HMRC chastised in court - car crash of a performance
#1
Re HMRC crapness, I won a case for a client 6 weeks ago.  Massive case but it won't be a legal decision by the judge and useful authority because Customs asked us to settle very early on.  We got an agreement on every point.  I have copied part of the sheer incoherence of their main witness from transcript (we paid for) at the end.  These arrogant boneheads are making legal decisions.

The case was about claiming excise duty already paid on goods that were being exported ("drawback") which had unlawfully been rejected by HMRC's decision maker.

We broke for lunch less than mid-way through HMRC's officer being cross-examined, which was a car-crash.  During this break, HMRC's lawyers offered to concede everything we needed in order to prevent further carnage.  So no formal decision. Nevertheless, the judge DID give her views which were to express astonishment at most of HMRC's case and tell the buggers off severely.  

Sample of the transcript of the hearing cross-examination:

Q: You're not answering the question, Officer, with respect.  The question is: are you saying under oath, it 's in any way relevant whether the person who's claiming drawback has commercially borne the cost of the duty in some way?

A: There could be a case for that.

Q: There could be a case for that being relevant?

A: There could be a case. There could be a case for that.

Q: On what basis?

A I haven't just come across one, that someone who hadn't paid the duty could claim just , you know, there is −− there is drawback. I know it's happened here −− I −− I get that −− but the reason −− just the government, was not because that they −− that they didn't pay just the duty, or the duty element, or because they tried to just −− just −− you know, just tell us. That is not the reason for the rejection . The rejection just put down the evidence.  (oh dear, oh dear(!))
Reply
#2
(06-04-2026, 02:27 PM)Hudds2 Wrote: Re HMRC crapness, I won a case for a client 6 weeks ago.  Massive case but it won't be a legal decision by the judge and useful authority because Customs asked us to settle very early on.  We got an agreement on every point.  I have copied part of the sheer incoherence of their main witness from transcript (we paid for) at the end.  These arrogant boneheads are making legal decisions.

The case was about claiming excise duty already paid on goods that were being exported ("drawback") which had unlawfully been rejected by HMRC's decision maker.

We broke for lunch less than mid-way through HMRC's officer being cross-examined, which was a car-crash.  During this break, HMRC's lawyers offered to concede everything we needed in order to prevent further carnage.  So no formal decision. Nevertheless, the judge DID give her views which were to express astonishment at most of HMRC's case and tell the buggers off severely.  

Sample of the transcript of the hearing cross-examination:

Q: You're not answering the question, Officer, with respect.  The question is: are you saying under oath, it 's in any way relevant whether the person who's claiming drawback has commercially borne the cost of the duty in some way?

A: There could be a case for that.

Q: There could be a case for that being relevant?

A: There could be a case. There could be a case for that.

Q: On what basis?

A I haven't just come across one, that someone who hadn't paid the duty could claim just , you know, there is −− there is drawback. I know it's happened here −− I −− I get that −− but the reason −− just the government, was not because that they −− that they didn't pay just the duty, or the duty element, or because they tried to just −− just −− you know, just tell us. That is not the reason for the rejection . The rejection just put down the evidence.  (oh dear, oh dear(!))

Probably the officer has been well remunerated for doing routine work and if he/she had been bothered they could have been completely prepared or simply stopped the whole thing from going so far. Madness.
Reply
#3
(06-04-2026, 02:59 PM)Tom Joad 25 Wrote:
(06-04-2026, 02:27 PM)Hudds2 Wrote: Re HMRC crapness, I won a case for a client 6 weeks ago.  Massive case but it won't be a legal decision by the judge and useful authority because Customs asked us to settle very early on.  We got an agreement on every point.  I have copied part of the sheer incoherence of their main witness from transcript (we paid for) at the end.  These arrogant boneheads are making legal decisions.

The case was about claiming excise duty already paid on goods that were being exported ("drawback") which had unlawfully been rejected by HMRC's decision maker.

We broke for lunch less than mid-way through HMRC's officer being cross-examined, which was a car-crash.  During this break, HMRC's lawyers offered to concede everything we needed in order to prevent further carnage.  So no formal decision. Nevertheless, the judge DID give her views which were to express astonishment at most of HMRC's case and tell the buggers off severely.  

Sample of the transcript of the hearing cross-examination:

Q: You're not answering the question, Officer, with respect.  The question is: are you saying under oath, it 's in any way relevant whether the person who's claiming drawback has commercially borne the cost of the duty in some way?

A: There could be a case for that.

Q: There could be a case for that being relevant?

A: There could be a case. There could be a case for that.

Q: On what basis?

A I haven't just come across one, that someone who hadn't paid the duty could claim just , you know, there is −− there is drawback. I know it's happened here −− I −− I get that −− but the reason −− just the government, was not because that they −− that they didn't pay just the duty, or the duty element, or because they tried to just −− just −− you know, just tell us. That is not the reason for the rejection . The rejection just put down the evidence.  (oh dear, oh dear(!))

Probably the officer has been well remunerated for doing routine work and if he/she had been bothered they could have been completely prepared or simply stopped the whole thing from going so far. Madness.
That unit is out of control more than the rest, and that is saying something.  Their internal Sols office and counsel really ought to have settled beforehand but it is not unusual for the Policy officials (or stubborn jobsworths) to try to bluff it out and override the lawyers  It really is a disgrace. But it was obvious what was going to happen. I will be raising it at the next meeting with the HQ staff end of the month.  These people should be held accountable.  Positive is a big fat contingency fee.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: