Mowatt
#31
(03-16-2026, 02:25 PM)Cheshire East Baggie Wrote: I find this analysis of individual players interesting. They all have different qualities and bring different skills to the team, but the tolerance (or otherwise) of posters to their foibles varies wildly depending on the player. It is, for example, perfectly acceptable on here to slag Molumby's every move - never passes forward, can't pass wind, a disciplinary liability, creates nothing (that in a game where he directly assisted a goal btw) etc etc. Lurk famously believes he would pick himself ahead of Molumby.

But when Mowatt has a poor game (and he was roundly criticised by Jez and AJ for his pusillanimous efforts late in the Oxford defeat) there are legions of posters reminding us that "everything we create goes through him", "he's the only one who can pick a pass" and "he should be the first name on the team sheet". Any suggestion that he's lost a bit of pace, he's too cautious, he doesn't jump his height in aerial duels etc is regarded as blasphemy.

Mowatt's had a long career and given good service to three teams in particular. I think at his age, with nearly 500 games in his little legs, he maybe isn't up to the rigours of being in a midfield pair with just two centre backs behind him. I'm hoping that Molumby and Diakite stay fit and Mowatt can play his part as a sub.

I am inclined to agree to an extent. There is a love-in with (and a forgiveness for poor games afforded to) Mowatt, that other midfielders (particularly Molumby - who became an easy spacegoat for some time) simply don’t enjoy. 

I made a sarcy post a while back (perhaps having taken a few too many tranquillisers and painkillers at the time) making that very same point - during the latter Ramsay era - stating that there was one, ever-present, always adored and forgiven constant, within a consistently underperforming midfield. Which was of course aimed at him. If he is indeed that good, and everything ‘was (indeed) going through him’, well… what exactly? Because we were still shit in the middle from my perspective, and indeed remained shit, winning fuck all and drawing at best, until Ramsay had indeed gone. But the bigger point being that everyone’s lover-boy Mowatt was constantly enjoying praise, while others were getting pelters. 

Now here’s the thing. I’m not saying Mowatt was to blame, has ever been, nor am I at all saying he doesn’t offer anything NOR hasn’t a very important role to play in our run in. He does. And I do believe that our first victory coming without him was by coincidence, rather than because of his absence. He was just unlucky/unfit enough to miss out. So is he still important, and do I want to see him in the all-new 4-4-2? Hell yes. In fact, I truly believe that it’s when we’ll get to see the best of Alex Mowatt again, and allow him to do what he does best - create/execute that energy and effective link up between the lines, enjoy the shooting positions he simply WASN’T getting, because - like many others, he wasn’t been coached nor deployed correctly. 

Like all under a new regime, he’s now got to challenge for his place back. Everybody does. Let’s hope he does that, because there is a creativity in him we haven’t seen for far too long, and we do miss his set pieces (especially corners).
Reply
#32
(03-16-2026, 03:29 PM)Birdman1811 Wrote:
(03-16-2026, 02:25 PM)Cheshire East Baggie Wrote: I find this analysis of individual players interesting. They all have different qualities and bring different skills to the team, but the tolerance (or otherwise) of posters to their foibles varies wildly depending on the player. It is, for example, perfectly acceptable on here to slag Molumby's every move - never passes forward, can't pass wind, a disciplinary liability, creates nothing (that in a game where he directly assisted a goal btw) etc etc. Lurk famously believes he would pick himself ahead of Molumby.

But when Mowatt has a poor game (and he was roundly criticised by Jez and AJ for his pusillanimous efforts late in the Oxford defeat) there are legions of posters reminding us that "everything we create goes through him", "he's the only one who can pick a pass" and "he should be the first name on the team sheet". Any suggestion that he's lost a bit of pace, he's too cautious, he doesn't jump his height in aerial duels etc is regarded as blasphemy.

Mowatt's had a long career and given good service to three teams in particular. I think at his age, with nearly 500 games in his little legs, he maybe isn't up to the rigours of being in a midfield pair with just two centre backs behind him. I'm hoping that Molumby and Diakite stay fit and Mowatt can play his part as a sub.

So so true.

It also amazes me those same posters defend Diakite who is technically worse than Molumby but does do even more of the defensive stuff.

Sometimes fans just really dislike a player, I was guilty of it with Ajayi to be fair, none of us are innocent.

True.. Lots took against Furlong, unaccountably. He had plenty of stick on here.
Yet he's demonstrably one of the best RBs in the league. As we've since discovered. Ajayi is in atop 6 team...as, sadly, are half our squad from last season!
Reply
#33
Well for what it's worth Hull City supporters don't seem to particularly rate Ajayi that high either.
Reply
#34
(03-16-2026, 11:04 PM)Johnnykayeengland Wrote:
(03-16-2026, 03:29 PM)Birdman1811 Wrote:
(03-16-2026, 02:25 PM)Cheshire East Baggie Wrote: I find this analysis of individual players interesting. They all have different qualities and bring different skills to the team, but the tolerance (or otherwise) of posters to their foibles varies wildly depending on the player. It is, for example, perfectly acceptable on here to slag Molumby's every move - never passes forward, can't pass wind, a disciplinary liability, creates nothing (that in a game where he directly assisted a goal btw) etc etc. Lurk famously believes he would pick himself ahead of Molumby.

But when Mowatt has a poor game (and he was roundly criticised by Jez and AJ for his pusillanimous efforts late in the Oxford defeat) there are legions of posters reminding us that "everything we create goes through him", "he's the only one who can pick a pass" and "he should be the first name on the team sheet". Any suggestion that he's lost a bit of pace, he's too cautious, he doesn't jump his height in aerial duels etc is regarded as blasphemy.

Mowatt's had a long career and given good service to three teams in particular. I think at his age, with nearly 500 games in his little legs, he maybe isn't up to the rigours of being in a midfield pair with just two centre backs behind him. I'm hoping that Molumby and Diakite stay fit and Mowatt can play his part as a sub.

So so true.

It also amazes me those same posters defend Diakite who is technically worse than Molumby but does do even more of the defensive stuff.

Sometimes fans just really dislike a player, I was guilty of it with Ajayi to be fair, none of us are innocent.

True.. Lots took against Furlong, unaccountably. He had plenty of stick on here.
Yet he's demonstrably one of the best RBs in the league. As we've since discovered. Ajayi is in atop 6 team...as, sadly, are half our squad from last season!

I think as fans we all have favourites and players that endear themselves based on their style of play, character and general fondness for them. Some people prefer technical ability, some prefer visible effort, Josh just prefers Mowatt. This impacts opinions for sure but it keeps this place interesting because if we all thought the same the freds would be pretty dull.
Reply
#35
(03-17-2026, 07:16 AM)HeggebøsBarnDoor Wrote:
(03-16-2026, 11:04 PM)Johnnykayeengland Wrote:
(03-16-2026, 03:29 PM)Birdman1811 Wrote:
(03-16-2026, 02:25 PM)Cheshire East Baggie Wrote: I find this analysis of individual players interesting. They all have different qualities and bring different skills to the team, but the tolerance (or otherwise) of posters to their foibles varies wildly depending on the player. It is, for example, perfectly acceptable on here to slag Molumby's every move - never passes forward, can't pass wind, a disciplinary liability, creates nothing (that in a game where he directly assisted a goal btw) etc etc. Lurk famously believes he would pick himself ahead of Molumby.

But when Mowatt has a poor game (and he was roundly criticised by Jez and AJ for his pusillanimous efforts late in the Oxford defeat) there are legions of posters reminding us that "everything we create goes through him", "he's the only one who can pick a pass" and "he should be the first name on the team sheet". Any suggestion that he's lost a bit of pace, he's too cautious, he doesn't jump his height in aerial duels etc is regarded as blasphemy.

Mowatt's had a long career and given good service to three teams in particular. I think at his age, with nearly 500 games in his little legs, he maybe isn't up to the rigours of being in a midfield pair with just two centre backs behind him. I'm hoping that Molumby and Diakite stay fit and Mowatt can play his part as a sub.

So so true.

It also amazes me those same posters defend Diakite who is technically worse than Molumby but does do even more of the defensive stuff.

Sometimes fans just really dislike a player, I was guilty of it with Ajayi to be fair, none of us are innocent.

True.. Lots took against Furlong, unaccountably. He had plenty of stick on here.
Yet he's demonstrably one of the best RBs in the league. As we've since discovered. Ajayi is in atop 6 team...as, sadly, are half our squad from last season!

I think as fans we all have favourites and players that endear themselves based on their style of play, character and general fondness for them. Some people prefer technical ability, some prefer visible effort, Josh just prefers Mowatt. This impacts opinions for sure but it keeps this place interesting because if we all thought the same the freds would be pretty dull.

I agree. Big Grin
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)