Great bands that you just don't get.
#81
Genesis
Reply
#82
(10-18-2025, 10:14 AM)Beachboysbaggie Wrote:
(10-18-2025, 09:44 AM)Duffers Wrote: The Beatles were greatest and most influential act of all time. Pretty much every major artist across every genre has cited them as an influence at some point.

The dismissal of them as a “manufactured boy band” makes very little sense when you remember that was only a small part of their overall career (63-65) and they still wrote their own stuff. Would love to see a manufactured act produce material as good as Help, Ticket To Ride, Eight Days A Week, Yesterday, etc. Then they shed all that, with the help of copious amounts of weed and LSD, and produced some of the most varied and experimental music of time, and most of it was great.

You can hear the Beatles influence in their songs, there are early examples of dance music (Tomorrow Never Knows), metal (Helter Skelter), psychadelia (Within Without You), there are even early examples of hip hop beats smattered across their later work.

Lennon, McCartney and Harrison all have individual claims to be amongst the greatest musicians of all time, working together they were unstoppable.

Great post. It’s so easy to be disparaging with 60 years of hindsight. But before the Beatles there were no groups, just solo acts or ‘Johnny & the Somethings’. Nobody wrote their own songs (Buddy Holly excepted). Albums were just a couple of hit singles at the start of each side, padded out with filler and covers. British acts were nowhere to be seen in the US charts. The Beatles changed all that

I would agree on the whole, but they were far better song writers than actual musicians as is demonstrated in the Disney doc, with the exception of McCartney who was/is a huge step above the others and most in musical intelligence. That’s not to discredit the writing contributions of the others, but he was on another level.
In the form of his life.
Reply
#83
How dare someone have a different opinion. OP asked a question expecting answers about great bands that individuals don't get. Greatness not in denial, influence not in denial. Personal tastes are the subject of the thread. As usual fuck all read through or understood by some. Have a great day ALL
Reply
#84
(10-18-2025, 10:50 AM)As Baggiejacko Wrote: How dare someone have a different opinion. OP asked a question expecting answers about great bands that individuals don't get. Greatness not in denial, influence not in denial. Personal tastes are the subject of the thread. As usual fuck all read through or understood by some. Have a great day ALL

This feels like a disproportionately angry response.
Reply
#85
(10-18-2025, 10:52 AM)Duffers Wrote:
(10-18-2025, 10:50 AM)As Baggiejacko Wrote: How dare someone have a different opinion. OP asked a question expecting answers about great bands that individuals don't get. Greatness not in denial, influence not in denial. Personal tastes are the subject of the thread. As usual fuck all read through or understood by some. Have a great day ALL

This feels like a disproportionately angry response.

Absolutely nah

As for not being a manufactured boy band
Did they have a haircut style?
Did they have a dress style?
Did they have a Simon Cowell?
Did they mime a lot?

No question about how much they changed after
Reply
#86
(10-18-2025, 10:55 AM)Baggiejacko Wrote:
(10-18-2025, 10:52 AM)Duffers Wrote:
(10-18-2025, 10:50 AM)As Baggiejacko Wrote: How dare someone have a different opinion. OP asked a question expecting answers about great bands that individuals don't get. Greatness not in denial, influence not in denial. Personal tastes are the subject of the thread. As usual fuck all read through or understood by some. Have a great day ALL

This feels like a disproportionately angry response.

Absolutely nah

As for not being a manufactured boy band
Did they have a haircut style?
Did they have a dress style?
Did they have a Simon Cowell?
Did they mime a lot?

For a couple of years maybe, but they were releasing albums between 1963 and 1970 and only really had that style for the first couple of years. The rest of the time they did their own thing.

They also wrote their own stuff and produced some incredible music during that time”manufactured” era, so quite frankly does it matter?
Reply
#87
(10-18-2025, 11:05 AM)Duffers Wrote:
(10-18-2025, 10:55 AM)Baggiejacko Wrote:
(10-18-2025, 10:52 AM)Duffers Wrote:
(10-18-2025, 10:50 AM)As Baggiejacko Wrote: How dare someone have a different opinion. OP asked a question expecting answers about great bands that individuals don't get. Greatness not in denial, influence not in denial. Personal tastes are the subject of the thread. As usual fuck all read through or understood by some. Have a great day ALL

This feels like a disproportionately angry response.

Absolutely nah

As for not being a manufactured boy band
Did they have a haircut style?
Did they have a dress style?
Did they have a Simon Cowell?
Did they mime a lot?

For a couple of years maybe, but they were releasing albums between 1963 and 1970 and only really had that style for the first couple of years. The rest of the time they did their own thing.

They also wrote their own stuff and produced some incredible music during that time”manufactured” era, so quite frankly does it matter?

Added to which, they spent years learning to be musicians, in Liverpool, Hamburg etc. I'm a few years younger, but remember that Pop music was something from the Golden Land of America, which we could only admire... They wrote and performed (brilliantly) their own songs.
Unheard of!
The Boy Band stuff is just hindsight. There was no such thing until the Monkees (whose music was also surprisingly good - but I guess that was session musicians).
Reply
#88
I realise I was wrong. The Beatles had more of a Louis Walsh than a Simon Cowell. Have a good day gents. I'm off up the match now.
Reply
#89
(10-18-2025, 07:42 AM)Johnnykayeengland Wrote:
(10-17-2025, 04:05 PM)Baggiejacko Wrote: Another vote for The Beatles from this judge. I know they're good but they ain't for me. Original boy band with hair cut and suit style gimmick imo. Radio station gets changed when they come on along with UB40 and Simply Red.  Apologies to fans but we're all different and the world would be a boring old place if we all liked the same

Fair point about "we're all different".
But you're wrong.(Winky face)
The Beatles changed everything. Perhaps you need to be my age to appreciate how different the world was when they came along.
And how much actual fun is - still - in their wonderful songs. 
We're all far too sophisticated to admire "I Wanna Hold Your Hand"... but when it comes on the radio it just bursts out with joy. 60 years on. 
What else is music for?

I'm not a Beatles fan so maybe I should have had them no.1 in the "great" bands you don'tget. Not wanting to cross swords with those here whose opinions I respect so some things are indisputable. 
The Beatles honed their craft (r +r) in Hamburg and had years experience before Brian Epstein gave them the boy band look.
Their early stuff had an energy and sound that is still the essence of the pop revolution.  Where I differ is in that those were uniquely happening times and IMO,  if they hadn't done it, someone else would have. The times were indeed a changing and Buddy Holly and Gene Vincent also deserve much credit. 
For me, for every great song there is a Maxwells SH, a Sgt Pepper,  a Yellow Submarine.  That doesn't ever take away the greatness of All my life, Yesterday or Hey Jude. 
The Beatles influence is all the greater when you factor in their short productive period. Together they were powerful but apart, although each have had moments, they are not quite as memorable. 
I loved 'em till I was about 10 but then discovered the bad boys, The Stones. Then onto other innovators like Bowie, Roxy, Television, Lou Reed. All artists that initiated a genre. 
Not that anyone will be too interested but George's ATMP album is the only thing from them I ever play although (in our family), In My Life has a regular spot at funerals.
The Beatles,  probably the perfect example of what I meant by the OP.  IMO, obviously.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: