Posts: 1,960
Threads: 80
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
26
(02-23-2026, 07:47 PM)Shabby Russian Wrote: (02-23-2026, 07:25 PM)richbaggie Wrote: (02-23-2026, 07:19 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: (02-23-2026, 06:42 PM)richbaggie Wrote: (02-23-2026, 06:30 PM)Hughie Reed 31 Wrote: Why bother take the 6 points hit
Our problems started by selling the likes of Palmer & Fellows because of PSR other teams get away with
Things why are we so special to be scrutinised by a EFL compliance team
Do you really believe That?
The CFRU scrutinise finances in the EFL and clubs that are close to breaching get extra scrutiny. So yes, given how bad the situation has been, I believe it.
Perhaps they should have prioritised a manager with some EFL experience in the summer instead of giving the job to a rookie and wasting what little money we had to spend on an incoherent mess of a squad.
That's a different discussion.
But perhaps one we should have.
The club, partly because of poor planning, were left in a very difficult situation in the summer. Every first team squad central defender who was on the books last season, left the club before the close of the summer transfer window. Meaning an area of relative strength last season for us, became a priority position for summer recruitment.
To completely change your central defence in one window and do it successfully i think is difficult for any club, but made harder for one that was struggling to meet psr regulations.
It also meant that the areas of the squad which really needed attention, in particular central midfield, was largely ignored in the window. And where we tried to strengthen, by loaning Colliyer failed through no fault of the club.
There's no doubt that the club didn't get it right in the summer, and the inexperience of key personnel of English football was a problem. But given the circumstances it was never going to be great. Agree it's a discussion to have and you've made good points and I agree with them. However, the point of my original post was to disagree with the Josh view that PSR shouldn't be used as an excuse because it's caused severe problems.
Posts: 527
Threads: 0
Joined: Dec 2020
Reputation:
4
(02-23-2026, 07:59 PM)richbaggie Wrote: (02-23-2026, 07:47 PM)Shabby Russian Wrote: (02-23-2026, 07:25 PM)richbaggie Wrote: (02-23-2026, 07:19 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: (02-23-2026, 06:42 PM)richbaggie Wrote: The CFRU scrutinise finances in the EFL and clubs that are close to breaching get extra scrutiny. So yes, given how bad the situation has been, I believe it.
Perhaps they should have prioritised a manager with some EFL experience in the summer instead of giving the job to a rookie and wasting what little money we had to spend on an incoherent mess of a squad.
That's a different discussion.
But perhaps one we should have.
The club, partly because of poor planning, were left in a very difficult situation in the summer. Every first team squad central defender who was on the books last season, left the club before the close of the summer transfer window. Meaning an area of relative strength last season for us, became a priority position for summer recruitment.
To completely change your central defence in one window and do it successfully i think is difficult for any club, but made harder for one that was struggling to meet psr regulations.
It also meant that the areas of the squad which really needed attention, in particular central midfield, was largely ignored in the window. And where we tried to strengthen, by loaning Colliyer failed through no fault of the club.
There's no doubt that the club didn't get it right in the summer, and the inexperience of key personnel of English football was a problem. But given the circumstances it was never going to be great. Agree it's a discussion to have and you've made good points and I agree with them. However, the point of my original post was to disagree with the Josh view that PSR shouldn't be used as an excuse because it's caused severe problems.
It's a reason why it was always likely to be worse than before but it's not an excuse for being this bad.
Posts: 1,735
Threads: 36
Joined: Sep 2022
Reputation:
5
Really interesting all of that Rich. Thanks for explaining. Doesn’t surprise me given the constraints and, for that reason, I don’t expect ER to leave in the short term. The little headroom was why appointing a novice made no sense and why the player recruitment had to be more hit than miss.
Posts: 2,941
Threads: 57
Joined: Jan 2022
Reputation:
25
(02-23-2026, 06:34 PM)ericlegrisly too Wrote: (02-23-2026, 04:35 PM)WorcsWBA Wrote: (02-23-2026, 03:03 PM)Man from delmonte Wrote: I find the criticism of JJA just rather depressing really. He's clearly keen to be here, has an affinity with the club but is being played in a postion he's not a natural in and in a really struggling side. The reward he gets is utter abuse. How lovely some of our 'fans' are.
Indeed. He was here for 10 years and has been at Villa for just 2. The attitudes of some in this thread has been puerile IMO.
Far be it from me to suggest anyone is on a high horse, but...
Considering the third of three dreadful loan signings from the same club to be also dreadful is not, I would contend, exhibiting a puerile attitude.
"JJA" has, thus far in Albion's first team, contributed approximately nothing. It's great that he's a nice lad, I am chuffed he wants to be here and try and help, has an affinity for the club and probably has a smashing family.
How many games has he played for us? What a world it is now where people reach instant judgements on almost everything.
Posts: 7,711
Threads: 172
Joined: Jul 2022
Reputation:
23
(02-23-2026, 09:46 PM)WorcsWBA Wrote: (02-23-2026, 06:34 PM)ericlegrisly too Wrote: (02-23-2026, 04:35 PM)WorcsWBA Wrote: (02-23-2026, 03:03 PM)Man from delmonte Wrote: I find the criticism of JJA just rather depressing really. He's clearly keen to be here, has an affinity with the club but is being played in a postion he's not a natural in and in a really struggling side. The reward he gets is utter abuse. How lovely some of our 'fans' are.
Indeed. He was here for 10 years and has been at Villa for just 2. The attitudes of some in this thread has been puerile IMO.
Far be it from me to suggest anyone is on a high horse, but...
Considering the third of three dreadful loan signings from the same club to be also dreadful is not, I would contend, exhibiting a puerile attitude.
"JJA" has, thus far in Albion's first team, contributed approximately nothing. It's great that he's a nice lad, I am chuffed he wants to be here and try and help, has an affinity for the club and probably has a smashing family.
How many games has he played for us? What a world it is now where people reach instant judgements on almost everything.
JJA passes the 30 mins test that Gilchrist failed. He'll be alright.
Posts: 7,994
Threads: 188
Joined: Jul 2019
Reputation:
37
(02-23-2026, 09:46 PM)WorcsWBA Wrote: (02-23-2026, 06:34 PM)ericlegrisly too Wrote: (02-23-2026, 04:35 PM)WorcsWBA Wrote: (02-23-2026, 03:03 PM)Man from delmonte Wrote: I find the criticism of JJA just rather depressing really. He's clearly keen to be here, has an affinity with the club but is being played in a postion he's not a natural in and in a really struggling side. The reward he gets is utter abuse. How lovely some of our 'fans' are.
Indeed. He was here for 10 years and has been at Villa for just 2. The attitudes of some in this thread has been puerile IMO.
Far be it from me to suggest anyone is on a high horse, but...
Considering the third of three dreadful loan signings from the same club to be also dreadful is not, I would contend, exhibiting a puerile attitude.
"JJA" has, thus far in Albion's first team, contributed approximately nothing. It's great that he's a nice lad, I am chuffed he wants to be here and try and help, has an affinity for the club and probably has a smashing family.
How many games has he played for us? What a world it is now where people reach instant judgements on almost everything.
Whitwell seems to have been written off after 1 cup outing
Posts: 1,170
Threads: 103
Joined: Mar 2024
Reputation:
6
(02-23-2026, 06:15 PM)richbaggie Wrote: (02-23-2026, 08:31 AM)Shabby Russian Wrote: (02-23-2026, 08:20 AM)Josh1873 Wrote: (02-23-2026, 07:28 AM)Shabby Russian Wrote: I would have thought that our issues with psr have something to do with it.
You only have to look at our January signings overall to see that we are still very tight when it comes to conforming with the psr regulations.
A more pertinent question is why Cleary was allowed to go to Barnsley. Was it because the undoubtedly small undisclosed fee was vital for psr compliance or that we underestimated his levels. His goal involvements this season at league 1 in his first full season of first team football suggest someone who might have been a genuinely useful option on the bench rather than the paper candidates we currently have there.
I'm not buying PSR as excuse. Whilst I accept it's made things difficult, it doesn't excuse the absolute dross we've signed over the last 12-18 months.
People talk as if we've had a transfer embargo and can't sign anyone, again, I accept it's been rough, but we have had funds to sign players, but what little funds we've had has been spunked on absolute shite. That's not on PSR, that's because we've had people running the show who haven't a clue what they're doing.
It probably goes along way in explaining why in January, when we needed an injection in quality, we signed 2 18 year old youth players and a 22 year old who had never played at a higher level than league one. Plus a reserve goalie who we only signed on the basis that our reserve goalie left.
You would be right to think that our overall recruitment policy has been weak, but that's worth it's own thread.
The sacking of Mason and his staff reduced what little we had left avaliable because of PSR. Every single thing we have tried to do has been scrutinised by the EFL compliance team. We've not been able to do stuff as a result and had to do stuff we really didn't want to do...all to ensure we comply. Whilst we do have to get better at recruitment, especially around how we utilise the tools we have, to say PSR is not an excuse is plain wrong and totally underestimates how difficult things have been financially this season.
I do wonder should we just have taken a hit. How much have Leicester lost- just 6 points. I don't know their circumstances but I heard they were pretty non-compliant.
I just don't think this PSR has any kind of rigid structure and seems a sham.
Posts: 7,711
Threads: 172
Joined: Jul 2022
Reputation:
23
(02-24-2026, 10:37 AM)PatelsPlatoon Wrote: (02-23-2026, 06:15 PM)richbaggie Wrote: (02-23-2026, 08:31 AM)Shabby Russian Wrote: (02-23-2026, 08:20 AM)Josh1873 Wrote: (02-23-2026, 07:28 AM)Shabby Russian Wrote: I would have thought that our issues with psr have something to do with it.
You only have to look at our January signings overall to see that we are still very tight when it comes to conforming with the psr regulations.
A more pertinent question is why Cleary was allowed to go to Barnsley. Was it because the undoubtedly small undisclosed fee was vital for psr compliance or that we underestimated his levels. His goal involvements this season at league 1 in his first full season of first team football suggest someone who might have been a genuinely useful option on the bench rather than the paper candidates we currently have there.
I'm not buying PSR as excuse. Whilst I accept it's made things difficult, it doesn't excuse the absolute dross we've signed over the last 12-18 months.
People talk as if we've had a transfer embargo and can't sign anyone, again, I accept it's been rough, but we have had funds to sign players, but what little funds we've had has been spunked on absolute shite. That's not on PSR, that's because we've had people running the show who haven't a clue what they're doing.
It probably goes along way in explaining why in January, when we needed an injection in quality, we signed 2 18 year old youth players and a 22 year old who had never played at a higher level than league one. Plus a reserve goalie who we only signed on the basis that our reserve goalie left.
You would be right to think that our overall recruitment policy has been weak, but that's worth it's own thread.
The sacking of Mason and his staff reduced what little we had left avaliable because of PSR. Every single thing we have tried to do has been scrutinised by the EFL compliance team. We've not been able to do stuff as a result and had to do stuff we really didn't want to do...all to ensure we comply. Whilst we do have to get better at recruitment, especially around how we utilise the tools we have, to say PSR is not an excuse is plain wrong and totally underestimates how difficult things have been financially this season.
I do wonder should we just have taken a hit. How much have Leicester lost- just 6 points. I don't know their circumstances but I heard they were pretty non-compliant.
I just don't think this PSR has any kind of rigid structure and seems a sham.
We were past that stage. As Rich says all our incomings are subject to EFL scrutiny before they're authorised for completion.
|