Sunderland offer hope
#11
(01-02-2026, 11:00 AM)Gzbaggy Wrote:
(01-02-2026, 09:59 AM)MrBater Wrote: Sunderland invested heavily in youth, achieving a crazy high amount of academy players actually playing last season (and before then). They then sold them, or some of them to become self sufficient.


It's exactly what we need to do, but we forgot the part where you have to play the kids to maximize profits when selling them... I think if we had been playing more kids and we're where we are now people would / could understand it far more, but we haven't. Excluding Gruffiths, who'd played before, which Academy players have we played regularly this season? If we don't play them we can't really make a lot of them.

None
Plenty playing for clubs above us in the table

Exactly. I'm fed up when I read negative fans on here saying our kids aren't ready. No clubs kids are ready until they are given a chance FFS. You have to give them their chance and be brave. It's the only way you find out and the only way you really find out about their make up and character.

If they aren't ready you haven't lost anything. You've just gained knowledge as what sort of loan they need going forward. And there will be the ones that have flown under the radar and surprise everyone by flourishing on the big stage. Like Ferguson when Bilic gave him a chance.

Bostock needs his chance now. Whitwell needs to be recalled. Hopefully Alex Williams gets fit as he looked promising. We simply have to get better at giving some youth a chance.
Reply
#12
The clear counter-argument to "they're not ready" is how much worse can it get?

We've watched countless youngsters leave for tennis over the last decade or so as we were always challenging for promotion or fighting relegation and it's tough to bloody but the best youngsters in those conditions. We're now in a position where we can and should throw a couple in, worse case scenario is they're crap and we keep losing, best case one is decent and makes us a few quid in the next couple of seasons. At this point it feels like one of Masons easiest wins with the fans to make sure we see some kids getting game time
Reply
#13
As a few have said you do not know until they play. HOWEVER, so many of our youngsters have done well elsewhere, with Cleary being the latest example, that you start to question why the club will not give them a go. Are managers afraid to drop senior players? We have been told for a few years that we need to develop younger players but do the opposite by buying/signing older players, of which Taylor, Wildsmith and Mepham are recent examples. These tend to stay for 2/3 years and leave for clubs in the lower leagues, Reach being a good example.

If it is true that Bielik was put on the bench last night when unfit, then the likes of Parker and Mohammed must think they are never going to get a chance here.
Reply
#14
Putting an injured player on the bench is another baffling decision by Mason, and one that has no defence.

I just don't see a point where Mason becomes a coach that maximises the resources he has at his disposal, and gets the best out of the players. He's shown nothing to suggest that he's the person to take us forward, and yet he's still in charge.

He's sadly out of his depth, and the longer he's in charge, the greater possibility there is that we become embroiled in a relegation battle.
Reply
#15
(01-02-2026, 12:21 PM)ElbowGrease73 Wrote: Putting an injured player on the bench is another baffling decision by Mason, and one that has no defence.

I just don't see a point where Mason becomes a coach that maximises the resources he has at his disposal, and gets the best out of the players. He's shown nothing to suggest that he's the person to take us forward, and yet he's still in charge.

He's sadly out of his depth, and the longer he's in charge, the greater possibility there is that we become embroiled in a relegation battle.

He's boxed himself in more than once recently with his bench choices. For me it shows he is extremely unimaginative.  Time and again our bench only has around 4 players that he will trust.
Reply
#16
Don't worry, Jed will be back soon.
Reply
#17
(01-02-2026, 06:22 PM)Tom Joad 25 Wrote:
(01-02-2026, 12:21 PM)ElbowGrease73 Wrote: Putting an injured player on the bench is another baffling decision by Mason, and one that has no defence.

I just don't see a point where Mason becomes a coach that maximises the resources he has at his disposal, and gets the best out of the players. He's shown nothing to suggest that he's the person to take us forward, and yet he's still in charge.

He's sadly out of his depth, and the longer he's in charge, the greater possibility there is that we become embroiled in a relegation battle.

He's boxed himself in more than once recently with his bench choices. For me it shows he is extremely unimaginative.  Time and again our bench only has around 4 players that he will trust.

Yep. In all my years watching football i have never seen any manager say that they'd rather put injured players on the bench than young fit players. 

Completely amazed by this.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: