Posts: 19,492
Threads: 824
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
60
Unfortunately it's lose-lose.
Their players are scrutinised far more highly than other loanees because of where they come from, and the track record of us mostly ending up with dog-shit from them, and if they do come here and perform, we contribute to Villa's success.
We should have taken Dobbin last season, when he'd had 2-3 loans acclimatising to the demands of this level, and when he could have offered something. Instead we had to sit through SIJ (who I did feel a little sorry for being played in all manner of positions).
Hemmings may be a very good player, and his bio sounds like what we need in that he's an athletic, box to box midfielder who drives the play forward, but he's again completely untried in first team football, has no understanding of what's needed in the Championship, and he plays in a position where we have Deeming, Mandey and even Whitwell should we want to try an untested, raw centre mid.
I also don't want us to loan the central midfield option we need. We have failed with Racic and Collyer in recent seasons and upgrading this position is absolutely crucial. We do not need a 4th choice player to come in and make up the numbers, we have been screaming out for a midfielder who can put his foot on the ball, push us up the pitch, and be relied on to make something happen - Sonny Carey from Charlton would have been a great pick up last summer on a free for example.
I can't watch another season of Mowatt and Molumby being topped up with a loanee who struggles give us 5 starts.
Posts: 3,107
Threads: 59
Joined: Sep 2025
Reputation:
20
(07-28-2026, 08:20 AM)SW4Baggie Wrote: Unfortunately it's lose-lose.
Their players are scrutinised far more highly than other loanees because of where they come from, and the track record of us mostly ending up with dog-shit from them, and if they do come here and perform, we contribute to Villa's success.
We should have taken Dobbin last season, when he'd had 2-3 loans acclimatising to the demands of this level, and when he could have offered something. Instead we had to sit through SIJ (who I did feel a little sorry for being played in all manner of positions).
Hemmings may be a very good player, and his bio sounds like what we need in that he's an athletic, box to box midfielder who drives the play forward, but he's again completely untried in first team football, has no understanding of what's needed in the Championship, and he plays in a position where we have Deeming, Mandey and even Whitwell should we want to try an untested, raw centre mid.
I also don't want us to loan the central midfield option we need. We have failed with Racic and Collyer in recent seasons and upgrading this position is absolutely crucial. We do not need a 4th choice player to come in and make up the numbers, we have been screaming out for a midfielder who can put his foot on the ball, push us up the pitch, and be relied on to make something happen - Sonny Carey from Charlton would have been a great pick up last summer on a free for example.
I can't watch another season of Mowatt and Molumby being topped up with a loanee who struggles give us 5 starts.
Agree. So now Mandey, our own player, drops in the pecking order. If we are taking loans to develop other clubs players, let's stick to Palace. They actually have some good ones.
Posts: 2,465
Threads: 34
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
6
(07-27-2026, 07:59 PM)Duffers Wrote: Law of averages suggests that at least one fk them should be good for us.
Personally I don't fancy us going through 99 of them before landing on that one gem. Who then gets recalled in January.
Posts: 1,735
Threads: 36
Joined: Sep 2022
Reputation:
5
I think the point about taking players on a second or third loan is really valid although not in the case of SIJ.
I know it was 15 mins but I really liked the look of Mandey at Hillsborough but fear it is a bit soon for him.
Posts: 19,492
Threads: 824
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
60
(07-28-2026, 09:37 AM)Stillclem4england Wrote: I think the point about taking players on a second or third loan is really valid although not in the case of SIJ.
I know it was 15 mins but I really liked the look of Mandey at Hillsborough but fear it is a bit soon for him.
On paper SIJ was exactly the type of player we should be looking to loan... 21, around 50 senior games behind him, experience playing in the Championship, and had a degree of quality we'd unlikely be able to outright buy.
Unfortunately nobody knew what position he played, and his versatility and willingness to play anywhere held him back.
Whilst he was frustrating at times, I felt a little sorry for him as he was brought into a clusterfuck and was asked to do different things every week. Don't think he was a bad lad, and he had ability, we just had no idea how to make the best of him and he really suffered from our needing him to cover 3-4 roles.
Posts: 13,256
Threads: 468
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
45
(07-28-2026, 10:04 AM)SW4Baggie Wrote: (07-28-2026, 09:37 AM)Stillclem4england Wrote: I think the point about taking players on a second or third loan is really valid although not in the case of SIJ.
I know it was 15 mins but I really liked the look of Mandey at Hillsborough but fear it is a bit soon for him.
On paper SIJ was exactly the type of player we should be looking to loan... 21, around 50 senior games behind him, experience playing in the Championship, and had a degree of quality we'd unlikely be able to outright buy.
Unfortunately nobody knew what position he played, and his versatility and willingness to play anywhere held him back.
Whilst he was frustrating at times, I felt a little sorry for him as he was brought into a clusterfuck and was asked to do different things every week. Don't think he was a bad lad, and he had ability, we just had no idea how to make the best of him and he really suffered from our needing him to cover 3-4 roles.
We also replaced him with worse. SIJ will likely be a lower end Serie A/La Liga squad player. I didn't see anything from JJA to suggest he'll reach that level and god knows how good Hindolo Mustapha is
Posts: 10,545
Threads: 95
Joined: Feb 2019
Reputation:
96
I've no issue with loans, it's where he's from I can't stand.
Posts: 264
Threads: 14
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
1
They must have enough dirt on us to get us kicked out of the league.
It's the only reason I can think of.
|