12-11-2025, 11:19 AM
(12-11-2025, 11:03 AM)MrBater Wrote:(12-11-2025, 10:48 AM)SW4Baggie Wrote:(12-11-2025, 09:26 AM)MrBater Wrote:(12-10-2025, 03:42 PM)Gzbaggy Wrote: Pardew and Pulis also fit this criteria.
We do not need another "experienced" manager whose best days are long behind them.
On that basis Carrick fits the bill, experienced in this division, played decent football, and probably has better days ahead... (according to Gemini AI, he's already strongly linked with us! I've not seen any of that except on here).
Pros, no compo, decent football (dependent on squad I suppose?), 46.7% win ratio as a manager, which is bloody high...
Cons - not overly defensive, last two full seasons 'Boro were bang average defensively (62 conceded in 23/24 and 56 in 24/25, for comparison we let in 47 in both, Boro outscored us in both of those seasons though). Plateaued and couldn't push on at 'Boro.
I'd not be against Carrick, but could Josh tell him and Mowatt apart or would he be their sandwich?
Steve Cooper - Pros Again a really high win percentage (47% near enough), holy fuck he's ONLY 46?!!? Did great at Swansea, but that was 4 years ago. Having a great season at Brondby (53% win ratio), organised and structured.
Cons - Average at Forest, shit at Leicester (just 20% wins). We'd have to look at him, which is harsh, but true.
Again, wouldn't be against him.
I think both would be better than Mason, but I think we have to stop saying that, because most managers would probably be, and most would look like they know what they're doing, and more importantly, what they're meaning to do.
Cooper average at Forest? They were in the bottom 3 when he arrived and he took them up that season, then kept them up despite the chaos of Marinakis buying 1000 players.
The man was fantastic at Forest - and look how Leicester capitulated when they replaced him with Ruud!
Maybe I should've added, based on win ratios? Forest just under 39%... which is average compared to his near 45% a Swansea.
A season and a third of that was in the prem.
Cooper should be the number one choice IMO, but I doubt we could get him.

