A captain on the pitch.
#21
I don't really buy into the 'we need a leader' narrative.

If we had sporting director that signed players which left us with a balanced squad when the window closed, and a half competent manager (I believe Mason was competent outside of the 90mins where it matters most!), who could organise a defence, get players doing the basics right, and be proactive during games, rather than reactive, we wouldn't be heading towards League One.

The idea of having a strong character on the pitch suddenly being a golden bullet isn't correct. Jed Wallace seems like a good leader to me, but he isn't having much impact.

I won't criticise the club for sacking Mason, as it was probably the right thing to do. Although, my gut feeling is, and always has been, there's a good manager there. I wish we'd have stuck with him, given hindsight.
Reply
#22
(03-05-2026, 09:55 AM)Brentbaggie Wrote:
(03-05-2026, 08:45 AM)Cheshire East Baggie Wrote: Seems to me that the armband is allocated mostly on the basis of seniority, which is why the very withdrawn Mowatt gets the gig on a regular basis. Since when was life a democracy, eh? The skipper needs to front up to the ref, to his team mates and to the press. The fact that Campbell was made available for interview after Oxford shows that most of the players were hiding.

Sport is a profession for extroverts. Cowards and shrinking violets are less successful, but we seem to have more than our share.

Not too sure about that. Bryan Robson may have been (be?) a drinker but he was no extrovert. He was a leader by example but his shouting and ordering was concise and to the point, especially at United. I think what you're talking about is a far more modern convention than historical. Don't remember Bobby Moore being much of an extrovert. Willie Johnston on the other hand …!

I met Willie Johnston in his Port Brae Tavern. "Can I get you a beer, Bud?" "No pal, you're all right. I'm having tea". I jest not, he had a teapot and poured his tea out into a cup with a saucer. No cucumber sandwiches in sight though..
Reply
#23
(03-05-2026, 07:07 AM)Ted Maul Wrote: The characteristics mentioned in this thread with regards to being a good leader are only useful when combined, as Lurker says with being a good footballer. I think there are a few downplaying how effective McInnes was as a midfielder, he was no yard dog. He was a proper footballer. Unlike the aforementioned Molumby who is shit.

If it's effort and shouting that will keep us up, why don't we just pick eleven guys out of the Brummie Road?

With respect, Ted, I believe you've over simplified there. McInnes was a very tidy player, and certainly no yard dog.  What he did do though was play his game while having a natural ability to organise those around him. Gregan was different but a good captain all the same. He led by example and again was another that organised around him. No one is saying effort and shouting is all that is missing, there's been no shortage of effort, it is organisation that is lacking, hence the goals against.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: