Posts: 7,711
Threads: 172
Joined: Jul 2022
Reputation:
23
(06-18-2026, 09:16 PM)tHEgLASSdOORS Wrote: I’m not really a believer that banning stuff is the solution. But equally the companies allowing access to content that is clearly unsuitable for young people need holding to account the same way other areas of society are or would be if they put kids in harms way. Unfortunately, for now at least, it may be a sledgehammer is needed to crack the nut. Hopefully, in the end, we have a better balance in the middle.
You only have to look at Jacko going after brown and disabled people to see how vulnerable some users are to indoctrination.
Nurse!
Posts: 8,953
Threads: 166
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
77
The way I read it is that this is a step to putting some guardrails around social media as a base camp rather tan the final solution. Social Media companies will potentially have to start to improve their own controls to get more access for children. Do I see it as solving the problem now, no, is it a step on a journey to improving content moderation, yes.
And the view that this is about kids searching out porn is looking in the wrong direction, it is the way that a ten second view of some influencer will mean their feed being inundated with similar content that needs to change. Social media companies are feeding our kids one side of any viewpoint based on some of their views rather than giving them both sides of any debate - that is the problem, not accessing MILFs.
Posts: 8,841
Threads: 315
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
78
(06-19-2026, 08:56 AM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: Social media does not have physiological effects on development like drugs and alcohol do, I very much support much stricter regulations on gambling advertising for all ages due to its addictive effects on both younger and older people and laws and regulations on what constitutes consent do not just apply to under 16s, even that is contextual e.g. a 15 year old and 16 year olds in a relationship, people older than the 16 not being able to give consent etc.
I have stated very clearly that I do not believe that children are adversely effected by social media than older people. I have stated very clearly the exact regulation I want to be brought in. I've stated very clearly that children are going to use it anyway as do the vast majority of people. I've stated very clearly that this is reinforced by evidence coming out of Australia where it looks to have failed to achieve anything. I have stated very clearly that the routes that people will use to get around this will put them in more vulnerable positions. Nobody has addressed any of those points on here, so why would I bother to change my opinion. Do you and everyone else on here support children's private data being harvested by the methods that will be using to circumvent this? I don't believe you do, what I do believe is that you haven't seriously thought of it as an issue for whatever reason but they're already using free VPNs in Australia to get around this and the reasons why they're free.
As a result, my position is always going to be that advocates for a ban on children getting access should be consistent and call for a total ban if they want to protect children as otherwise it fails to address the equivalent harms on older people or the significant issues, even more problematic, of children's data privacy.
The fundamental issue then is that you don't think children are more vulnerable than adults to harmful external stimuli, which goes against pretty much everything that is known about child development.
A pretty good parallel would actually be age ratings on films. Does this mean that no child ever sees 18 rated films? No, but it does mean that parents and society are aware that the content of these films is not suitable for child and therefore far fewer of them are exposed to this content then would otherwise happen. This is generally viewed as a good thing.
Posts: 17,071
Threads: 614
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
114
06-19-2026, 10:36 AM
(This post was last modified: 06-19-2026, 10:37 AM by Derek Hardballs.)
(06-19-2026, 09:45 AM)baggy1 Wrote: The way I read it is that this is a step to putting some guardrails around social media as a base camp rather tan the final solution. Social Media companies will potentially have to start to improve their own controls to get more access for children. Do I see it as solving the problem now, no, is it a step on a journey to improving content moderation, yes.
And the view that this is about kids searching out porn is looking in the wrong direction, it is the way that a ten second view of some influencer will mean their feed being inundated with similar content that needs to change. Social media companies are feeding our kids one side of any viewpoint based on some of their views rather than giving them both sides of any debate - that is the problem, not accessing MILFs.
Well that’s all very sensible and I agree, but you think this is bad, you should have seen the state of Borin and Proth’s MySpace pages!
Posts: 13,568
Threads: 492
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
40
06-19-2026, 10:58 AM
(This post was last modified: 06-19-2026, 11:07 AM by Borin' Baggie.)
No, the fundamental issue is that I do not believe this will work at all, as do the vast majority of people, and it will result in huge data privacy issues as one of the significant second-order effects. This is backed up by what has happened in Australia with their social media ban and the failings of the Online Safety Act. I've stated multiple times in this thread that chronological timelines being opt-out by default are better and as seen with cookies legislation has a much higher chance of success.
And the evidence from studies track the negative effects of social media usage based on usage, not age. They track the same regardless of age and the social media companies know this hence why they target adults in the same way as children and they know they get better returns on adults. The specific neurological challenges (peer-related) relevant to children are going to cause this to fail just as much as it's failed to stop them playing GTA or watching Deadpool.
(06-19-2026, 10:36 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: (06-19-2026, 09:45 AM)baggy1 Wrote: The way I read it is that this is a step to putting some guardrails around social media as a base camp rather tan the final solution. Social Media companies will potentially have to start to improve their own controls to get more access for children. Do I see it as solving the problem now, no, is it a step on a journey to improving content moderation, yes.
And the view that this is about kids searching out porn is looking in the wrong direction, it is the way that a ten second view of some influencer will mean their feed being inundated with similar content that needs to change. Social media companies are feeding our kids one side of any viewpoint based on some of their views rather than giving them both sides of any debate - that is the problem, not accessing MILFs.
Well that’s all very sensible and I agree, but you think this is bad, you should have seen the state of Borin and Proth’s MySpace pages!
The thing is Dekka I actually was a young person on the internet in the 2000s and early 2010s, I know that me and everyone I knew cycled through links. People ended up going on all sorts of unmoderated sites following those links, that's how all those dodgy forums, videos etc ending up. I managed to end up on some very dodgy sites by accidentally clicking through, do not look up what bug chasers are. The extremely heinous suicide forums date back to then and it was significantly easier to find them accidentally. I also grew up with the emergence of social media and the shift towards that being replaced with moderated spaces. You're being extremely naive as to how much of a wild west the internet was until it was commercialised.
Posts: 8,953
Threads: 166
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
77
I’m not surprised that people will think it will fail if all the talk is of Porn, GTA or watching movies. The key part of this is to get some control over the influencers that are indoctrinating young minds these days. This isn’t about not allowing kids to watch something that the vast majority know is make believe, it is about getting some controls around the feeds that will convince young people that their view is the real world.
Posts: 13,568
Threads: 492
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
40
(06-19-2026, 11:08 AM)baggy1 Wrote: I’m not surprised that people will think it will fail if all the talk is of Porn, GTA or watching movies. The key part of this is to get some control over the influencers that are indoctrinating young minds these days. This isn’t about not allowing kids to watch something that the vast majority know is make believe, it is about getting some controls around the feeds that will convince young people that their view is the real world.
Australia has implemented a ban, 70% of parents post-ban know their children still use social media. The Online Safety Act resulted in a huge spike in traffic outside of the UK indicating that didn't work. Russia's Telegram ban hasn't worked. China's Great Firewall doesn't stop anyone who wants to access the internet outside of China from doing so. There's a huge amount of precedent to show this won't work, and it was significantly easier to regulate physical media like games and film and yet that didn't stop people. And the controls already exist, parents don't use them and they aren't going to be able to stop anyone from bypassing it via this legislation with the best means still being parental browser tools, joint account management tools and obviously parenting kids to limit screen time.
Posts: 17,071
Threads: 614
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
114
I’ve been on the internet since the 90s, the hyperlink thing, just jumped you to sites, but it wasn’t sophisticated, it was clunky, crap quality content that within one click could be avoided. It’s not the same as the insidious bankrolled content that is now allowed or created by very clever but morally questionable people looking to cause harm to not only people but countries.
If you want to equate it to the Wild West still, then I’d argue in the 90s and early 2000s the cowboy was shooting with a Smith and Wesson Colt hand gun, whilst his equivalent now is using a armed to the teeth drone, thousands of miles away, and you’re not entirely sure who for.
|