Posts: 13,017
Threads: 1,260
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
6
Ronaldo will be 38 in a month. May pros have retired by that age.
Posts: 880
Threads: 30
Joined: Aug 2022
Reputation:
2
(12-30-2022, 08:28 PM)Spandaubaggie Wrote: (12-30-2022, 08:10 PM)BradleyFromTheHalfWayLine Wrote: I saw an article headline which questioned who is the greatest, from Pele, Maradona, Cruyff, Messi or Ronaldo. Ronaldo is and never has been in the class of the other four of these. Ronaldinho, Ronaldo 1, Zidane and Best to name but 4 all belong more in a list with them more than Ronaldo 2.
Ronaldo is more in the class of a Eusebio, Gerd Muller, Rummenigge, Rivaldo, Baggio, Bergkamp, Henry, Batistuta, Romario etc, etc. Could you really say he is clearly a greater player than any, let along all of these? Truly great players to be compared to but they are not, however, among the best-of-best ever and neither is he, despite what his 'numbers' say.
Trouble is different players play in different positions. It’s an argument that really doesn’t work.
Personally I’d put Ronaldo up there, but to cement your point, I agree figures don’t stack up nowadays.
He’s played in an era for big clubs where they dominate like never before.
To add to this more international matches than ever and many against crap sides like Andorra where you can win 9-0 and he score five.
He’s spoilt his reputation greatly this year.
This is also the reason why talk of the 'greatest' with regards to Ronaldo is bogus. Was he a better striker than Maldini was a defender? Was he a better striker than Modric is a playmaker? Was he a better striker than Cafu was a full back? Did he possess the once-or-twice-in-a-generation natural talent of a Hagi, Bergkamp or Ronaldinho? Was he any more imperious a player than Michael Laudrup or Cantona at the peak of their powers? Would strikers from the fairly recent past such as Romario, Stoichkov or Weah have had records similar to his if their time had come in the last 15 years when playing for teams as dominant as Madrid and United were in their respective countries at the time and where it is almost expected for players to play into their mid-30's and beyond rather than being cast aside shortly after reaching their 30th year as used to be commonplace? Would they be more acclaimed on the international stage if they had had the fortune to play for very strong Portugal sides laced with world-class talent rather than minnows Bulgaria and Liberia? Could Ronaldo have inspired a bang-average Bulgaria side to a World Cup semi-final the way Stoichkov did almost single-handedly for them in '94?
Regarding 'numbers' and honours, if this was the best method of assessing excellence then Gary Neville would be one of the greatest right-backs to have played the game. This is clearly not even remotely the case, so what to make of numbers and honours that Ronaldo himself loves to point to when highlighting his 'GOAT' credentials?
Posts: 1,904
Threads: 49
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
6
(12-31-2022, 08:33 PM)BradleyFromTheHalfWayLine Wrote: (12-30-2022, 08:28 PM)Spandaubaggie Wrote: (12-30-2022, 08:10 PM)BradleyFromTheHalfWayLine Wrote: I saw an article headline which questioned who is the greatest, from Pele, Maradona, Cruyff, Messi or Ronaldo. Ronaldo is and never has been in the class of the other four of these. Ronaldinho, Ronaldo 1, Zidane and Best to name but 4 all belong more in a list with them more than Ronaldo 2.
Ronaldo is more in the class of a Eusebio, Gerd Muller, Rummenigge, Rivaldo, Baggio, Bergkamp, Henry, Batistuta, Romario etc, etc. Could you really say he is clearly a greater player than any, let along all of these? Truly great players to be compared to but they are not, however, among the best-of-best ever and neither is he, despite what his 'numbers' say.
Trouble is different players play in different positions. It’s an argument that really doesn’t work.
Personally I’d put Ronaldo up there, but to cement your point, I agree figures don’t stack up nowadays.
He’s played in an era for big clubs where they dominate like never before.
To add to this more international matches than ever and many against crap sides like Andorra where you can win 9-0 and he score five.
He’s spoilt his reputation greatly this year.
This is also the reason why talk of the 'greatest' with regards to Ronaldo is bogus. Was he a better striker than Maldini was a defender? Was he a better striker than Modric is a playmaker? Was he a better striker than Cafu was a full back? Did he possess the once-or-twice-in-a-generation natural talent of a Hagi, Bergkamp or Ronaldinho? Was he any more imperious a player than Michael Laudrup or Cantona at the peak of their powers? Would strikers from the fairly recent past such as Romario, Stoichkov or Weah have had records similar to his if their time had come in the last 15 years when playing for teams as dominant as Madrid and United were in their respective countries at the time and where it is almost expected for players to play into their mid-30's and beyond rather than being cast aside shortly after reaching their 30th year as used to be commonplace? Would they be more acclaimed on the international stage if they had had the fortune to play for very strong Portugal sides laced with world-class talent rather than minnows Bulgaria and Liberia? Could Ronaldo have inspired a bang-average Bulgaria side to a World Cup semi-final the way Stoichkov did almost single-handedly for them in '94?
Regarding 'numbers' and honours, if this was the best method of assessing excellence then Gary Neville would be one of the greatest right-backs to have played the game. This is clearly not even remotely the case, so what to make of numbers and honours that Ronaldo himself loves to point to when highlighting his 'GOAT' credentials?
Really good points made in a really good post. However, re the bold bit - Yordan Letchkov wants a word....
Posts: 10,272
Threads: 694
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
32
(12-31-2022, 08:56 PM)ericlegrisly Wrote: (12-31-2022, 08:33 PM)BradleyFromTheHalfWayLine Wrote: (12-30-2022, 08:28 PM)Spandaubaggie Wrote: (12-30-2022, 08:10 PM)BradleyFromTheHalfWayLine Wrote: I saw an article headline which questioned who is the greatest, from Pele, Maradona, Cruyff, Messi or Ronaldo. Ronaldo is and never has been in the class of the other four of these. Ronaldinho, Ronaldo 1, Zidane and Best to name but 4 all belong more in a list with them more than Ronaldo 2.
Ronaldo is more in the class of a Eusebio, Gerd Muller, Rummenigge, Rivaldo, Baggio, Bergkamp, Henry, Batistuta, Romario etc, etc. Could you really say he is clearly a greater player than any, let along all of these? Truly great players to be compared to but they are not, however, among the best-of-best ever and neither is he, despite what his 'numbers' say.
Trouble is different players play in different positions. It’s an argument that really doesn’t work.
Personally I’d put Ronaldo up there, but to cement your point, I agree figures don’t stack up nowadays.
He’s played in an era for big clubs where they dominate like never before.
To add to this more international matches than ever and many against crap sides like Andorra where you can win 9-0 and he score five.
He’s spoilt his reputation greatly this year.
This is also the reason why talk of the 'greatest' with regards to Ronaldo is bogus. Was he a better striker than Maldini was a defender? Was he a better striker than Modric is a playmaker? Was he a better striker than Cafu was a full back? Did he possess the once-or-twice-in-a-generation natural talent of a Hagi, Bergkamp or Ronaldinho? Was he any more imperious a player than Michael Laudrup or Cantona at the peak of their powers? Would strikers from the fairly recent past such as Romario, Stoichkov or Weah have had records similar to his if their time had come in the last 15 years when playing for teams as dominant as Madrid and United were in their respective countries at the time and where it is almost expected for players to play into their mid-30's and beyond rather than being cast aside shortly after reaching their 30th year as used to be commonplace? Would they be more acclaimed on the international stage if they had had the fortune to play for very strong Portugal sides laced with world-class talent rather than minnows Bulgaria and Liberia? Could Ronaldo have inspired a bang-average Bulgaria side to a World Cup semi-final the way Stoichkov did almost single-handedly for them in '94?
Regarding 'numbers' and honours, if this was the best method of assessing excellence then Gary Neville would be one of the greatest right-backs to have played the game. This is clearly not even remotely the case, so what to make of numbers and honours that Ronaldo himself loves to point to when highlighting his 'GOAT' credentials?
Really good points made in a really good post. However, re the bold bit - Yordan Letchkov wants a word....
Letchkov was the spit of an Irish bloke I knew called Jack McLoughlin. I remember my parents splitting themselves laughing when I called them in to say Jack had scored the winner. They couldn’t believe how similar he was.
Sadly Jack is long gone.
|