Debenture
#21
(01-04-2023, 11:29 AM)AnelkasBeard Wrote:
(01-04-2023, 11:19 AM)MassDebater Wrote:
(01-04-2023, 11:04 AM)TTM2 Wrote: Interesting that the trade marks and domain names are included in the security of this loan.

Have MSD seen Lai coming and spotted a way to relieve a desperate man of a football club on the cheap?

First thing I thought is it sounds more like a buy out betting/waiting on us failing to go up. they seem to get an awful lot if we fuck up, for the cost of just a bit more than Pereira.

Seems to be a no brainer move from MSD then, if this is the case.

Could this loan actually be a blessing in disguise for us? If this ends up with Lai selling/losing the club and MSD selling, it will hopefully be a good thing for the club. People want Lai out, this seems like it will bring the action to a head.

Can they effectively seize the club on that basis without putting it into administration, with all the horrific stuff that brings?
Reply
#22
(01-04-2023, 11:32 AM)TTM2 Wrote:
(01-04-2023, 11:29 AM)AnelkasBeard Wrote:
(01-04-2023, 11:19 AM)MassDebater Wrote:
(01-04-2023, 11:04 AM)TTM2 Wrote: Interesting that the trade marks and domain names are included in the security of this loan.

Have MSD seen Lai coming and spotted a way to relieve a desperate man of a football club on the cheap?

First thing I thought is it sounds more like a buy out betting/waiting on us failing to go up. they seem to get an awful lot if we fuck up, for the cost of just a bit more than Pereira.

Seems to be a no brainer move from MSD then, if this is the case.

Could this loan actually be a blessing in disguise for us? If this ends up with Lai selling/losing the club and MSD selling, it will hopefully be a good thing for the club. People want Lai out, this seems like it will bring the action to a head.

Can they effectively seize the club on that basis without putting it into administration, with all the horrific stuff that brings?

I'm no expert.  On the front page it says basically "Land and IP" but on Page 6 it refers to "All investments, shares and corresponding related rights".  Then on page 7 it talks about a floating charge which allows them first disposal of its present and future assets, undertakings and rights. 

Which, to the untrained eye, looks like lock, stock and barrel.
Would rather talk to ChatGPT
Reply
#23
So if we default, do MSD then own West Bromwich Albion or just the assets of WBA? or is that the same thing? Its very confusing
Reply
#24
£20m is a bargain for a club of our size with minimal debt.

(01-04-2023, 11:47 AM)Noibla Wrote: So if we default, do MSD then own West Bromwich Albion or just the assets of WBA? or is that the same thing? Its very confusing

Surely, if they own the ground, the assets, the contracts/liabilities and the IP, they effectively own the club (regardless of what Bobby Robson said)?
Would rather talk to ChatGPT
Reply
#25
(01-04-2023, 11:32 AM)TTM2 Wrote:
(01-04-2023, 11:29 AM)AnelkasBeard Wrote:
(01-04-2023, 11:19 AM)MassDebater Wrote:
(01-04-2023, 11:04 AM)TTM2 Wrote: Interesting that the trade marks and domain names are included in the security of this loan.

Have MSD seen Lai coming and spotted a way to relieve a desperate man of a football club on the cheap?

First thing I thought is it sounds more like a buy out betting/waiting on us failing to go up. they seem to get an awful lot if we fuck up, for the cost of just a bit more than Pereira.

Seems to be a no brainer move from MSD then, if this is the case.

Could this loan actually be a blessing in disguise for us? If this ends up with Lai selling/losing the club and MSD selling, it will hopefully be a good thing for the club. People want Lai out, this seems like it will bring the action to a head.

Can they effectively seize the club on that basis without putting it into administration, with all the horrific stuff that brings?

I don't have a clue, complete layman here in terms of this stuff. But, on the face of it, it seems that way to me.
Reply
#26
(01-04-2023, 11:45 AM)CarlosCorbewrong Wrote:
(01-04-2023, 11:32 AM)TTM2 Wrote:
(01-04-2023, 11:29 AM)AnelkasBeard Wrote:
(01-04-2023, 11:19 AM)MassDebater Wrote:
(01-04-2023, 11:04 AM)TTM2 Wrote: Interesting that the trade marks and domain names are included in the security of this loan.

Have MSD seen Lai coming and spotted a way to relieve a desperate man of a football club on the cheap?

First thing I thought is it sounds more like a buy out betting/waiting on us failing to go up. they seem to get an awful lot if we fuck up, for the cost of just a bit more than Pereira.

Seems to be a no brainer move from MSD then, if this is the case.

Could this loan actually be a blessing in disguise for us? If this ends up with Lai selling/losing the club and MSD selling, it will hopefully be a good thing for the club. People want Lai out, this seems like it will bring the action to a head.

Can they effectively seize the club on that basis without putting it into administration, with all the horrific stuff that brings?

I'm no expert.  On the front page it says basically "Land and IP" but on Page 6 it refers to "All investments, shares and corresponding related rights".  Then on page 7 it talks about a floating charge which allows them first disposal of its present and future assets, undertakings and rights. 

Which, to the untrained eye, looks like lock, stock and barrel.


As per most Debentures, the broad intention is that the assets charged are all of those owned by the Club and its corporate group.  So for instance, the intellectual property is all IP owned by the group anywhere - including the trade marks listed.

The land and buildings charged does however appear limited to those specified in the property schedule.  Usually, this clause would also be defined  "all land and buildings including, without limitation, the specific properties in schedule....." - so MSD have a catch-all

The dividends clause is surprisingly ambiguously drafted, but it does appear Prag's interpretation is correct.  I would expect the stance on dividends
 from MSD to be stricter than Barclays (who are a mainstream lender).

As everyone has stated though - the security is pretty standard form and robust.  Essentially, the key is that the club can maintain the repayments - otherwise the security bites.
Reply
#27
(01-04-2023, 11:45 AM)CarlosCorbewrong Wrote:
(01-04-2023, 11:32 AM)TTM2 Wrote:
(01-04-2023, 11:29 AM)AnelkasBeard Wrote:
(01-04-2023, 11:19 AM)MassDebater Wrote:
(01-04-2023, 11:04 AM)TTM2 Wrote: Interesting that the trade marks and domain names are included in the security of this loan.

Have MSD seen Lai coming and spotted a way to relieve a desperate man of a football club on the cheap?

First thing I thought is it sounds more like a buy out betting/waiting on us failing to go up. they seem to get an awful lot if we fuck up, for the cost of just a bit more than Pereira.

Seems to be a no brainer move from MSD then, if this is the case.

Could this loan actually be a blessing in disguise for us? If this ends up with Lai selling/losing the club and MSD selling, it will hopefully be a good thing for the club. People want Lai out, this seems like it will bring the action to a head.

Can they effectively seize the club on that basis without putting it into administration, with all the horrific stuff that brings?

I'm no expert.  On the front page it says basically "Land and IP" but on Page 6 it refers to "All investments, shares and corresponding related rights".  Then on page 7 it talks about a floating charge which allows them first disposal of its present and future assets, undertakings and rights. 

Which, to the untrained eye, looks like lock, stock and barrel.

I think that’s correct. They will want to ensure that if the club does have to be sold to effect their security, there aren’t any obstacles. It is not MSD’s desire to own clubs (owning a club and having debentures with others is a clear conflict) but they could force a sale in the event of default

(01-04-2023, 11:47 AM)Noibla Wrote: So if we default, do MSD then own West Bromwich Albion or just the assets of WBA? or is that the same thing? Its very confusing

They would have the right, but not the obligation, to seize everything from Group downwards

If MSD did enforce their security then that would be a good thing as their priority is to recover their debt, which would be a fraction of the value of the Group. They would need to sell the club for “fair market value” to ensure a sale, and Yunyai would simply receive any balance, but that would enable a sale at day £80-£100m rather than £200m, so a big loss for them. However, in China they could probably save “face” by being forced by MSD to sell at a loss , rather than choosing how to sell at a loss.
Reply
#28
MassDebater Wrote:
CarlosCorbewrong Wrote:
Squid Wrote:
MassDebater Wrote:When The Times uses the word precarious, yam know we iz fugged
https://www.thetimes.co.uk/article/c1750...46ff36ca12

The £583k per month is if the loan is only 10%, even the Times is guessing at 10%, and saying that we have to pay bay £28m, which is £583k a month for 48 months... Couldn't we have used Amigo and asked Seals / Dingles to be our guarantor and then killed the holding company so they'd have had to pay it back Big Grin

It's good that we are getting national media attention. Hopefully it may make some waves among the owners.

There's no point in protesting, apparently.  A quick google of "Guochuan Lai" is reputationally damaging for the wee fella.  And that's because of A4A and S4A.

Not sure the protests have got the Times etc... paying notice (certainly not the Xmas lights and whistles anyway, a more traditional 'life threatening one' may have got the extra notice), they seem to have woke up because of this stupid loan, and let's face it, the protests were in place way before the loan was, so can't even say most of the protests were because of the loan. Also google searches are location based, and affected by all sorts of other things (like your  own search history etc..)so what you see may be skewed, whereas in China they'll see different results. I just Googled him and saw nothing reputationally damaging (because it's not in my search history so it's not so skewed)

Really? Football clubs are always borrowing money, it's hardly news. Whether or not you agree with the various protests I don't think there can be any doubt it is the protesting that has wakened the media to what is happening at Albion. The loan happening has simply added to the furore.
Reply
#29
(01-04-2023, 06:23 PM)Tom Joad Wrote:
MassDebater Wrote:
CarlosCorbewrong Wrote:
Squid Wrote:
MassDebater Wrote:When The Times uses the word precarious, yam know we iz fugged
https://www.thetimes.co.uk/article/c1750...46ff36ca12

The £583k per month is if the loan is only 10%, even the Times is guessing at 10%, and saying that we have to pay bay £28m, which is £583k a month for 48 months... Couldn't we have used Amigo and asked Seals / Dingles to be our guarantor and then killed the holding company so they'd have had to pay it back Big Grin

It's good that we are getting national media attention. Hopefully it may make some waves among the owners.

There's no point in protesting, apparently.  A quick google of "Guochuan Lai" is reputationally damaging for the wee fella.  And that's because of A4A and S4A.

Not sure the protests have got the Times etc... paying notice (certainly not the Xmas lights and whistles anyway, a more traditional 'life threatening one' may have got the extra notice), they seem to have woke up because of this stupid loan, and let's face it, the protests were in place way before the loan was, so can't even say most of the protests were because of the loan. Also google searches are location based, and affected by all sorts of other things (like your  own search history etc..)so what you see may be skewed, whereas in China they'll see different results. I just Googled him and saw nothing reputationally damaging (because it's not in my search history so it's not so skewed)

Really? Football clubs are always borrowing money, it's hardly news. Whether or not you agree with the various protests I don't think there can be any doubt it is the protesting that has wakened the media to what is happening at Albion. The loan happening has simply added to the furore.

The debenture effectively hands over control to the lender (or their assignees) now.  They control the club for all intents and purposes.  The covenant structure will require monthly numbers.  So, they must have concluded we have a plan to be able to repay.   If not, a buyer is lined up..
Reply
#30
(01-04-2023, 11:04 AM)TTM2 Wrote: Interesting that the trade marks and domain names are included in the security of this loan.

Have MSD seen Lai coming and spotted a way to relieve a desperate man of a football club on the cheap?

Yes - hence some of us feeling fairly relaxed about the prospect of being left without a ground/bankrupt. 

The only way MSD get their money back is with this club in business, as the assets are relatively worthless otherwise.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: