West Mids fanbases and boundaries (Brum & BC)
#41
(09-10-2023, 02:54 PM)Tom Joad Wrote:
(09-10-2023, 02:16 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote:
(09-10-2023, 11:24 AM)Tom Joad Wrote:
(09-10-2023, 11:00 AM)ColliersWoodBaggie Wrote: Apparently, in the 19th Century, Wolverhampton was considered 'capital of Black Country' and Dudley was not. It was a Market town which grew economically because of the coal and iron ore nearby. Rather as Walsall and Birmingham did by the 18th-19th Cent. I think it is because traditionalists see the 'Black Country' as part of the South Staffs coal seams (surface and deep). Dudley was Worcestershire pre-1974, and it sits on a limestone cliff, so technically not part of it. Wolverhampton town centre isn't, and suburbs built in the 1930s & 1950s onwards to the north of the centre are not either.

As for the tribalism mentioned by Tom Joad- this is correct. There's footage on You Tube of people being interviewed in Wednesbury, sometime in the 60s,  moaning that all the attention and funding went to West Bromwich once the District /Town Council of West Brom absorbed Wednesbury. And this morning on a Tipton FB site, someone moaned "all the money in Sandwell goes to West Brom".

OP was about BC Boundaries, but also about where the support for each of the 5 West Mids comes from, particularly ours. Overlaps etc. My argument was that we are a mainly BC club, not a Brummie one, due to where our support comes from; and Wolves are less so. Despite the proximity of the ground to Birmingham.

Agree with much of this but remember, Dudley has also been in Staffs previously. I'm still convinced Wolvo has never been BC although accept that the towns it engulfed (Bilston etc) were. Re the OP, my area of Dudley was a straight  split of Baggies/ Dings. My schooldays job, as a milkmon's mairt, meant we covered areas of Tipton. This seemed slightly more Albion. As you got to Coseley it tended to be more Dingle. Obviously though, the side in the ascendancy tends to be the more obvious. The real bodyblow for me is the Premier influence, one day wolves will once again be a minor, noisy, dirty  inconvenience but Villa definitely have a foothold now where they have no right and worse IMO, is the Asian love for Liverpool and Man U.

Dudley was in Worcs. I don't know about the north end of the town that was absorbed but the town centre was always in Worcs dating to the Domesday Book.

I think Tipton was split between Worcs and Staffs, I know it was Worcs though when my Granddad came over (his letters from the 1950s and 1960s have Worcestershire as the postal county).

Smethwick is the funny one, the borough used to contain Harborne (before that was annexed into Warwickshire as it was absorbed into Birmingham) and until the 1960s I believe it was in Staffordshire for its entirety - probably why I saw more Albion fans round there than Villa and Blues when I lived nearby for uni. Then Smethwick was briefly in Worcestershire as it was absorbed into Warley which was a borough of Worcestershire. Which means that if you look at the OS maps in the late 1960s/early 1970s The Hawthorns transcended 3 counties (part of the East Stand was in Warwickshire, part of the Smethwick End was in Worcestershire).
I think you'll find that Dudley, although having much the most of it's history-as you say from the Domesday Book on- in Worcs  has spent a small part of it's history in Staffs. (Even a small part of my childhood).  I think it was because the Castle area may have been in Staffs and the centre of the town and beyond was Worcs.  I'm sure I saw a relative's geneology study as describing some of my ancestors as being from Dudley, Staffs and others, Dudley, Worcs. Somehow Dudley and Warley became an island in Worcs surrounded by Staffs. 
Of course, there is no point in going to war over this now as we are all West Midlanders....

Also, edit, I read once that Worcestershire incorporated much of what is now Pershore Rd. B'ham including Edgbaston Cricket Ground. Think on that, Bears.

Nah, Edgbaston Cricket Ground was always in Warwickshire as it's entirely west of the River Rea and north of the Bourn Brook. The modern day colts pitch/outdoor nets were in pre-1891 Worcestershire as part of the parish of King's Norton but not the ground proper. The dip into Worcestershire on the Pershore Road happened just south of where Cannon Hill Park is, essentially where the Bourn Brook cuts off the Rea. Pre-Birmingham megalith the area to the west of the Rea and north of the Bourn Brook was Edgbaston (Warks, since time immemorial), the area west of the Rea and south of the Bourn Brook was Selly Oak (Worcs) and the area east of the Rea was King's Norton (Worcs). So Warwickshire have never had a home ground inside the county of Worcestershire, can't say the same with the Pears having a home ground in Warwickshire though (cough, Bournville, cough).

If the link works, this OS map shows it. The dotted lines show the boundaries pretty nicely, and refute your disgusting assertion.

Speaking of Worcestershire CCC, my granddad used to sometimes watch the Pears at Tipton Road when he first moved over. Anyone know what the hell happened to that ground? I know there was a sinkhole but that's it.
Reply
#42
Nice map Borin', especially the bit where you can superimpose the modern aerial view. Good to see the old Six Ways in Smethwick (down the bottom end of Windmill Lane). 

So the place that the Hawthorns is sited was actually called the Hawthorns before the Albion moved there. I knew it was full of hawthorn bushes but didn't realise that was the acknowledged name back then.
Reply
#43
(09-10-2023, 03:12 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote:
(09-10-2023, 02:54 PM)Tom Joad Wrote:
(09-10-2023, 02:16 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote:
(09-10-2023, 11:24 AM)Tom Joad Wrote:
(09-10-2023, 11:00 AM)ColliersWoodBaggie Wrote: Apparently, in the 19th Century, Wolverhampton was considered 'capital of Black Country' and Dudley was not. It was a Market town which grew economically because of the coal and iron ore nearby. Rather as Walsall and Birmingham did by the 18th-19th Cent. I think it is because traditionalists see the 'Black Country' as part of the South Staffs coal seams (surface and deep). Dudley was Worcestershire pre-1974, and it sits on a limestone cliff, so technically not part of it. Wolverhampton town centre isn't, and suburbs built in the 1930s & 1950s onwards to the north of the centre are not either.

As for the tribalism mentioned by Tom Joad- this is correct. There's footage on You Tube of people being interviewed in Wednesbury, sometime in the 60s,  moaning that all the attention and funding went to West Bromwich once the District /Town Council of West Brom absorbed Wednesbury. And this morning on a Tipton FB site, someone moaned "all the money in Sandwell goes to West Brom".

OP was about BC Boundaries, but also about where the support for each of the 5 West Mids comes from, particularly ours. Overlaps etc. My argument was that we are a mainly BC club, not a Brummie one, due to where our support comes from; and Wolves are less so. Despite the proximity of the ground to Birmingham.

Agree with much of this but remember, Dudley has also been in Staffs previously. I'm still convinced Wolvo has never been BC although accept that the towns it engulfed (Bilston etc) were. Re the OP, my area of Dudley was a straight  split of Baggies/ Dings. My schooldays job, as a milkmon's mairt, meant we covered areas of Tipton. This seemed slightly more Albion. As you got to Coseley it tended to be more Dingle. Obviously though, the side in the ascendancy tends to be the more obvious. The real bodyblow for me is the Premier influence, one day wolves will once again be a minor, noisy, dirty  inconvenience but Villa definitely have a foothold now where they have no right and worse IMO, is the Asian love for Liverpool and Man U.

Dudley was in Worcs. I don't know about the north end of the town that was absorbed but the town centre was always in Worcs dating to the Domesday Book.

I think Tipton was split between Worcs and Staffs, I know it was Worcs though when my Granddad came over (his letters from the 1950s and 1960s have Worcestershire as the postal county).

Smethwick is the funny one, the borough used to contain Harborne (before that was annexed into Warwickshire as it was absorbed into Birmingham) and until the 1960s I believe it was in Staffordshire for its entirety - probably why I saw more Albion fans round there than Villa and Blues when I lived nearby for uni. Then Smethwick was briefly in Worcestershire as it was absorbed into Warley which was a borough of Worcestershire. Which means that if you look at the OS maps in the late 1960s/early 1970s The Hawthorns transcended 3 counties (part of the East Stand was in Warwickshire, part of the Smethwick End was in Worcestershire).
I think you'll find that Dudley, although having much the most of it's history-as you say from the Domesday Book on- in Worcs  has spent a small part of it's history in Staffs. (Even a small part of my childhood).  I think it was because the Castle area may have been in Staffs and the centre of the town and beyond was Worcs.  I'm sure I saw a relative's geneology study as describing some of my ancestors as being from Dudley, Staffs and others, Dudley, Worcs. Somehow Dudley and Warley became an island in Worcs surrounded by Staffs. 
Of course, there is no point in going to war over this now as we are all West Midlanders....

Also, edit, I read once that Worcestershire incorporated much of what is now Pershore Rd. B'ham including Edgbaston Cricket Ground. Think on that, Bears.

Nah, Edgbaston Cricket Ground was always in Warwickshire as it's entirely west of the River Rea and north of the Bourn Brook. The modern day colts pitch/outdoor nets were in pre-1891 Worcestershire as part of the parish of King's Norton but not the ground proper. The dip into Worcestershire on the Pershore Road happened just south of where Cannon Hill Park is, essentially where the Bourn Brook cuts off the Rea. Pre-Birmingham megalith the area to the west of the Rea and north of the Bourn Brook was Edgbaston (Warks, since time immemorial), the area west of the Rea and south of the Bourn Brook was Selly Oak (Worcs) and the area east of the Rea was King's Norton (Worcs). So Warwickshire have never had a home ground inside the county of Worcestershire, can't say the same with the Pears having a home ground in Warwickshire though (cough, Bournville, cough).

If the link works, this OS map shows it. The dotted lines show the boundaries pretty nicely, and refute your disgusting assertion.

Speaking of Worcestershire CCC, my granddad used to sometimes watch the Pears at Tipton Road when he first moved over. Anyone know what the hell happened to that ground? I know there was a sinkhole but that's it.

That is it, it fell into the ground! Is now a hotel/cinema complex. I saw Worcs there numerous times. The ground was opened with a game vs Australia, 30,000 attended.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: