Posts: 17,074
Threads: 614
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
114
(05-17-2023, 01:52 PM)Birdman1811 Wrote: I see now it's either love Mowbray or hate him, all middle ground is ignored.
Honestly, it's getting boring.
Even with my usual sensibilities, I loved our promotion under him, though had concerns about the next season, concerns which sort of came true, but he tried to adapt, arguably, like Val more recently, making it worse by doing so.
I don't care about him leaving, fans whine, but so many want a manager sacked for losing a game. There's twitter folks and Facebook idiots wanting Carlos Corberan sacked. Clubs sack managers without a seconds thought, why should managers show any loyalty? Same for players too.
He has rebuilt his reputation since Celtic, dropping down leagues to take jobs and his teams still play decent football but with a lot more cynicism and defensive rigidity nowadays. He's a good Championship manager, which isn't a slight at all.
I don’t think he’s a poor manager or a exceptionally good one, I think he’s an average Champ manager which is still at an incredibly high level in the game but I’m not going to blow smoke up his bottom for getting us up that season given the resources he had. No I’ll feeling about him leaving that’s football but probably wasn’t a great idea to demand loyalty from the players when he didn’t show any
Posts: 2,941
Threads: 57
Joined: Jan 2022
Reputation:
25
(05-17-2023, 02:20 PM)cornishbaggie Wrote: I will never understand the negativity about a manager that came within a whisker of emulating the unique double that only we have achieved, took us to a play off final and got us promoted winning our only meaningful silverware in 40 years.
As for the comments of getting promoted with less points than Megson, Bilic or RDM, he won the title with his 81.
Great post, which sums things up for me. Delivering what was our first league title since 1920 was no mean feat and, of course, hasn't been repeated since either, and yet some are disparaging about it because we "only" got 81 points and that the squad that Mogga had should have won the title anyway.
There are plenty of great squads on paper down the years who should have achieved things but didn't - try asking the Chelsea fans how it's gone this season. Our squad that scraped third place in 1976 (scoring just 50 goals in 42 games and with what would have been 73 points if it was 3 points for a win) - they must have been a right bunch of losers!
Posts: 10,866
Threads: 497
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
23
(05-17-2023, 01:52 PM)Birdman1811 Wrote: I see now it's either love Mowbray or hate him, all middle ground is ignored.
Honestly, it's getting boring.
Even with my usual sensibilities, I loved our promotion under him, though had concerns about the next season, concerns which sort of came true, but he tried to adapt, arguably, like Val more recently, making it worse by doing so.
I don't care about him leaving, fans whine, but so many want a manager sacked for losing a game. There's twitter folks and Facebook idiots wanting Carlos Corberan sacked. Clubs sack managers without a seconds thought, why should managers show any loyalty? Same for players too.
He has rebuilt his reputation since Celtic, dropping down leagues to take jobs and his teams still play decent football but with a lot more cynicism and defensive rigidity nowadays. He's a good Championship manager, which isn't a slight at all.
Spot on.
Posts: 7,973
Threads: 254
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
6
The Gnuurker has been done to death on here. IMO
He underperformed that 2006/07 season. The toxic dressing room is mitigation (and we all know the issues that brings over the last few years) but his points went return was well below par given the team we had
He deserves credit for 2007/08. We did enough and got to the title playing good stuff as well. We got there ahead of Stoke who were also strong on paper. We had a nice draw to the semis but were then unlucky to get Pompey. We would of beaten Barnsley and probably had enough for Cardiff
He was poor in 2008/09. He bought poorly and gave JG Valero and Kim way too much game time in centre midfield. He could of used Dozza and Mulumbu much more. His tactics in the winnable games were poor and Stoke/Hull finished well ahead of us
He is a much better manager now after his experiences at Cov and Blackburn. He’s done an excellent job this season. Sunderland should be around 14th. After Robins - he is arguably MOTY (along with Edwards and Kompany).
Posts: 782
Threads: 40
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
6
Posts: 1,182
Threads: 43
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
2
(05-18-2023, 05:49 PM)MancBaggie Wrote: The Gnuurker has been done to death on here. IMO
He underperformed that 2006/07 season. The toxic dressing room is mitigation (and we all know the issues that brings over the last few years) but his points went return was well below par given the team we had
He deserves credit for 2007/08. We did enough and got to the title playing good stuff as well. We got there ahead of Stoke who were also strong on paper. We had a nice draw to the semis but were then unlucky to get Pompey. We would of beaten Barnsley and probably had enough for Cardiff
He was poor in 2008/09. He bought poorly and gave JG Valero and Kim way too much game time in centre midfield. He could of used Dozza and Mulumbu much more. His tactics in the winnable games were poor and Stoke/Hull finished well ahead of us
He is a much better manager now after his experiences at Cov and Blackburn. He’s done an excellent job this season. Sunderland should be around 14th. After Robins - he is arguably MOTY (along with Edwards and Kompany).
Great summary there Manc and pretty much my thoughts too, i had no issue with him moving onto Celtic and he did well for us, i just dont think he warrants the adulation that he is shown by some on here because we won the second tier title, a trophy won by Leicester 7 times and Norwich 5 times. Someone even compared it to winning the top flight in 1920 as if it was the same achievement because it was a title.
Posts: 2,955
Threads: 67
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
12
All the above may be true. I just remember enjoying certain seasons because of the football we played. And Mowbray's teams, with the best midfield in the world, (far better than man city) were just great to watch.
|