You didn't know what you were voting for...
#11
(05-02-2023, 12:07 PM)Ted Maul Wrote: 100% agree Proth.

This stupid island will get the leader it deserves at the next election, whether that be full-fat Tory or Diet Tory. How any genuine Labour man or woman can look at what's happened to the party in the last three years and be proud is beyond me.

The problem is Ted the Ooh Jeremy Corbyn version of Labour would see them in permanent opposition. Now you can be proud of your principles but they help no one but placard makers, permanent maker manufacturers and loud hailer salespeople. 

They failed and until those who supported them accept responsibility for that then they are forever going to be shouting into the void.
Reply
#12
(05-02-2023, 02:14 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(05-02-2023, 12:07 PM)Ted Maul Wrote: 100% agree Proth.

This stupid island will get the leader it deserves at the next election, whether that be full-fat Tory or Diet Tory. How any genuine Labour man or woman can look at what's happened to the party in the last three years and be proud is beyond me.

The problem is Ted the Ooh Jeremy Corbyn version of Labour would see them in permanent opposition. Now you can be proud of your principles but they help no one but placard makers, permanent maker manufacturers and loud hailer salespeople. 

They failed and until those who supported them accept responsibility for that then they are forever going to be shouting into the void.

That's fine Derek, but is there no red line for you, no compromise too far.

I haven't voted Labour (in a GE) since 1992. My personal red line is electoral reform, I won't vote for a party that does not support pr. Ironically it was the one positive about Starmer, he said he was open to a change in the way we vote. Something else he has changed his mind on, now firmly a fptp guy.

At some stage you have to ask are the current Labour Party a force for progress, if elected to govern , will they change things for the better.

Sadly I have come to the conclusion they won't.
Reply
#13
(05-02-2023, 01:54 PM)baggy1 Wrote: 2019 was fought on Brexit alone Ted and Corbyn's inability to articulate what he wanted to do was the biggest downfall and the Tories jumped on that. The party on the whole wanted a referendum but the left didn't due to restriction of any nationalisation of services if we were still in the EU. Being out suited Corbyn and you could see that in his reluctance to pick a side. 

The tories just upped the bullshit with 'oven ready deal' and 'send the paperwork to me' and conned the masses. Problem is much like when the mob currently in power 'won' brexit they hadn't actually got an implementation plan.

You're incorrect that 2019 was fought on Brexit alone. It was also the opportunity to firmly reject the toxicity of Corbyn.

As a dyed in the wool 50-year opponent of the EU and everything it stood for Corbyn could have helped the situation along enormously rather than being in hock to his own Remain extremists for 4 years - of which Starmer led the vanguard. The public, by and large, were so sick and tired of the whole fucking Remain charade of "respecting the vote" (arf) that they voted for a deal. Any deal. And the shitshow that's ensued.

As for the next election, which is the only one worth talking about B1 - Starmer has changed his position on every single major policy programme. God only knows what we'd get if he was elected, though at least he hasn't got the freedom Blair had of inheriting an economy that worked - which'll bind his hands.

Cards on the table. At the next election I will vote for the party that convinces me they have a realistic plan to build houses, won't devise new and exciting ways to tax my income and assets, details reform of the NHS and offers the semblance of sense on deregulating an economy that's been throttled ever more since Brexit.

I'm guessing I'll be spoiling my ballot like I will on Thursday - choice of anti development Tory, anti development Indy, anti development Lib Dem. All of them live in houses built on farmland like I do.
Reply
#14
(05-02-2023, 03:08 PM)Shabby Russian Wrote:
(05-02-2023, 02:14 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(05-02-2023, 12:07 PM)Ted Maul Wrote: 100% agree Proth.

This stupid island will get the leader it deserves at the next election, whether that be full-fat Tory or Diet Tory. How any genuine Labour man or woman can look at what's happened to the party in the last three years and be proud is beyond me.

The problem is Ted the Ooh Jeremy Corbyn version of Labour would see them in permanent opposition. Now you can be proud of your principles but they help no one but placard makers, permanent maker manufacturers and loud hailer salespeople. 

They failed and until those who supported them accept responsibility for that then they are forever going to be shouting into the void.

That's fine Derek, but is there no red line for you, no compromise too far.

I haven't voted Labour (in a GE) since 1992. My personal red line is electoral reform, I won't vote for a party that does not support pr. Ironically it was the one positive about Starmer, he said he was open to a change in the way we vote. Something else he has changed his mind on, now firmly a fptp guy.

At some stage you have to ask are the current Labour Party a force for progress, if elected to govern , will they change things for the better.

Sadly I have come to the conclusion they won't.

The problem I have is I have always been politically homeless. Momentum’s style Labour are just as extreme as the tossers currently in charge. They are the flip-side of the ERG / Brexiteer / Libertarian types, unable to get past their ideological position to the detriment of the country. They (hard left) may say nice things but only if you smile politely and agree with them. It’s not an honest position that they take far from it having worked with them in the past.

The idea that one extreme side of the political spectrum has all the right ideas to very complex problems is a lie perpetuated by door knocker types to the gullible. For example if I was making policies I would not tolerate antisocial behaviour at all because imo it gives licence for crime to escalate and drags an area and community down. Essentially it’s giving in to bullies. Now if I said that to a Momentum type I would be accused of being too judgmental / harsh / right wing, if I said it to a Libertarian they would scoff at the idea of community or responsibility to think of others. You cannot win with those on to the left or right of politics because they will always put their ideology first rather than pragmatic decision making to make things better. Some policies have to be hard nosed, some have to be softer some both depending upon what you’re trying to fix / make better. Our first past the post system is ludicrous I totally agree but until it changes do I and millions of others who have been adversely affected by this government just sit on our hands and not vote or do I choose the only other current credible alternative? 

We whether I or others like it or not live in a small c Conservative country and unless a Labour, Lib Dem or Green Party recognises that or the political system changes we are forever in a death spiral of warring cancel culture populism versus let’s sing Ooh Jeremy Corbyn at Glastonbury politics neither of which solve fugging anything as we have seen for the past 13 years. The trouble is both the hard right and hard left have been far too influential at the expensive of those with pragmatic rather than ideological answers to difficult questions.
Reply
#15
(05-02-2023, 03:51 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: we are forever in a death spiral of warring cancel culture populism versus let’s sing Ooh Jeremy Corbyn at Glastonbury politics neither of which solve fugging anything 

We're not now, so I doubt we will be in the foreseeable future with two such centrist stuffed shirts leading their parties. The direction of travel is to the kind of politics you love Dekka. Vanilla, safe, Blairite centrism with a heart.
Reply
#16
(05-02-2023, 04:03 PM)Protheroe Wrote:
(05-02-2023, 03:51 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: we are forever in a death spiral of warring cancel culture populism versus let’s sing Ooh Jeremy Corbyn at Glastonbury politics neither of which solve fugging anything 

We're not now, so I doubt we will be in the foreseeable future with two such centrist stuffed shirts leading their parties. The direction of travel is to the kind of politics you love Dekka. Vanilla, safe, Blairite centrism with a heart.

Not really when you have the likes of Badenoch (spelling), Braverman, 30p Lee, Gullis playing culture wars and the Tufton Street mob applying pressure in the background etc, forever trying to create division and come up with childish, vindictive, simple solutions to complex problems and overseeing 13 abject years. 

We can have exciting back with the likes of Johnson the liar and Truss the economic disaster if you want. It’s not really best for the country though is it? Your politics would and has harmed the country. Let the grown ups rather than the petulant toddlers run the country.
Reply
#17
(05-02-2023, 04:54 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:  Your politics would and has harmed the country. 

My politics hasn't been attempted since about 1987.
Reply
#18
Right wing labour - might get in power every 20 years with no decent policies

Left wing labour - never a chance of getting power

What’s the point ?
Reply
#19
I’ve no issue with him rowing back on tuition fees. It’s unaffordable at the moment and the reasons for that are the economic mess he will inherit
Someone could have been killed
Reply
#20
(05-02-2023, 08:59 PM)Ournextstriker Wrote: Right wing labour - might get in power every 20 years with no decent policies

Left wing labour - never a chance of getting power

What’s the point ?

If you distilled the left of Labour down then Owen Jones is the a single malt of stupidity with a bitter after taste. The bloke would rather people suffer at the hands of this awful government than compromise his ideology the massive whopper!
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: