05-30-2023, 01:06 PM
It could all be worse. We could be Italian lake tourists or Canadian homeless...
|
Apologies to Proth
|
|
05-30-2023, 01:06 PM
It could all be worse. We could be Italian lake tourists or Canadian homeless...
05-30-2023, 02:28 PM
(05-30-2023, 10:21 AM)Protheroe Wrote:(05-30-2023, 07:23 AM)baggy1 Wrote: What a bizarre statement, I'm not entirely certain where depositor protection equates to a transfer of wealth, especially a direct transfer, when those that want a safe place for their cash are prepared to place it with someone that protects it and that has a guarantee attached. Maybe everyone should just gamble their future away in true Tory style of the past decade with the promise of the possibilities of wealth beyond their needs. What are you talking about? Are you referring to the bailout of the banks or the FSCS, they are two different things that you appear to be confusing.
05-31-2023, 10:15 AM
(05-30-2023, 02:28 PM)baggy1 Wrote: What are you talking about? Are you referring to the bailout of the banks or the FSCS, they are two different things that you appear to be confusing. They're wholly related in respect of moral hazard. £85,000 per person, per institution is a crazy level of protection for HNW people who lend their money to banks. Or are you fine with moral hazard? I knew I was taking a risk chasing interest rates with Kaupthing & Landsbanki. After the event I didn't expect to be compensated. As it is tens of thousands of UK residents did get all their deposits back from wholly insolvent institutions. This was not, and should not be the basis for global banking. In 2008 governments nationalised risk and have shown no inclination to privatise it again. If you want to rub the noses of the young and asset poor in the dirt I can't think of a better way to do it. Indiscriminate transfers through Covid and Energy prices have just made matters worse.
05-31-2023, 01:02 PM
Moral hazard
, someone has been listening to too many podcasts ![]() You live in a vacuum obviously, what do you think would happen if the FSCS was reduced to £50k or £25k? It would reduce the amounts that individuals place with the banks. And then what do you think would happen to the amount banks would lend for overdrafts and mortgages if the amount of money that they have in interest paying accounts reduces. Simply bizarre thinking. And you probably need to get back up to date with how much the FSCS actually paid out in the longer term for Iceland bank protection. https://www.gov.uk/government/news/uk-au...om-icesave I swear to god, you simply don't understand what these institutions are there for, it isn't a blind guarantee. It is there to provide the individual with the refund whilst a government 'class action' takes place. There have been a few comments over time from you about banking and regulation around it and every time you comment it shows how little you know on the subject. I'd focus on housing if I were you, or some other subject that you might have some idea about.
I'm amazed that someone on the left of politics can be so prepared to use the state to underwrite banks - almost without limit. It's truly astounding.
The UK government got its money back from Landsbanki after 8 years. It didn't get anything further from Kaupthing after liquidating its UK business. Here's a helpful guide to credit creation btw, as I swear to God you don't you simply don't understand it: How Banks Make Loans in the Real World In today’s modern economy, most money takes the form of deposits, but rather than being created by a group of savers entrusting the bank with holding their money, deposits are actually created when banks extend credit (i.e., create new loans). As Joseph Schumpeter once wrote, “It is much more realistic to say that the banks 'create credit,' that is, that they create deposits in their act of lending than to say that they lend the deposits that have been entrusted to them.” When a bank makes a loan, there are two corresponding entries that are made on its balance sheet, one on the assets side and one on the liabilities side. The loan counts as an asset to the bank and it is simultaneously offset by a newly created deposit, which is a liability of the bank to the depositor holder. Contrary to the story described above, loans actually create deposits. Now, this may seem a bit shocking since, if loans create deposits, private banks are creators of money. But you might be asking, "Isn’t the creation of money the central banks’ sole right and responsibility?" Well, if you believe that the reserve requirement is a binding constraint on banks’ ability to lend then yes, in a certain way banks cannot create money without the central bank either relaxing the reserve requirement or increasing the number of reserves in the banking system. The truth, however, is that the reserve requirement does not act as a binding constraint on banks’ ability to lend and consequently, their ability to create money. The reality is that banks first extend loans and then look for the required reserves later.
Oh dear - you've googled something that you don't understand. At least credit Investopedia when you cut and paste their information without the slightest idea of what it means.
And being left of you doesn't necessarily put me on the left of politics. If it helps with your understanding of banking in the UK look at the Capital Requirements Directive and Solvency II
It's much better getting the facts from Investopedia than suggesting modern banking is something equivalent to a provincial building society in the 1950s.
It's also clear that from your posts you don't value competition in the banking sector, the lack of which in the UK is the feedback loop for ridiculously high deposit guarantees to ward off systemic threat. That seems like the very definition of moral hazard to me.
I'm loving the moral hazard approach to your commentary. I'm guessing that is the new libertarian buzzphrase that we'll hear more about.
What competition do you think is lacking in the UK banking sector, you have multiple choices for getting loans, different types of bank account that suits your needs, interest rates on savings that reflect the market. This is all underpinned by the PRA and the FCA through their regulations and oversight, that leads to protection for the consumer through CCA and the new consumer duty. You're still confusing two concepts - the bailout of the banks was a political decision that steadied the market for millions of customers; and then the FSCS which is a government guarantee for anyone with any savings, this is based on the institution that has that protection being regulated in the UK. That regulation allows some insurance for the government to reclaim the funds outlaid (an example of which I gave you above that you appeared completely unaware of). You've discussed less regulation before and when questioned which aspect of the Solvency II regulation you would want to remove or reduce you just ignore the question because you simply have no idea. At a guess I'd say you've been to a few presentations and talks from 'experts' on what would be a better model for the banking sector which would probably benefit the few that can take advantage of the riskier approach. The banking sector works for the vast majority of the population in the UK and they have the protection they need from unscrupulous actors. It's not perfect but regulations such as the Consumer Duty and the proposals around the Edinburgh Reforms are improving the impact on the customer whilst giving banks / business better instruction. As for suggesting my understanding of modern banking is based on a model from the 1950s, I've been in Financial Services for the last decade. I do have an idea of what is happening, albeit always learning. I would take that experience over a few TED talks and an audit of the council's treasury department in 1997 |
|
« Next Oldest | Next Newest »
|