Not good enough for some ...
#11
When a loan player is on the back pages every week, making assists and scoring for fun, the parent club will always think we will have some of that. Hence he goes back. I'm glad we had Barnes and we owe him our place in the league IMO. He gave the whole place a lift with his enthusiasm and energy.
Reply
#12
(03-25-2019, 10:12 AM)Statto Wrote: The flip side of removing the recall option of the parent club is that would also remove the option to send them back.  For us, see Galloway.  If Barnes hadn't worked out, he'd have been left here.

For the seals, they'd have been secure in the knowledge they had Abrahams, but would still have Bolassie stinking the place out on mega dough.

Loans have always been a case of some you win, some you lose.

What amazes me is that people seem to think that the club loaning the player are in a position to dictate terms to the parent club, however much they might be polishing up their rough diamond.  Imagine our attitude if Walsall or Exeter started trying to dictate the terms on loanees. It would be a case of "it's our player, who the fuck are you?" and "beggars can't be choosers".

They are. How many people wanted Barnes?? We stole him off Leeds.
Reply
#13
(03-25-2019, 10:37 AM)Kit Kat Chunky Wrote:
(03-25-2019, 10:12 AM)Statto Wrote: The flip side of removing the recall option of the parent club is that would also remove the option to send them back.  For us, see Galloway.  If Barnes hadn't worked out, he'd have been left here.

For the seals, they'd have been secure in the knowledge they had Abrahams, but would still have Bolassie stinking the place out on mega dough.

Loans have always been a case of some you win, some you lose.

What amazes me is that people seem to think that the club loaning the player are in a position to dictate terms to the parent club, however much they might be polishing up their rough diamond.  Imagine our attitude if Walsall or Exeter started trying to dictate the terms on loanees. It would be a case of "it's our player, who the fuck are you?" and "beggars can't be choosers".

They are. How many people wanted Barnes?? We stole him off Leeds.


Of course you can sell the club to the player by offer playing opportunities, with payment incentives coming into the mix at club level.

However, the response was mainly about the Barnes/Abraham recall point earlier in the thread.  

If we were insisting on no recall for Barnes and Leeds were agreeing to a January recall option, then if Leicester wanted the recall option in there, he goes to Leeds.
Reply
#14
On loans in general, at the level of the Barnes loan, there are fees to be negotiated so it is not a one way street. It may be that the club who takes out the loan is willing to pay more for a deal where there is no clause to recall. These are not selfless acts by the parent clubs, there is a commercial aspect to them.

On Barnes in particular, I haven't worked this out, but I would be surprised f there was a massive difference between the points per game earned when he has played and when he hasn't played for us. The big difference is in the games against teams in the top 3. Didn't help that his leaving coincided with Phillips not being available through injury.
Reply
#15
(03-24-2019, 11:35 PM)Sliced Wrote: Of all the sticks to beat TP with, not playing Serge Gnabry the season we finished 14th in the Prem really isn't high up on the list.

Wenger saw him for 7 years and still let him go a) firstly to us on loan and b) away for 5 million because he refused to give assurances that Gnabry would have first team opportunities. If anyone deserves criticism....

I can't remember who exactly was above him in the pecking order at Arsenal but I'm willing to bet they were a bit better than Craig Gardner.
Reply
#16
(03-25-2019, 01:37 PM)Malcolm Tucker Wrote:
(03-24-2019, 11:35 PM)Sliced Wrote: Of all the sticks to beat TP with, not playing Serge Gnabry the season we finished 14th in the Prem really isn't high up on the list.

Wenger saw him for 7 years and still let him go a) firstly to us on loan and b) away for 5 million because he refused to give assurances that Gnabry would have first team opportunities. If anyone deserves criticism....

I can't remember who exactly was above him in the pecking order at Arsenal but I'm willing to bet they were a bit better than Craig Gardner.
 
Big Grin
Reply
#17
Maybe the player just grew up and improved? Perhaps having left Arsenal he decided to be the player his potential promised he could be? Or we could sit rocking in a corner uttering an ex managers name in some strange mascochistic ritual some like to indulge in.
Reply
#18
(03-25-2019, 12:28 PM)Shabby Russian Wrote: On loans in general, at the  level of the Barnes loan, there are fees to be negotiated so it is not a one way street. It may be that the club who takes out the loan is willing to pay more for a deal where there is no clause to recall. These are not selfless acts by the parent clubs, there is a commercial aspect to them.

On Barnes in particular, I haven't worked this out, but I would be surprised f there was a massive difference between the points  per game earned when he has played and when he hasn't played for us. The big difference is in the games against teams in the top 3. Didn't help that his leaving coincided with Phillips not being available through injury.

Ultimately, are you saying you wouldn't have took him if you knew there was a fair possibility of him leaving at christmas?
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)