Cricket Clique - England vz NZ Tests
(06-30-2026, 01:38 PM)yeoman lai Wrote:
(06-30-2026, 12:36 PM)backsidebaggie Wrote:
(06-30-2026, 11:11 AM)yeoman lai Wrote: Anderson as bowling coach?

He is still our best bowler and should be playing.

How is he our best bowler?

Anderson was ace but do his championship figures this season really make him better than Atkinson and Robinson right now?? Surely not.

An attempt at humour mate, like saying Bomber should be in our team.  Big Grin

I got whooshed
Reply
(06-30-2026, 02:05 PM)AnelkasBeard Wrote:
(06-30-2026, 01:57 PM)Josh1873 Wrote:
(06-30-2026, 12:56 PM)richbaggie Wrote:
(06-30-2026, 12:45 PM)Josh1873 Wrote: Cricket is cyclical, as with any sport, really. We're currently as close to rock bottom as you could get in international cricket.

We'll sack people, bring people in, change things up, and we'll see improvement.

We may well get back to being one of the best, and if/when that happens, it won't last, and we'll find ourselves in a mess and need of another change. Rinse and repeat.

Whilst agreeing that it's cyclical, I think saying we are as close to rock bottom as could be is an exaggeration. We have dropped to 5th in Test rankings, dropping from 2nd in 2025. We had won 1 in 17  just before McCullum took over in 2022. That was rock bottom stuff.

That's not to say that things are good. It's been a mess this past 12 months and change is required.

That's fair - what I'm trying to get at, however, is that we're pretty poor right now, and in need of a reset, which will come sooner or later. That reset will work, and we'll hopefully get somewhere near to the top, but then it'll go tits up again, at some point. 

I get invested and frustrated with us being poor and on the downward cycle, but I I try to remind myself that it'll only be temporary, and try (and fail) to not let it bother me too much.

I think we would all agree that the issue isn't so much the lack of success, but the rampant unprofessional-ism and seeming lack of application this England team has portrayed. There is plenty of talent in the team, but they're not applying (or being given the chance to apply it) that talent.

Compare us to the New Zealand team of this series, their application was on another planet, and it's why they won the last two Tests convincingly.

If the England were shite, but tried hard, trained well, and applied themselves, I think we'd be a lot more sanguine about it all.

Bang on AB.

The biggest concern for me was Brooks trying to hit every ball our of the ground in the second innings, like it was a 20:20 game. That was the vice captain, admittedly, just following his captains lead.

That's why a reset is needed and with Stokes going it's the right time to change the coach. As fun as the journey has been, the top teams have definitely worked out how to beat us. Basically play sensible test match cricket, and you've got a good chance of winning the series. We need a fresh more professional approach now.
Reply
(06-30-2026, 02:05 PM)AnelkasBeard Wrote:
(06-30-2026, 01:57 PM)Josh1873 Wrote:
(06-30-2026, 12:56 PM)richbaggie Wrote:
(06-30-2026, 12:45 PM)Josh1873 Wrote: Cricket is cyclical, as with any sport, really. We're currently as close to rock bottom as you could get in international cricket.

We'll sack people, bring people in, change things up, and we'll see improvement.

We may well get back to being one of the best, and if/when that happens, it won't last, and we'll find ourselves in a mess and need of another change. Rinse and repeat.

Whilst agreeing that it's cyclical, I think saying we are as close to rock bottom as could be is an exaggeration. We have dropped to 5th in Test rankings, dropping from 2nd in 2025. We had won 1 in 17  just before McCullum took over in 2022. That was rock bottom stuff.

That's not to say that things are good. It's been a mess this past 12 months and change is required.

That's fair - what I'm trying to get at, however, is that we're pretty poor right now, and in need of a reset, which will come sooner or later. That reset will work, and we'll hopefully get somewhere near to the top, but then it'll go tits up again, at some point. 

I get invested and frustrated with us being poor and on the downward cycle, but I I try to remind myself that it'll only be temporary, and try (and fail) to not let it bother me too much.

I think we would all agree that the issue isn't so much the lack of success, but the rampant unprofessional-ism and seeming lack of application this England team has portrayed. There is plenty of talent in the team, but they're not applying (or being given the chance to apply it) that talent.

Compare us to the New Zealand team of this series, their application was on another planet, and it's why they won the last two Tests convincingly.

If the England were shite, but tried hard, trained well, and applied themselves, I think we'd be a lot more sanguine about it all.

Yep, fully agreed. 

Excellent post.
Reply
(06-30-2026, 07:52 AM)AnelkasBeard Wrote:
(06-29-2026, 08:36 PM)Hughie Reed 31 Wrote: I’d give the captaincy to Haseeb Hameed he’s 29 now been captain of Nottinghamshire for around 2
Seasons far better equipped this time round for Test Cricket and also doing well leading his team
And get Sam Curran in as the all rounder & Jordan Cox as the wicket Keeper

Fuck off McCullum & Key
Make Flintoff the coach along with Anderson
Put Vaughan in overall Charge

Wowzers.

Sam Curran? Averages 24 and 35, and not the right way around.
Michael Vaughan should be nowhere near the ECB, will be just as bad as Key.

Hameed whilst playing well is a flawed batter, and there is no reason to drop either Duckett or Gay (who has looked like he has potential in this series)

However, this does need to be the time to completely reset everything. Bazball wasn't a reset, it was the same core of blokes given a mentality shift. And it worked for the first year or so, until they started believing their own hype. Compare the batting from the NZ and Pakistan series, and the postponed India Test, to the more recent fare. Aggressive and attacking, but not reckless. It soon became very reckless, and became mired in selection headaches (Bashir? really?!)

Get proper cricket blokes with their heads screwed on in charge. Alec Stewart as the Key replacement, go all out to get someone like Ponting as coach and put together a 5-10 year plan of how we can actually use County cricket as a proper pipeline of talent and players.

In terms of the team moving forward in the short term... it doesnt look great. Need to focus on getting younger players the experience. Bring Rehan in and cobble together him and Atkinson as the "all-rounder". Jamie Smith is still averaging 40 in Tests, but he needs to drastically improve his keeping. Longer term, Thomas Rew needs to replace him. Bethell has potential, but they've got to get him playing more red ball to gain that experience. Bowlers? Honestly, fuck knows. We'll have to stick with Atkinson, Robinson, Tongue and Archer in the short term but that's a very injury prone stable of quicks.

Duckett
Gay
Bethell
Root
Brook
Smith
Rehan
Atkinson
Archer
Tongue
Robinson

They might be a few wowzers in your opinion
Captaincy wise who are you suggesting?
Curran’s last test appearance was back in 2021
I suggest he is a far better player now
Jordan Cox is a fair batsman and a good wicker keeper

I don’t think Brook can be captain he’s just to rash
And Root is to old for it
And Robinson is never fit

I agree with Rehan getting a chance

It’s a big job ahead for someone
I’d go Vaughan.
Reply
To be frank it’s the management & the coach and there mentality they allow around the test set up is just seems to accommodate.
It’s important to look at the facts 2 biggest tours India in 2025 the team rocks up in India just over 24HRS before the first test and leaving India after the 3rd test losing 2-1 in the series for R&R in Dubai before the final 2 tests!!..That’s just dam unprofessional & insulting to the host England lost the series 4-1.Its got to be noted that the very same Englands very top players have no issue playing IPL for 13+ weeks!!.The Ashes 2026 ditto same unpreparedness and unprofessionalism and another 4-1 series loss.
Forget thrashing average teams in England it’s meaningless England could not beat India or Australia at home in a 5 test series too.
Keys has to go as well as the coach!!..
Reply
(06-30-2026, 05:21 PM)pindgill Wrote: To be frank it’s the management & the coach and there mentality they allow around the test set up is just seems to accommodate.
It’s important to look at the facts 2 biggest tours India in 2025 the team rocks up in India just over 24HRS before the first test and leaving India after the 3rd test losing 2-1 in the series for R&R in Dubai before the final 2 tests!!..That’s just dam unprofessional & insulting to the host England lost the series 4-1.Its got to be noted that the very same Englands very top players have no issue playing IPL for 13+ weeks!!.The Ashes 2026 ditto same unpreparedness and unprofessionalism and another 4-1 series loss.
Forget thrashing average teams in England it’s meaningless England could not beat India or Australia at home in a 5 test series too.
Keys has to go as well as the coach!!..

All true. Then add in the fact Foulkes did no wrong for England and is clearly a better WK than Smith but can't get picked? Hartley and Bashir being bought in out of the blue for the India tour then one discarded altogether and the other supposedly groomed for the Ashes before not figuring in them. Crawley, a fixture despite being semi permanently out of form but he's Rob Key's best mate's son. Bethel given a contract and not  playing any red ball cricket at all until thrown in at the deep end in the biggest game in the world, coming in no.3 in the Boxing Day test. Then the last 3 sessions of a series deciding test  this week when all common sense went out the window. This is not how to manage players. As I said upthread, there is nothing wrong with adventurous attacking cricket, it does not have to be accompanied with a lack of professionalism.
Reply
(06-30-2026, 04:46 PM)Hughie Reed 31 Wrote:
(06-30-2026, 07:52 AM)AnelkasBeard Wrote:
(06-29-2026, 08:36 PM)Hughie Reed 31 Wrote: I’d give the captaincy to Haseeb Hameed he’s 29 now been captain of Nottinghamshire for around 2
Seasons far better equipped this time round for Test Cricket and also doing well leading his team
And get Sam Curran in as the all rounder & Jordan Cox as the wicket Keeper

Fuck off McCullum & Key
Make Flintoff the coach along with Anderson
Put Vaughan in overall Charge

Wowzers.

Sam Curran? Averages 24 and 35, and not the right way around.
Michael Vaughan should be nowhere near the ECB, will be just as bad as Key.

Hameed whilst playing well is a flawed batter, and there is no reason to drop either Duckett or Gay (who has looked like he has potential in this series)

However, this does need to be the time to completely reset everything. Bazball wasn't a reset, it was the same core of blokes given a mentality shift. And it worked for the first year or so, until they started believing their own hype. Compare the batting from the NZ and Pakistan series, and the postponed India Test, to the more recent fare. Aggressive and attacking, but not reckless. It soon became very reckless, and became mired in selection headaches (Bashir? really?!)

Get proper cricket blokes with their heads screwed on in charge. Alec Stewart as the Key replacement, go all out to get someone like Ponting as coach and put together a 5-10 year plan of how we can actually use County cricket as a proper pipeline of talent and players.

In terms of the team moving forward in the short term... it doesnt look great. Need to focus on getting younger players the experience. Bring Rehan in and cobble together him and Atkinson as the "all-rounder". Jamie Smith is still averaging 40 in Tests, but he needs to drastically improve his keeping. Longer term, Thomas Rew needs to replace him. Bethell has potential, but they've got to get him playing more red ball to gain that experience. Bowlers? Honestly, fuck knows. We'll have to stick with Atkinson, Robinson, Tongue and Archer in the short term but that's a very injury prone stable of quicks.

Duckett
Gay
Bethell
Root
Brook
Smith
Rehan
Atkinson
Archer
Tongue
Robinson

They might be a few wowzers in your opinion
Captaincy wise who are you suggesting?
Curran’s last test appearance was back in 2021
I suggest he is a far better player now
Jordan Cox is a fair batsman and a good wicker keeper

I don’t think Brook can be captain he’s just to rash
And Root is to old for it
And Robinson is never fit

I agree with Rehan getting a chance

It’s a big job ahead for someone
I’d go Vaughan.

The thing I strongly disagree with you about is Vaughan. I'm not sure he has the right skill set to lead the ECB. We need someone who has been in cricket administration roles with actual relevant experience, not another ex-player media jockey. We've seen what a debacle in terms of actually running the ECB Key has made, numerous administrative errors, so please give us someone who would know what they're doing.

Granted Vaughan has a much more impressive playing career than Key, and for that reason could potentially fit in as the Head Coach. The same issue applies though - little to no coaching experience.

The rest of your post is completely fair enough, very much a gut feel on almost all of it. And for the captaincy, there just isn't a good enough candidate. Brook will get it, but I'm less than enthused at best.
Reply
Vaughan didn't come out of YorkshireGate too well. IMO there is something slimey about him. No denying, he was a fine captain.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: