03-15-2026, 10:53 AM
(03-15-2026, 10:33 AM)Vinebaggie Wrote: I think part of the frustration we've all felt stems from the belief that there's always been a half decent football team in the current squad, that were being consistently set up to fail under Ramsay and Mason. Jimmy knows these players strengths and weaknesses better than anyone and doesn't ask them to do things they can't do. Glass half full says we're unbeaten in three, should really have won 2 out of the last 3 and could have won all 3. Really thought we were down and out, but I'm allowing myself a small glimmer of hope.
Is about the square root of it all.
Some people play too much EA26, or are over-awed by the data aspect of it all. They love clever formations and regurgitate trendy terms for ‘getting numbers forward’ or ‘defending as a unit’ that make you yourself want to puke. Others, like Mowbray, would rather we just ‘went out and played’. The truth, as it is so often, lies in the middle.
I’m all for data-driven metrics on player stats and performances, health/injuries, opposition analysis, even signings. But when all is said and done it’s a fairly basic game. You have to pick a team to go out and win, with the right players in the right places to do that. If it works, great. If it doesn’t, change it up a bit. If it works but then they change something and it stops working, you counter that change. Oh, and at the end of it all, and most importantly, don’t forget that it’s most important of all to score more (on an ideal day more than once) than they do (which on an ideal day is zero).
Of course it’s becoming more scientific, but rocket science it ain’t. I’ve been crying out repetitively (and scoffed at) for 4-4-2 for ages, and hey presto, it works.
Will it continue to? Time and player availability (not to mention future opposition analysis on us) will tell. But after what I’ve seen this last week we can do this, the basics way, and - given that for two-thirds of the season over-experimenting led to chronic underperformance - I know which approach I prefer right now.
I think we can worry about over complicating things when we’re facing brilliant teams and chasing the play-offs. At the minute we’re doing neither. We should just keep doing what we’re doing because it is - finally - working, and the games we have left are all winnable ones.

