02-11-2024, 06:40 PM
(02-11-2024, 04:51 PM)Gzbaggy Wrote:(02-11-2024, 02:28 PM)Dreamkiller Wrote:How many of your players have done well after leaving Stoke? I can't think of too many and that is a sign of poor(02-11-2024, 01:17 PM)CorbsIsMagic Wrote:(02-11-2024, 12:24 AM)Dreamkiller Wrote:(02-10-2024, 10:19 PM)SW4Baggie Wrote: Posted on a different thread that I had no idea just how close to the drop you were… I really thought you’d be outsiders for a top 6 spot on the summer as Neil knows his way around the Champ and I felt you’d done some decent business as well as adding a few intriguing players from abroad that would if nothing else, add some interest to things.
What’s happened to the players from the summer spree?
Burger came with a very big rep, and Mmaee and Vidigal looked very strong against us earlier in the season!
Burger's decent. Good attitude and could have a very good career. Bae Jun-Ho and Tchamadeu are both young and could be stars if handled properly.
Other than that though, the rest are as 'meh' as you could get. Vidigal's early goals glossed over what appears to be the most averagely underwhelming player I've seen in a long time. Maybe he's just not being used properly, but he's just shown nothing since he came on and scored the winner against you boys.
Mmaee is similar. I know you-tube videos notoriously and sometimes laughably overegg the pudding, but at present, in comparison to the bloke we saw on the videos, he looks like a competition winner with a goddamn awful attitude to boot. The rest just look remarkable only for their unremarkableness. There's no spark or creativity whatsoever.
Even Pearson, who every Stoke supporter was desperate for us to sign permanemtly, has been a real disappointment. He turned up for pre-season having apparently been on the Charlie Adam eat yourself fitter program, and has been playing catch-up ever since. Add in that every ref books him if he so much as scratches his arse, and all that's left is a liability.
Personally, I'm not sure getting rid of Alex Neil was the right decision. He didn't become a disaster of a manager overnight. But it just keeps happening that players and managers alike turn into utter liabilities within a month or two of joining us. It's been happening consistently now for 8 years or so.
Frankly, it's beyond weird.
Spoke to a Stoke fan I know at work recently and he was saying that managers have been given way too much control in terms of transfers - think that’s the case or maybe does blame lie with any scouting department re transfer flops?
You could ask 5 Stoke supporters and you'd get 5 different responses.
Good managers being given complete control over transfers would usually be a good thing, wouldn't it? Let them build a team with all the interlocking pieces they need.
You could argue that they weren't good managers, but for the most part, they were decent before they joined us.
The recruitment has more recently been placed into the hands of a team which was meant to resemble what Brentford have been doing. What they came up with was a team of one-paced (slow) players, with no goalscorers, wingers who can't beat a man, no fit for purpose left back, no decent keeper, and weak as piss central defenders.
The last 7, maybe 8 years has been an exercise in ticking every box on the 'what not to do' list. And on each occasion, it started, as this thread did, with us saying "This time it looks like we got it right."
recruitment, if they did not do well at Stoke or elsewhere it indicates that you probably should have not bought them in the first place.
Another area that we've cocked up is in not letting players go at the right time. We could have let a number of players go for decent money in our Premier League days, but kept hold for too long to the point where we couldn't give 'em away.
Since we've been relegated though, you're right. Nathan Collins hasn't shone as brightly as we expected, but he's stayed in the Premier League. After that, I'm struggling. Nick Powell ending up at Stockport probably tells its own story.

