How does this work?
(05-13-2025, 09:31 AM)Protheroe Wrote: Restricting immigration for care workers and expecting Brits to take up the slack is simply deranged.

How have they restricted them Proth?
Reply
(05-13-2025, 08:21 AM)tHEgLASSdOORS Wrote: You’ll get a reply that says you must be another Lanyard who wants to destroy disabled people

Have I ever used the term lanyard? No. 

As ever on here, the obligatory… well, well, what would you do question… I’m one person on a midtable Championship football club fans forum. You know when policies are ill thought because this is the last resort when all other excuses for them have been exhausted. 

Firstly I would not have kicked social care down the road, it’s fundamental to both this discussion about carers and those of cuts to disability, not to mention health. That needed to be first and foremost alongside the NHS as a priority, if you don’t solve that you aren’t been serious about solving the other aforementioned problems we face. 

The elephant in the room when we talk about immigration is the UK population is getting older but not healthier, and people aren’t having enough children to fill the gaps in the labour market. Migration is currently still needed, we cannot as a country get away from that. Is this ever addressed? Is the argument ever made that, would you prefer you mom or dad to have a carer from say Zimbabwe or no carer at all? 

Similarly the cuts to disability, solve no problems, they move them to other areas such as the NHS, social care etc. Before you make decisions you should find out from those who work in the sector what they would change to help with the challenges for example those who can work, face when looking for work or retaining a job. This didn’t happen, it was knee jerk policy/cuts first (because of a lack of growth), consultation in retrospect and those experts are still being ignored. 

None of the policies set out by this administration are joined up. For all the performative language and policy announcements these policies won’t save any significant money and don’t address the core problems.

The need for carers doesn’t go away if you restrict access from abroad.
The low birth rate in the UK apart from those migrating here doesn’t change without tackling the cost of living etc
Those who are disabled, don’t in the main become non-disabled and takeaway or reduce their PIP etc 

You argue these are grown up decisions the government are doing, they aren’t they are childish and spiteful populist statements that ignore all the tricky things it doesn’t want to address, ironically for the click bait and headlines you argue people should look past!
Reply
Every population on every continent (except Africa) is heading for a demographic timebomb. It’s a problem much wider than just our state, and when we simply “import” children or young working age people, we put a temporary prop here and create or exacerbate a problem elsewhere
Reply
From what I understand about the data to be released next week your view that immigration will solve the problems are going to fail.

Social care unemployment rates are slightly higher (8%) than the national average but not massively anymore. Social care workers that were granted visas last year was less than 10k (I will look into that figure a bit more at some point btw as the data published by the government today on visas is different to what the care providers are reporting - gov saying 20k ish from a very quick glance over my cornflakes this morning).

Whichever way you look at it the amount of visas is not solving the care crisis and we need to find another solution, training and pay being the obvious routes.
Reply
(05-13-2025, 10:25 AM)baggy1 Wrote: From what I understand about the data to be released next week your view that immigration will solve the problems are going to fail.

Social care unemployment rates are slightly higher than the national average but not massively anymore. Social care workers that were granted visas last year was less than 10k (I will look into that figure a bit more at some point btw as the data published by the government today on visas is different to what the care providers are reporting - gov saying 20k ish from a very quick glance over my cornflakes this morning).

Whichever way you look at it the amount of visas is not solving the care crisis and we need to find another solution, training and pay being the obvious routes.

Who is paying for the better pay? Is Smarmer going to be honest about people having to pay more either through tax or assets? 

You say it doesn’t solve the problem, clearly in its own immigration doesn’t but it does exasperate it. 

As I said it’s either a lack of joined up thinking or an inability for this government to be honest with the electorate about what reducing migration to the care sector will mean to them financially and practically. 

Also I doubt and there is data to support this, people are concerned by legal migration, anywhere near as much as illegal migration.
Reply
As I posted yesterday - the amount of visas available is not the problem, it is the demand for visas. The government can do very little about that.
Reply
Higher taxes - no.
Cheap labour in the form of immigrants from abroad - no.
Putting the onus on those who can work, to work - no.
Building new homes - no.
Making tough decisions - no.
Making easy decisions - no.

Better things for everyone - yes.

Glad we've got to the bottom of it now.
Reply
(05-13-2025, 10:59 AM)Ted Maul Wrote: Higher taxes - no.
Cheap labour in the form of immigrants from abroad - no.
Putting the onus on those who can work, to work - no.
Building new homes - no.
Making tough decisions - no.
Making easy decisions - no.

Better things for everyone - yes.

Glad we've got to the bottom of it now.

Amen. A fine summary of the pervading mentality

(05-13-2025, 10:59 AM)Ted Maul Wrote: Higher taxes - no.
Cheap labour in the form of immigrants from abroad - no.
Putting the onus on those who can work, to work - no.
Building new homes - no.
Making tough decisions - no.
Making easy decisions - no.

Better things for everyone - yes.

Glad we've got to the bottom of it now.

Amen. A fine summary of the pervading mentality
Reply
(05-13-2025, 10:37 AM)baggy1 Wrote: As I posted yesterday - the amount of visas available is not the problem, it is the demand for visas. The government can do very little about that.

1.  They can though - https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/articles/c4gegkkg14ko
2.  Their narrative (and expected policy position) is to do the opposite
Would rather talk to ChatGPT
Reply
(05-13-2025, 10:59 AM)Ted Maul Wrote: Higher taxes - no. 
Cheap labour in the form of immigrants from abroad - no.
Putting the onus on those who can work, to work - no.
Building new homes - no.
Making tough decisions - no.
Making easy decisions - no.

Better things for everyone - yes.

Glad we've got to the bottom of it now.

Who has said this? 

Higher taxes - inevitable and needed, if we want decent public services. This also needs to be better spent, given my experience with the NHS and social care. A tough decision ducked. 

Cheap labour from abroad - well we are constantly told there is a financial black hole left by the Tory government, so I assume this is welcome. Or are they going to explain that care will now cost more in either taxes or the selling of assets? A tough decision ignored. 

The onus on those that can work - absolutely, get those who have never worked and are able into employment, but perhaps when you’re doing that realise many can’t work without the support that PIP provides and that employers either don’t want to or can’t afford to take on staff with access requirements. What happens then? Just make those people poorer? How does that help anyone? Experts ignored or just not consulted. 

Build new homes - yes, but don’t build in areas already suffering from infrastructure problems such as a lack of school places, green spaces, decent roads, doctors, nurseries etc unless they are paid for either by the state or the developer. Don’t just dump poorly designed, cheaply built houses anywhere because it’s the easy option.

Making tough decision - this governments ‘tough’ decisions have almost exclusively been made at the expense of small business, the elderly, the sick and disabled. Not so tough when it comes to upsetting the well off. Ducking social care for the entire term in office is another great example. Tough decisions against the weak so as not to upset the strong. 

Making easy decisions - they make them all the time, pick on the most vulnerable because they don’t have the means or loud voices to make a difference.  

Better things for everyone - erm clearly not, with an extra helping of dividing people into the deserving and non-deserving. What’s the Labour mantra… only working people are worthy of their support or consideration.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 3 Guest(s)