Ratings, long journey home!!
#21
(11-11-2024, 10:58 AM)Stillclem4england Wrote: He needs to go in the summer for the sake of both parties.

January, if we can.
Reply
#22
On Diangana he needs to get back to the form he was showing pre African cup of nations.

I dislike ratings for individual players, football is a team game and an individual performance is dependent on your fellow team mates .

Fir example Fellows is getting some criticism, harshly I think. A couple of occasions yesterday he was able to provide a good cross into the box. No one got on the end of them, but if they had and scored, Fellows would be being celebrated as the next great thing, as it is he is getting stick. As an aside he does need to work on his all round game, but hey what 20/21 year old doesn't.

And again the back 4 is getting justifiable praise, despite the number of first choice back 4 players missing. It just shows how the team as a whole defends well, not just the defenders as individuals.
Reply
#23
Feels like Grady often starts to show promise and put together a few decent games only to get injured again and lose it all.

TBF best thing he did yesterday was winning that free kick in the 94th minute.
Reply
#24
(11-11-2024, 10:59 AM)Josh1873 Wrote:
(11-11-2024, 10:58 AM)Stillclem4england Wrote: He needs to go in the summer for the sake of both parties.

January, if we can.

that's a big "if" given how he's playing, really don't think anyone would want him
Reply
#25
(11-11-2024, 11:09 AM)Shabby Russian Wrote: On Diangana he needs to get back to the form he was showing pre African cup of nations.

I dislike ratings for individual players, football is a team game and an individual performance is dependent on your fellow team mates .

Fir example Fellows is getting some criticism, harshly I think. A couple of occasions yesterday he was able to provide a good cross into the box. No one got on the end of them, but if they had and scored, Fellows would be being celebrated as the next great thing, as it is he is getting stick. As an aside he does need to work on his all round game, but hey what 20/21 year old doesn't.

And again the back 4 is getting justifiable praise, despite the number of first choice back 4 players missing. It just shows how the team as a whole defends well, not just the defenders as individuals.

+1 on Tom, faw shaw
Reply
#26
(11-10-2024, 11:11 PM)chasetownbaggie Wrote:
(11-10-2024, 10:38 PM)wba13 Wrote: Was I watching the wrong match with these pathetic ratings for Palmer. Apart from some of his distribution he had a decent game. A 4 is pathetic he he certainly wasn’t that, same as Mowatt he kept things ticking over without being at his best.
Johnston great first half but nowhere to be seen second half 7 at most.
Isn’t football a strange game it’s all about opinions and mine are different to some on here.


No way was Palmer a 4. Think Josh's judgement may be clouded by the fact he chose to punch and not catch a cross just prior to Hull's goal (I agree with Josh on this, tbf), but he was still assured in rest of the game.
Ironically that was a good punch, but still led to the goal. After that, he did come and catch a few. He's very assured in catching, dunno why he opts to punch so much.
Reply
#27
(11-11-2024, 02:41 PM)Wednesburybaggie Wrote:
(11-10-2024, 11:11 PM)chasetownbaggie Wrote:
(11-10-2024, 10:38 PM)wba13 Wrote: Was I watching the wrong match with these pathetic ratings for Palmer. Apart from some of his distribution he had a decent game. A 4 is pathetic he he certainly wasn’t that, same as Mowatt he kept things ticking over without being at his best.
Johnston great first half but nowhere to be seen second half 7 at most.
Isn’t football a strange game it’s all about opinions and mine are different to some on here.


No way was Palmer a 4. Think Josh's judgement may be clouded by the fact he chose to punch and not catch a cross just prior to Hull's goal (I agree with Josh on this, tbf), but he was still assured in rest of the game.
Ironically that was a good punch, but still led to the goal. After that, he did come and catch a few. He's very assured in catching, dunno why he opts to punch so much.

It's a modern game instruction. I've no idea why, especially when GK's are so protected, that if a GK is so much as breathed on and drops an attempted catch the ref blows for a foul.
Reply
#28
(11-11-2024, 07:14 AM)Jacko Wrote:
(11-11-2024, 06:26 AM)Josh1873 Wrote:
(11-10-2024, 11:11 PM)chasetownbaggie Wrote:
(11-10-2024, 10:38 PM)wba13 Wrote: Was I watching the wrong match with these pathetic ratings for Palmer. Apart from some of his distribution he had a decent game. A 4 is pathetic he he certainly wasn’t that, same as Mowatt he kept things ticking over without being at his best.
Johnston great first half but nowhere to be seen second half 7 at most.
Isn’t football a strange game it’s all about opinions and mine are different to some on here.


No way was Palmer a 4. Think Josh's judgement may be clouded by the fact he chose to punch and not catch a cross just prior to Hull's goal (I agree with Josh on this, tbf), but he was still assured in rest of the game.

If doing ratings then each players starts with a 5 as a base score. If they have a poor game then it's lower. A good game it's higher. 

I've yet to see the goal back, so I'm happy to be proven wrong, but I do believe he was partly at fault for their goal due to punching not catching. His distribution was also woeful, how many times does he kick the ball out of play, or put his team mates under unnecessary pressure with a hospital pass? There was also that goal kick that went out for a corner! 

From memory he made one save from a well hit free kick that was straight at him, and he had the excellent catch (which would have been a far more difficult and dangerous catch than the one would have been for their goal, btw) in injury time. 

I like him, he's a great GK for us, so don't take this as some sort of vendetta. But he really does need to work on his distribution. It's awful. If he can't kick a ball then stop him having it.

Starting score is 6 imo, as per Champ Man/FM. Then adjust from there.

Starting score should be zero. Make the fuckers earn those points!
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: