A fairer way than penalties to decide play-offs?
#21
MLS style penalties?
Reply
#22
(05-29-2023, 04:27 PM)ItsAGoal Wrote: MLS style penalties?

Why?
Reply
#23
(05-29-2023, 04:43 PM)Pragmatist Wrote:
(05-29-2023, 04:27 PM)ItsAGoal Wrote: MLS style penalties?

Why?

They appear to require more skill, e.g.:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_bOPd9oHrGg

But I agree they are no substitute for a game over 90 minutes.
Just play on indefinitely until there is a result was the old way. Was that so bad?

Or withdraw players every 10 minutes down to a Battle of Brammel Lane style 7 aside?

Force fans to watch Ted Lasso - last one standing wins?
Reply
#24
(05-29-2023, 04:48 PM)ItsAGoal Wrote:
(05-29-2023, 04:43 PM)Pragmatist Wrote:
(05-29-2023, 04:27 PM)ItsAGoal Wrote: MLS style penalties?

Why?

They appear to require more skill, e.g.:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_bOPd9oHrGg

But I agree they are no substitute for a game over 90 minutes.
Just play on indefinitely until there is a result was the old way.  Was that so bad?

Or withdraw players every 10 minutes down to a Battle of Brammel Lane style 7 aside?

Force fans to watch Ted Lasso - last one standing wins?

TV schedules can just about cope with extra time and penalties. It’s a degree of certainty.  They’d never cope with a “golden goal” or withdrawing of players which could go on for ever
Reply
#25
I’d like to see an idea that was suggested about 20 years and that I’ve never seen implemented. Take the penalty shootout before extra time, and the team that comes out top on that goes into extra time with a nominal half goal advantage. The team that lost the penalty shootout then has 30 minutes to try and win the game by outscoring their opponents. Draw after 30 minutes and the penalty winners prevail.

Can’t see a flaw in that, myself.
Reply
#26
(05-29-2023, 09:56 PM)Old Stroller Wrote: I’d like to see an idea that was suggested about 20 years and that I’ve never seen implemented. Take the penalty shootout before extra time, and the team that comes out top on that goes into extra time with a nominal half goal advantage. The team that lost the penalty shootout then has 30 minutes to try and win the game by outscoring their opponents. Draw after 30 minutes and the penalty winners prevail.

Can’t see a flaw in that, myself.

The likely flaw, as with the OP, is that the team with the advantage would likely park the bus. I find penalties deeply unsatisfactory too. I like the sudden death idea. I also like how the National League do play offs which weight the playoffs in favour of the higher placed team.
Reply
#27
(05-30-2023, 08:06 AM)chasetownbaggie Wrote:
(05-29-2023, 09:56 PM)Old Stroller Wrote: I’d like to see an idea that was suggested about 20 years and that I’ve never seen implemented. Take the penalty shootout before extra time, and the team that comes out top on that goes into extra time with a nominal half goal advantage. The team that lost the penalty shootout then has 30 minutes to try and win the game by outscoring their opponents. Draw after 30 minutes and the penalty winners prevail.

Can’t see a flaw in that, myself.

The likely flaw, as with the OP, is that the team with the advantage would likely park the bus. I find penalties deeply unsatisfactory too. I like the sudden death idea. I also like how the National League do play offs which weight the playoffs in favour of the higher placed team.

Agree on the weighting part, expanding the playoffs to 6 teams also adds a real element of jeopardy and could lead to some very interesting teams winning promotion from the Champ, and May offset the parachute payments complaints so many sides have. 

Problem with penalties being played before ET is the amount of time they take to do - especially if it goes to sudden death. You could have large number of the players not involved for a prolonged period then ask them to go straight back into intense football for 30 mins which isn’t good for their bodies.

The current system of 90 mins + ET+ pens is as good as it’s going to get IMO… Though I would like the golden goal reintroduced for ET,and if there’s no score in 30 mins you go to pens.
Reply
#28
I was never a fan of golden goal. Led to cagey, non risk football as both sides were scared to gamble and leave themselves open.
Reply
#29
You could argue that the two-legged semi-finals provide better entertainment and more drama. So, why not have a two-legged final, highest placed team 2nd leg at home, and fuck Wembley off altogether.
Reply
#30
(05-30-2023, 04:48 PM)Tom Joad Wrote: I was never a fan of golden goal. Led to cagey, non risk football as both sides were scared to gamble and leave themselves open.

Agree with this
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: