ifs.org.uk/taxlab/taxlab-key-que...nationally
And it will have increased since. Unless you can find more recent, contradictory evidence! I’d also argue that - with some very notable exceptions - countries like Denmark get good value from that burden.
It also needs to be weighed against who can afford to pay it, also. Like many stats it tells little on its own.
My point above still stands about offshoring of corporation tax for those who can. Sort that loophole and you can afford to fix a lot. We’re probably not alone in having that issue, however (although the papers won’t tell you that).
It's 36.3% of GDP for the last fiscal year based on the 2025 Autumn Budget, it puts us in-line with the G7 average and middle of the pack. It's still comfortably below the EU average and all comparable peer nations in the EU, but they have better public services generally (except Belgium).
What the UK does is not adequately tax wealth vs income creating significant disparity between high earners who get their income from unearned income vs earned income (and before Proth goes has a hissyfit again about "Unearned Income", those are tax definitions) creating labour disincentives, severely under taxes lower earners relative to all of our peer nations (lower earners in the UK have it better on tax than every other G7 member, including the US, quite comfortably which says a lot) and has tax disparity (NICs not applying to equivalent earners, student loans) that causes regressive distortions on income. The obvious things that need to happen to fix this are to fold in employee NICs into income tax and replace rates (Council Tax and Business Rates), abolish zero-rating and lower-rating of VAT and replace it with a single VAT rate (15% to be revenue neutral last I checked) and stamp duties (SDLT and shares) with a revenue-neutral land value tax (around 1.25% to 1.4% per annum last I looked into it) but that will upset the biggest voting bloc (older people) and the biggest political influencers (wealthy people) so the chances of it happening are nil despite fiscal economists generally agreeing it needs to happen. There's also stuff like adjusting thresholds and smoothing out the cliff edges e.g. increasing the additional rate by 1% or 2% and using that extra revenue to disapply the withdrawal rates at £100k to give a significantly lower marginal rate between £100k and £125k.
But the oxygen is being sucked in on the left by vague and punitive wealth taxes (that categorically do not work because wealth not derived by land values is internationally mobile) and on the right by welfare spending (welfare spending is currently in line with what it has been since the early 1980s at around 10% of GDP, there's wiggle room within that as pensions have pushed out employment and disability benefits but it's really not a current or immediate problem and won't make a lick of difference in the immediate term).
Posts: 11,311
Threads: 419
Joined: Feb 2020
Reputation:
18
08-02-2026, 02:38 PM
(This post was last modified: 08-02-2026, 02:44 PM by Protheroe.)
(08-01-2026, 08:13 PM)baggy1 Wrote: Proth “It’s all one pot, NI is not for your pension”
Also Proth “They called it a social care tax”
You should really pay attention to what politicians actually say. The last increase in NI was to “pay for social care”, the Council Tax precept was to “pay for social care”. I know it’s all bollocks. You know it’s all bollocks. Why should Burnham’s next tax grab be seen as anything other than more bullshit?
BB - don’t get me wrong about the term “unearned”. I’m all for CGT on the sale of principal residences rather than on investment returns that actually contribute to the economy.
Our tax system is bananas. It does not tax the majority of people enough of their income, taxes a minority far too much of their income and hammers both in all sorts of other ways unless they’ve had the good fortune to accumulate capital.
Posts: 8,078
Threads: 201
Joined: Feb 2019
Reputation:
55
08-05-2026, 09:57 AM
(This post was last modified: 08-05-2026, 10:03 AM by HawkingsHalfpint.)
(08-02-2026, 12:52 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: (08-02-2026, 11:02 AM)HawkingsHalfpint Wrote: Fair point on the subject of tax burdens; perhaps I’m getting mistaken between our own history and internationally.
But we’re still in the upper-mid quartile according to this:
https://ifs.org.uk/taxlab/taxlab-key-que...nationally
And it will have increased since. Unless you can find more recent, contradictory evidence! I’d also argue that - with some very notable exceptions - countries like Denmark get good value from that burden.
It also needs to be weighed against who can afford to pay it, also. Like many stats it tells little on its own.
My point above still stands about offshoring of corporation tax for those who can. Sort that loophole and you can afford to fix a lot. We’re probably not alone in having that issue, however (although the papers won’t tell you that).
It's 36.3% of GDP for the last fiscal year based on the 2025 Autumn Budget, it puts us in-line with the G7 average and middle of the pack. It's still comfortably below the EU average and all comparable peer nations in the EU, but they have better public services generally (except Belgium).
What the UK does is not adequately tax wealth vs income creating significant disparity between high earners who get their income from unearned income vs earned income (and before Proth goes has a hissyfit again about "Unearned Income", those are tax definitions) creating labour disincentives, severely under taxes lower earners relative to all of our peer nations (lower earners in the UK have it better on tax than every other G7 member, including the US, quite comfortably which says a lot) and has tax disparity (NICs not applying to equivalent earners, student loans) that causes regressive distortions on income. The obvious things that need to happen to fix this are to fold in employee NICs into income tax and replace rates (Council Tax and Business Rates), abolish zero-rating and lower-rating of VAT and replace it with a single VAT rate (15% to be revenue neutral last I checked) and stamp duties (SDLT and shares) with a revenue-neutral land value tax (around 1.25% to 1.4% per annum last I looked into it) but that will upset the biggest voting bloc (older people) and the biggest political influencers (wealthy people) so the chances of it happening are nil despite fiscal economists generally agreeing it needs to happen. There's also stuff like adjusting thresholds and smoothing out the cliff edges e.g. increasing the additional rate by 1% or 2% and using that extra revenue to disapply the withdrawal rates at £100k to give a significantly lower marginal rate between £100k and £125k.
But the oxygen is being sucked in on the left by vague and punitive wealth taxes (that categorically do not work because wealth not derived by land values is internationally mobile) and on the right by welfare spending (welfare spending is currently in line with what it has been since the early 1980s at around 10% of GDP, there's wiggle room within that as pensions have pushed out employment and disability benefits but it's really not a current or immediate problem and won't make a lick of difference in the immediate term).
I don’t disagree with much of that, but too much tax is simply avoided. Either by offshoring (as I keep saying) of profit or in investments schemes (if you can) down to crypto-backed side hustles. I’d say our benefits system is fair, I’m in alignment with those who would advocate paying more tax for better public services, but it doesn’t necessarily align with people’s experiences. There is a huge gulf now between what I would call ‘managerial class’ incomes, and some of those who would be better off not working at all; or are actually actively incentivised to cap their hours to 16-20 a week (forget which, but it’s certainly done no harm in fudging unemployment figures). And all of this avoids the major question - unless in the case of another, much deadlier pandemic, this country is in for a huge care crisis in a decade or two. If it’s not already in one now. My father (who valued nursing homes for a living) has been saying this since the mid-80s.
Tax rises aren’t the major issue facing many middle-earners. A year or two’s hyper inflation is what is making life difficult for many, but it’s easier to blame taxation.
So who is going to pay for it when so few politicians admit they have the appetite to tackle it in the only way it is possible to?
|