Caleb Taylor
#41
(01-05-2026, 10:24 AM)Lurker#3 Wrote:
(01-05-2026, 09:44 AM)BaggieTom89 Wrote: Typical Albion fans to rave about him after a goal and assist. He's a centre back and was at fault for the Swansea goal ?.

Won't be surprised if he has a solid Championship career but don't think we've sold the next Rio Ferdinand.

Correct. 

He will have a good career and get better into his 30s. Might even follow GMacs lead. 

But everytime I saw him I thought he was a liability. Flat footed, bad body shape, poor positioning. No loss and great PSR boost.

Same here. And I think more than a few agreed with that at the time. I wouldn't put this as a black mark against the leadership, to be honest.
Reply
#42
(01-05-2026, 10:35 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(01-05-2026, 10:24 AM)Lurker#3 Wrote:
(01-05-2026, 09:44 AM)BaggieTom89 Wrote: Typical Albion fans to rave about him after a goal and assist. He's a centre back and was at fault for the Swansea goal ?.

Won't be surprised if he has a solid Championship career but don't think we've sold the next Rio Ferdinand.

Correct. 

He will have a good career and get better into his 30s. Might even follow GMacs lead. 

But everytime I saw him I thought he was a liability. Flat footed, bad body shape, poor positioning. No loss and great PSR 

Let’s see, he’s are far better player than you are suggesting he is.

He looked a lesser player than you are implying.

But that was what it looked like at the time.  Not that much to go on for any of us.  Time will tell.
Reply
#43
(01-05-2026, 10:35 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(01-05-2026, 10:24 AM)Lurker#3 Wrote:
(01-05-2026, 09:44 AM)BaggieTom89 Wrote: Typical Albion fans to rave about him after a goal and assist. He's a centre back and was at fault for the Swansea goal ?.

Won't be surprised if he has a solid Championship career but don't think we've sold the next Rio Ferdinand.

Correct. 

He will have a good career and get better into his 30s. Might even follow GMacs lead. 

But everytime I saw him I thought he was a liability. Flat footed, bad body shape, poor positioning. No loss and great PSR 

Let’s see, he’s are far better player than you are suggesting he is.

Let's see, I don't think he is - yet.
"IMO of course..."
Reply
#44
in the few chances he had he looked lacking of pace, a bit flat footed and needed guiding through games for position etc. It's what you would expect for someone breaking through, the games at Millwall will have undoubtably brought him on. He won't have got quicker, but he may have more positional sense. As a comparison O'Shea coming through looked better, but that doesn't mean players won't develop as they play, clearly he will.

Either way, he really isn't the issue. If Mason was using the players at his disposal correctly then no one would be thinking twice about Taylor. It was a claculated business decision, PSR profit and his poistion replaced with a write off over several years. We need to be the club in the financial position to take advantage of others in this PSR predicament in the coming years.
Trump is a Cunt
Reply
#45
(01-05-2026, 10:40 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(01-05-2026, 10:33 AM)wba13 Wrote: Thinks look easy in hindsight, before the summer transfer ended who would you rather have, Phillips and Mepham or Phillips and Taylor or Mepham and Taylor.  Taylor was never going to stay once we had Phillips , Mepham Bielik and Campbell as back up.
My first choice would be Phillips and Bielik if only Bielik could stay fit.
I also agree Taylor will probably became a very good championship defender will he get to the premiership I hope so but don’t think so.

We have seen absolutely nothing to suggest Mepham or Phillips are any better than Taylor. They regularly xxxx up under no pressure and if they were as good as some argue they are, then they wouldn’t be coming to us at this period in time.

They both had good reputations before they came, it's difficult to argue honestly against that. 
You may also be doing us a disservice as a prospective employer:
  1. We are still one of the better payers despite our troubles.
  2. We had gaps in our defence so they had a good chance of playing regularly.
  3. Up until the last few weeks of the last season, we were still fighting to get in the playoffs and our new manager was widely regarded as having potential.
  4. Unlike a lot of clubs we do have money, so once the ffp restrictions expires or the rules change, we are positioned well for their future careers.
Unfortunately, this season has been a nightmare which has been at the bottom end of everyone's expectations. So maybe, in hindsight, it wasn't such a great move for them.
Reply
#46
(01-05-2026, 10:40 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(01-05-2026, 10:33 AM)wba13 Wrote: Thinks look easy in hindsight, before the summer transfer ended who would you rather have, Phillips and Mepham or Phillips and Taylor or Mepham and Taylor.  Taylor was never going to stay once we had Phillips , Mepham Bielik and Campbell as back up.
My first choice would be Phillips and Bielik if only Bielik could stay fit.
I also agree Taylor will probably became a very good championship defender will he get to the premiership I hope so but don’t think so.

We have seen absolutely nothing to suggest Mepham or Phillips are any better than Taylor. They regularly xxxx up under no pressure and if they were as good as some argue they are, then they wouldn’t be coming to us at this period in time.

Yet if asked during the summer I'd have good money on the vast majority of our fans wanting Mepham and Phillips over Taylor.
Reply
#47
(01-05-2026, 10:40 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(01-05-2026, 10:33 AM)wba13 Wrote: Thinks look easy in hindsight, before the summer transfer ended who would you rather have, Phillips and Mepham or Phillips and Taylor or Mepham and Taylor.  Taylor was never going to stay once we had Phillips , Mepham Bielik and Campbell as back up.
My first choice would be Phillips and Bielik if only Bielik could stay fit.
I also agree Taylor will probably became a very good championship defender will he get to the premiership I hope so but don’t think so.

We have seen absolutely nothing to suggest Mepham or Phillips are any better than Taylor. They regularly xxxx up under no pressure and if they were as good as some argue they are, then they wouldn’t be coming to us at this period in time.
Phillips is better than Taylor. But in the summer if you or anyone had said we were buying both Phillips and Mepham and Selling Taylor I think virtually all Albion fans would have said that’s a good deal. But some things just don’t turn out how you expect.
Reply
#48
(01-05-2026, 10:22 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(01-05-2026, 09:44 AM)BaggieTom89 Wrote: Typical Albion fans to rave about him after a goal and assist. He's a centre back and was at fault for the Swansea goal ?.

Won't be surprised if he has a solid Championship career but don't think we've sold the next Rio Ferdinand.

Fans rated him before he left… sorry to snow on your parade.

Just to add some balance - any time I saw him play, I thought he looked fucking useless.
Reply
#49
As the lad barely played for our 1st team I don't see how so many on here managed to form such strong opinions. Aside from his football ability,  CT is a natural leader, very level headed, young enough to get better and is currently playing for one of the most experienced managers in the Championship. Oh, and he is at a club occupying the play off positions and about 14 places higher than Albion. All I'll add to balance this is that had he stayed he would doubtless have regressed similarly to all our other players.
Reply
#50
He also tended to get picked in makeshift defences for cup games and was never given a run in the side as part of a settled defence. Did he ever play consecutive league games for us?
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: