Gary Walsh
#21
Kit Kat Chunky Wrote:The same could be said of CC. He should have evaluated Button as not good enough, and if Josh isn't good enough leave him on loan. We could then take an emergency loan if needed.

Disagree. CC kept Palmer as no.1 and recalled Griffiths, I'm not really sure he has had time to fully evaluate our keepers but I guess it occurred to him he needs another. I have every confidence he'll do whatever is best. Of all things, who thought our season might be derailed by a 6 week keeper lay off?
Reply
#22
He will have had opportunity to call Josh back for training during his loan. There is usually a clause to allow this.
Reply
#23
I do think that Button deserved a fresh start under Corberan the same as every other player had.I also think that now is the time to bring in Griffiths as we can’t afford to have any negativity creeping in.
Everyone knows the way certain fans react and at least with Griffiths it will be a fresh start where as Button will be lambasted from the start.
Reply
#24
(02-12-2023, 07:08 PM)Huggybear Wrote: I do think that Button deserved a fresh start under Corberan the same as every other player had.I also think that now is the time to bring in Griffiths as we can’t afford to have any negativity creeping in.
      Everyone knows the way certain fans react and at least with Griffiths it will be a fresh start where as Button will be lambasted from the start.

It’s fortunate that Griffiths has plenty of first team experience. It’s almost certain he’ll play. 
As has been said it makes no sense to keep Button in. 
I’m sure he must’ve been an adequate player at one point but his form for us this season has been horrendous.
Reply
#25
I remember not to long ago Johnstone got slagged off week in and week out. Then slowly he began to come off his line, did a few saves and then he was a hero. Now Button is the fall guy. At his age I think his time is up though. Good bench emergency keeper is his position. Lets give Griffiths a go and rebuild the confidence level back to where it was. 
CC always has the option of signing a keeper who doesn't have a club. A few reasonable guys are available.
Reply
#26
(02-12-2023, 09:45 PM)Remi_Moses Wrote: I remember not to long ago Johnstone got slagged off week in and week out. Then slowly he began to come off his line, did a few saves and then he was a hero. Now Button is the fall guy. At his age I think his time is up though. Good bench emergency keeper is his position. Lets give Griffiths a go and rebuild the confidence level back to where it was. 
CC always has the option of signing a keeper who doesn't have a club. A few reasonable guys are available.

Johnstone was never anywhere near as bad as Button. He had a couple of poor games under Moore where the defence was destabilised by what Jones had them doing, but generally the criticism he received was unwarranted and led by agendas.

Button is just plain awful and needs to go for both his sake and ours.

He deserved a chance playing under a more settled defence with CC, but it seems that actually Button was part of the problem we conceded so many cheap, early goals under Bruce and all his return has done is destabilise a vastly improved defence under CC.
Reply
#27
Johnstone developed into a decent Prem keeper. Not England class in my opinion, but did improve. He had a good season in the Prem, but his own agenda didn't help him last season.

Button hasn't played regularly in 6 seasons, and at 34 whatever he had seems to have left him.

He will pick up his money until he is 35, and it's then job done for him.

He should not have been offered a contract, he didn't even want to live in the area. He should be in the lower leagues now.
Reply
#28
(02-12-2023, 10:08 PM)Kit Kat Chunky Wrote: Johnstone developed into a decent Prem keeper. Not England class in my opinion, but did improve. He had a good season in the Prem, but his own agenda didn't help him last season.

Button hasn't played regularly in 6 seasons, and at 34 whatever he had seems to have left him.

He will pick up his money until he is 35, and it's then job done for him.

He should not have been offered a contract, he didn't even want to live in the area. He should be in the lower leagues now.


Yup

More lazy business.
Reply
#29
(02-12-2023, 09:45 PM)Remi_Moses Wrote: I remember not to long ago Johnstone got slagged off week in and week out. Then slowly he began to come off his line, did a few saves and then he was a hero. Now Button is the fall guy. At his age I think his time is up though. Good bench emergency keeper is his position. Lets give Griffiths a go and rebuild the confidence level back to where it was. 
CC always has the option of signing a keeper who doesn't have a club. A few reasonable guys are available.

Johnstone was always a good shot stopper and recognised as such by most, but he was appalling at crosses and his mettle was always a question mark IMO.
Button, has no redeeming features. He's the worst shot stopper I have ever seen in an Albion shirt, is no better in regards to crosses and his positional sense is just laughable. His body language after that ridiculous free kick suggested that he knows he is out of his depth.

CC needs to act on Wednesday, this is no time for loyalty, Griffiths needs to at least get a chance. If he's rubbish, then it's probably our season over, but, if he's even slightly better than Button, we might still have a chance.
Reply
#30
(02-12-2023, 09:45 PM)Remi_Moses Wrote: I remember not to long ago Johnstone got slagged off week in and week out. Then slowly he began to come off his line, did a few saves and then he was a hero. Now Button is the fall guy. At his age I think his time is up though. Good bench emergency keeper is his position. Lets give Griffiths a go and rebuild the confidence level back to where it was. 
CC always has the option of signing a keeper who doesn't have a club. A few reasonable guys are available.

Crap bench emergency keeper is his position.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)