CL Twatter
(08-14-2023, 01:49 PM)NewWanker Wrote: So Warm front loaned WBA holdings the money, so they can claim some shares in that, which means they own a couple of percent shares in the club? How's that make a sale harder? Don't we have 12% of shares with fans and others already anyway? If someone bought 84% instead of 87% what difference does it make?

Surely it's actually more positive that Warm Front can 'only' claim some shares in WBA Holdings rather than the club? Is it holdings that own the 88% (or whatever) of the club, so someone would buy them anyway?

It’s an even smaller percent as it’s 2.85% of the 88%

If that small percentage of WBA group Ltd does end up in the hands of warmfront, they will be included in the minority shareholders and Lai can sell the rest without the agreement from the minority shareholders as he is selling HIS remaining shares from Holdings Ltd.  This is a transaction purely in the books of Holdings Ltd and has nothing to do with Group, other than waterfront may acquire a small percentage of Group shares.



The
Reply
So it looks like this £20M loan (or rather, the conditions attached to it), might actually be useful inasmuch as it prevents many further shenanigans from Lai?
Also, much credit to the minority shareholders, they may have saved the club for a second time.
Reply
(08-14-2023, 03:46 PM)Fulham Fallout Wrote:
(08-14-2023, 01:49 PM)NewWanker Wrote: So Warm front loaned WBA holdings the money, so they can claim some shares in that, which means they own a couple of percent shares in the club? How's that make a sale harder? Don't we have 12% of shares with fans and others already anyway? If someone bought 84% instead of 87% what difference does it make?

Surely it's actually more positive that Warm Front can 'only' claim some shares in WBA Holdings rather than the club? Is it holdings that own the 88% (or whatever) of the club, so someone would buy them anyway?

It’s an even smaller percent as it’s 2.85% of the 88%

If that small percentage of WBA group Ltd does end up in the hands of warmfront, they will be included in the minority shareholders and Lai can sell the rest without the agreement from the minority shareholders as he is selling HIS remaining shares from Holdings Ltd.  This is a transaction purely in the books of Holdings Ltd and has nothing to do with Group, other than waterfront may acquire a small percentage of Group shares.



The

Their deal only relates to Warmfront only being able to take shares in Holdings, not in Group.  There is no current mechanism
by which Warmfront would own shares in Group unless they are sold to Warmfront by Holdings.
Reply
The MSN loan offers protection from asset stripping, the danger is if an incoming minority shareholder provides sufficient funds to pay it back - removing the protection provided by the charge and exposing us to said asset stripping. Bearing in mind also that a minority shareholder wouldn’t be subject to any fit & proper test.
Reply
Then there's the lesser known Warmfront Holdings loan. This is a different type of loan in that it doesn't particularly concern West Bromwich Albion as a football club. They're not out of pocket from it, nor are they the beneficiaries of it. The £2m loan, dated as September 2021, was borrowed by Lai from Warmfront Holdings and, in doing so, secured 2.35% of his shares in Albion against that loan through West Bromwich Albion Holdings.
That £2m loan was agreed with a 5% monthly interest rate from June 2022. At any rate, as it was stated in the Holdings accounts earlier this year, Warmfront 'will not take any action to seek or enforce any or all sums of money until at least 8 February 2024."


It's understood that while the interest rate will continue to pile up in the period of time that it isn't repaid, the 2.35% is only secured against the original £2m sum borrowed by Lai through Holdings. What happens, then if - and, likely, when - that money is returned to Warmfront? Then they'll conceivably be able to claim 2.35% of Holdings - which in turn owns nearly 88% of Group, which covers the football club among other things.

https://www.birminghammail.co.uk/sport/f...n-27520187


Reply
That £2m loan being secured against 2.35% equity in Holdings looks - at a high level, obviously without seeing all the detail - the worst piece of securitisation of all time. At a 100% LTV it values Holdings at just over £85m.
Reply
(08-14-2023, 06:21 PM)Malcolm Tucker Wrote: That £2m loan being secured against 2.35% equity in Holdings looks - at a high level, obviously without seeing all the detail - the worst piece of securitisation of all time. At a 100% LTV it values Holdings at just over £85m.

I did think the same thing in that respect
Someone could have been killed
Reply
So what’s to stop a calculated management charge from Holdings down to the club?

Legitimate costs for Lai or other board members expertise?

(I haven’t read the debenture)
Trump is a Cunt
Reply
(08-14-2023, 07:19 PM)CA Baggie Wrote: So what’s to stop a calculated management charge from Holdings down to the club? 

Legitimate costs for Lai or other board members expertise?

(I haven’t read the debenture)

No way MSD will believe that!
Reply
(08-14-2023, 07:19 PM)CA Baggie Wrote: So what’s to stop a calculated management charge from Holdings down to the club? 

Legitimate costs for Lai or other board members expertise?

(I haven’t read the debenture)

There’s everything to stop it.  A management charge has to be bona fide, which means that Holdings  would have to justify what services it is providing for that fee.  Holdings is a holding company with no staff.  There are no commercially justifiable services that it could provide for a fee.  MSD certainly wouldn’t allow it either as it would be a sham.

It’s impossible to do that sort of thing when your every move is being watched by the minority shareholders, by MSD, the auditors and the EFL.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: