Ratings
#31
Brandywell Wrote:
Sliced Wrote:
Brandywell Wrote:
Sliced Wrote:
Brandywell Wrote:If we are using stats to rate the players O'Shea was man of the match followed by Phillips then Reach and Molumby

That makes no sense. There's no stat that translates to a man of the match, it's a combination of factors; not all of which are measurable.

However, having a 66.7% accuracy is objectively fucking shite.

Which aren't measurable?

If a player is making space off the ball to receive a pass, the quality of the run he makes or the quality position he picks up the ball in would be lost in the stats. XG does not account for the position of the defenders or the heights of the attackers and defenders ,it just looks at the position of the attacker. If a winger puts in a cross that an attacker gets on the end of then whether thats down to the accuracy of the crosser or the movement of the attacker is not accounted for. Sometimes shit crosses results in goals. I mean how many more examples do you want of things that aren't born out purely by looking at the raw stats?

You saying "If we are using stats to rate the players O'Shea was man of the match followed by Phillips then Reach and Molumby" makes absolutely no sense at all, because it's generated by a subjective combination of factors. What the hell is there in the stats to say that Reach was man of the match when he was only on for a short while? Whatever algorithm you're looking at clearly is flawed.
Somebody purely based Phillips on his pass % ignoring tackles, interceptions miles covered, headers win  etc etc. I merely presented the facts from a number of player analytical packages 

Unless you reviewed every single Albion player movement in the 90 mins to determine your ratings........fair play

Or just agreeing that your and every method is flawed and perhaps player biased
I certainly missed those. Wink
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: