According to the Perce
I can't see why people equate 442 with having 2 midfielders? Stating the obvious, it gives us 4. With Gibbs and Holgate there is abundant  wide cover. With the exception of having a target man, a MAF or a Bednar, we have plenty of 442 options and by using the width of the pitch we'd have enough threat from 2 of the best strikers in the division.
Our biggest problem this year is that we are over run in midfield, normally because our ponderous approach puts our players on their heel while the opposition are free to push them into errors..
Reply
(03-12-2019, 02:38 PM)WorcBaggie Wrote:
(03-12-2019, 10:00 AM)CA Baggie Wrote: Fair play for at least responding.

We have no chance with the current midfielders of playing 2 in the middle.  We get over run very often with 3 - which 2 could do that job?

The biggest issue I have with your summation is that you want us to be a counter attacking team.  RH struggled at home with that style in the PL, when most teams tipped up to our place thinking they could roll us over.  This season most teams have been happy to sit back from the off and take a point.  We have to take the game to them more so and be a bit more inventive.  That's the reason behind the playing out and enticing them out, we're "supposed" to beat their press and then play in the space this provides.  Not been happening mainly because the defenders aren't consistently capable.  Teams have started pressing us because they've cottoned on to the fact we're shit at playing out.  Ipswich front 3 pressed and the rest stood on the half way line so there was still very little space to go long.

We also don't really possess the forward who can play up top alone and be the focal point of the attack.  MAF did this excellently for RH.

We have a group of very good players, what we don't have from them is a team with much flexibility.  No Left sided CB to play 3, this is obvious and watching Bartley or Tosin try to do that is painful.  Maybe Barry could play there, I'm not sure.

So, it has to be 4 at the back and I reckon we almost all agree on Holgate-Dawson-Hegazi-Gibbs.  Of late I'd question Dawson's position, but I think that's more application than ability.

I can't see any combination of our central midfielders that results in playing 2 in the middle.  Livermore, Barry & Field don't\can't get around the pitch and don't get ahead of the ball.  Morrison and Harper don't do enough off the ball which leaves Johansen, interestingly his best position is supposedly the attacking one in a midfield 3.

So we go with 5, presumably Phillips on the right?  Who plays left?

Which one of our forwards will play up top alone - neither JRod or Gayle have shown an ability to play the lone striker role.  Unless you'd bench the pair and put HRK up front?

I forgot Brunt from the midfield - I think that probably says it all.  Never been a CM and he's not going to start now he's 32/33.  Maybe in front of Gibbs and let him do all the running for him and sit-in to cover him?

For me, we have to play 5 in the middle as we get over run otherwise, ideally 3 at the back too as we simply don't have the forward to play 1.  The problem, as highlighted,  being we don't have a LCB.  The 3 at the back and fannying around at the back aren't connected.  SGM played 3 and he certainly didn't do so.  2 up top would allow Jrod and Gayle to see if they can work as a pair.

My biggest gripe is that we have to play at a much higher tempo, you don't have to have pace (although we have a few) to play quick football. Pass the ball quicker, get it wide early and go at teams.  I think, again, we don't have the drive from central midfield to do this.

We have a legacy from Tony fucking Pulis of midfielders all wanting to sit behind the play and not commit or move too far.

All of this is why we're better away from home.  We haven't yet adapted to being a team that's expected to dominate and be the aggressor to win, we're still in the underdog mode as if it's the PL.  The onus, especially at home, is on us to attack teams and get at them.  

So I think we have a good squad of individuals, on a par with pretty much any on the league, which is where some peoples criticism of BD comes in.  I don't believe they've been moulded into a team.  The squad is missing this ingredient and I'm not sure if BD didn't spot this or simply wasn't given the funds\freedom to do so.  Remember he was working without a DoF or a scouting network of any note for his first ever job.

There is plenty of flexibility in the squad. There are more that 1 way of playing with 4 at the back and the squad is perfectly set up to play a 4.2.3.1 - 4.4(diamond).2 or 4.3.3

The biggest problem with the way we set up under DM (4.3.3) was the lack of intensity and the insistence that the forward 3 did not really have to work backwards. We defended by funnelling back and filling gaps hoping to pinch the ball back and springing into attack. When it worked (primarily with Barnes in the team) it masked a lot of mistakes. When it didn't it looked horrendous. 

There is pace in the team at full back, with Phillips and now Murphy and Montero and to a lesser degree Gayle. The pedestrian way we played and almost 'within' ourselves was just ludicrous and ultimately cost DM his job. Whilst it is all about opinions I will  cannot be convinced that post January the group from 1 -18 on matchday should have gone on a run that got us automatic promotion.

We need a manager who is able to put 'round pegs into round holes' and get the best out of an extremely talented and not especially unbalanced squad (left footed centre half aside).

Exactly!
Reply
Disagree with JRod and Gayle not being having to work hard out of possession in a 433 they did IMHO, but this was a problem as their skill set isn't going to be correctly employed deep in our own half when the ball goes from negative transition to positive!
Reply
(03-12-2019, 05:18 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(03-12-2019, 02:38 PM)WorcBaggie Wrote:
(03-12-2019, 10:00 AM)CA Baggie Wrote: Fair play for at least responding.

We have no chance with the current midfielders of playing 2 in the middle.  We get over run very often with 3 - which 2 could do that job?

The biggest issue I have with your summation is that you want us to be a counter attacking team.  RH struggled at home with that style in the PL, when most teams tipped up to our place thinking they could roll us over.  This season most teams have been happy to sit back from the off and take a point.  We have to take the game to them more so and be a bit more inventive.  That's the reason behind the playing out and enticing them out, we're "supposed" to beat their press and then play in the space this provides.  Not been happening mainly because the defenders aren't consistently capable.  Teams have started pressing us because they've cottoned on to the fact we're shit at playing out.  Ipswich front 3 pressed and the rest stood on the half way line so there was still very little space to go long.

We also don't really possess the forward who can play up top alone and be the focal point of the attack.  MAF did this excellently for RH.

We have a group of very good players, what we don't have from them is a team with much flexibility.  No Left sided CB to play 3, this is obvious and watching Bartley or Tosin try to do that is painful.  Maybe Barry could play there, I'm not sure.

So, it has to be 4 at the back and I reckon we almost all agree on Holgate-Dawson-Hegazi-Gibbs.  Of late I'd question Dawson's position, but I think that's more application than ability.

I can't see any combination of our central midfielders that results in playing 2 in the middle.  Livermore, Barry & Field don't\can't get around the pitch and don't get ahead of the ball.  Morrison and Harper don't do enough off the ball which leaves Johansen, interestingly his best position is supposedly the attacking one in a midfield 3.

So we go with 5, presumably Phillips on the right?  Who plays left?

Which one of our forwards will play up top alone - neither JRod or Gayle have shown an ability to play the lone striker role.  Unless you'd bench the pair and put HRK up front?

I forgot Brunt from the midfield - I think that probably says it all.  Never been a CM and he's not going to start now he's 32/33.  Maybe in front of Gibbs and let him do all the running for him and sit-in to cover him?

For me, we have to play 5 in the middle as we get over run otherwise, ideally 3 at the back too as we simply don't have the forward to play 1.  The problem, as highlighted,  being we don't have a LCB.  The 3 at the back and fannying around at the back aren't connected.  SGM played 3 and he certainly didn't do so.  2 up top would allow Jrod and Gayle to see if they can work as a pair.

My biggest gripe is that we have to play at a much higher tempo, you don't have to have pace (although we have a few) to play quick football. Pass the ball quicker, get it wide early and go at teams.  I think, again, we don't have the drive from central midfield to do this.

We have a legacy from Tony fucking Pulis of midfielders all wanting to sit behind the play and not commit or move too far.

All of this is why we're better away from home.  We haven't yet adapted to being a team that's expected to dominate and be the aggressor to win, we're still in the underdog mode as if it's the PL.  The onus, especially at home, is on us to attack teams and get at them.  

So I think we have a good squad of individuals, on a par with pretty much any on the league, which is where some peoples criticism of BD comes in.  I don't believe they've been moulded into a team.  The squad is missing this ingredient and I'm not sure if BD didn't spot this or simply wasn't given the funds\freedom to do so.  Remember he was working without a DoF or a scouting network of any note for his first ever job.

There is plenty of flexibility in the squad. There are more that 1 way of playing with 4 at the back and the squad is perfectly set up to play a 4.2.3.1 - 4.4(diamond).2 or 4.3.3

The biggest problem with the way we set up under DM (4.3.3) was the lack of intensity and the insistence that the forward 3 did not really have to work backwards. We defended by funnelling back and filling gaps hoping to pinch the ball back and springing into attack. When it worked (primarily with Barnes in the team) it masked a lot of mistakes. When it didn't it looked horrendous. 

There is pace in the team at full back, with Phillips and now Murphy and Montero and to a lesser degree Gayle. The pedestrian way we played and almost 'within' ourselves was just ludicrous and ultimately cost DM his job. Whilst it is all about opinions I will  cannot be convinced that post January the group from 1 -18 on matchday should have gone on a run that got us automatic promotion.

We need a manager who is able to put 'round pegs into round holes' and get the best out of an extremely talented and not especially unbalanced squad (left footed centre half aside).

Exactly!

So you agree - a 5 man midfield.

In your 433 and wide players working back - who would do that role?  Wouldn't it be 451 off the ball and 433 on the ball?   I don't think we have the left sided winger\attacker who will track back an get up front quickly - who would you suggest for this role?  When we're 451 who will lead the lead, I've seen nothing from JRod or Gayle to suggest they have the skill set to do this.


You're agreeing again - we play too slowly.

Not a million miles apart, I just happen to think making a team out of those individuals isn't as easy as you do.  

So Dekka, "Exactly" is a bit bollocks imo and doesn't really answer the questions as to who from the squad will play those roles.
Reply
(03-12-2019, 06:39 PM)CA Baggie Wrote:
(03-12-2019, 05:18 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(03-12-2019, 02:38 PM)WorcBaggie Wrote:
(03-12-2019, 10:00 AM)CA Baggie Wrote: Fair play for at least responding.

We have no chance with the current midfielders of playing 2 in the middle.  We get over run very often with 3 - which 2 could do that job?

The biggest issue I have with your summation is that you want us to be a counter attacking team.  RH struggled at home with that style in the PL, when most teams tipped up to our place thinking they could roll us over.  This season most teams have been happy to sit back from the off and take a point.  We have to take the game to them more so and be a bit more inventive.  That's the reason behind the playing out and enticing them out, we're "supposed" to beat their press and then play in the space this provides.  Not been happening mainly because the defenders aren't consistently capable.  Teams have started pressing us because they've cottoned on to the fact we're shit at playing out.  Ipswich front 3 pressed and the rest stood on the half way line so there was still very little space to go long.

We also don't really possess the forward who can play up top alone and be the focal point of the attack.  MAF did this excellently for RH.

We have a group of very good players, what we don't have from them is a team with much flexibility.  No Left sided CB to play 3, this is obvious and watching Bartley or Tosin try to do that is painful.  Maybe Barry could play there, I'm not sure.

So, it has to be 4 at the back and I reckon we almost all agree on Holgate-Dawson-Hegazi-Gibbs.  Of late I'd question Dawson's position, but I think that's more application than ability.

I can't see any combination of our central midfielders that results in playing 2 in the middle.  Livermore, Barry & Field don't\can't get around the pitch and don't get ahead of the ball.  Morrison and Harper don't do enough off the ball which leaves Johansen, interestingly his best position is supposedly the attacking one in a midfield 3.

So we go with 5, presumably Phillips on the right?  Who plays left?

Which one of our forwards will play up top alone - neither JRod or Gayle have shown an ability to play the lone striker role.  Unless you'd bench the pair and put HRK up front?

I forgot Brunt from the midfield - I think that probably says it all.  Never been a CM and he's not going to start now he's 32/33.  Maybe in front of Gibbs and let him do all the running for him and sit-in to cover him?

For me, we have to play 5 in the middle as we get over run otherwise, ideally 3 at the back too as we simply don't have the forward to play 1.  The problem, as highlighted,  being we don't have a LCB.  The 3 at the back and fannying around at the back aren't connected.  SGM played 3 and he certainly didn't do so.  2 up top would allow Jrod and Gayle to see if they can work as a pair.

My biggest gripe is that we have to play at a much higher tempo, you don't have to have pace (although we have a few) to play quick football. Pass the ball quicker, get it wide early and go at teams.  I think, again, we don't have the drive from central midfield to do this.

We have a legacy from Tony fucking Pulis of midfielders all wanting to sit behind the play and not commit or move too far.

All of this is why we're better away from home.  We haven't yet adapted to being a team that's expected to dominate and be the aggressor to win, we're still in the underdog mode as if it's the PL.  The onus, especially at home, is on us to attack teams and get at them.  

So I think we have a good squad of individuals, on a par with pretty much any on the league, which is where some peoples criticism of BD comes in.  I don't believe they've been moulded into a team.  The squad is missing this ingredient and I'm not sure if BD didn't spot this or simply wasn't given the funds\freedom to do so.  Remember he was working without a DoF or a scouting network of any note for his first ever job.

There is plenty of flexibility in the squad. There are more that 1 way of playing with 4 at the back and the squad is perfectly set up to play a 4.2.3.1 - 4.4(diamond).2 or 4.3.3

The biggest problem with the way we set up under DM (4.3.3) was the lack of intensity and the insistence that the forward 3 did not really have to work backwards. We defended by funnelling back and filling gaps hoping to pinch the ball back and springing into attack. When it worked (primarily with Barnes in the team) it masked a lot of mistakes. When it didn't it looked horrendous. 

There is pace in the team at full back, with Phillips and now Murphy and Montero and to a lesser degree Gayle. The pedestrian way we played and almost 'within' ourselves was just ludicrous and ultimately cost DM his job. Whilst it is all about opinions I will  cannot be convinced that post January the group from 1 -18 on matchday should have gone on a run that got us automatic promotion.

We need a manager who is able to put 'round pegs into round holes' and get the best out of an extremely talented and not especially unbalanced squad (left footed centre half aside).

Exactly!

So you agree - a 5 man midfield.

In your 433 and wide players working back - who would do that role?  Wouldn't it be 451 off the ball and 433 on the ball?   I don't think we have the left sided winger\attacker who will track back an get up front quickly - who would you suggest for this role?  When we're 451 who will lead the lead, I've seen nothing from JRod or Gayle to suggest they have the skill set to do this.


You're agreeing again - we play too slowly.

Not a million miles apart, I just happen to think making a team out of those individuals isn't as easy as you do.  

So Dekka, "Exactly" is a bit bollocks imo and doesn't really answer the questions as to who from the squad will play those roles.


What?? 

Where have I said a 5 man midfield. You are misreading and misquoting to suit your post. A 4.2.3.1 can as quickly move to a 4.4.2 especially with our squad. The obvious way being if JRod was the centre of the 3 behind Gayle, he could easily shift up the pitch leaving the wider of the 3 to play alongside the central m/f players. 

My reply to you wasn't made to be critical of you. It is obvious to all that go that we were painfully slow in our build up but what I would say is to say we can't play with a 2 (central) in midfield because 3 got overrun under DM is nonsense.
Reply
(03-12-2019, 08:03 PM)WorcBaggie Wrote:
(03-12-2019, 06:39 PM)CA Baggie Wrote:
(03-12-2019, 05:18 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(03-12-2019, 02:38 PM)WorcBaggie Wrote:
(03-12-2019, 10:00 AM)CA Baggie Wrote: Fair play for at least responding.

We have no chance with the current midfielders of playing 2 in the middle.  We get over run very often with 3 - which 2 could do that job?

The biggest issue I have with your summation is that you want us to be a counter attacking team.  RH struggled at home with that style in the PL, when most teams tipped up to our place thinking they could roll us over.  This season most teams have been happy to sit back from the off and take a point.  We have to take the game to them more so and be a bit more inventive.  That's the reason behind the playing out and enticing them out, we're "supposed" to beat their press and then play in the space this provides.  Not been happening mainly because the defenders aren't consistently capable.  Teams have started pressing us because they've cottoned on to the fact we're shit at playing out.  Ipswich front 3 pressed and the rest stood on the half way line so there was still very little space to go long.

We also don't really possess the forward who can play up top alone and be the focal point of the attack.  MAF did this excellently for RH.

We have a group of very good players, what we don't have from them is a team with much flexibility.  No Left sided CB to play 3, this is obvious and watching Bartley or Tosin try to do that is painful.  Maybe Barry could play there, I'm not sure.

So, it has to be 4 at the back and I reckon we almost all agree on Holgate-Dawson-Hegazi-Gibbs.  Of late I'd question Dawson's position, but I think that's more application than ability.

I can't see any combination of our central midfielders that results in playing 2 in the middle.  Livermore, Barry & Field don't\can't get around the pitch and don't get ahead of the ball.  Morrison and Harper don't do enough off the ball which leaves Johansen, interestingly his best position is supposedly the attacking one in a midfield 3.

So we go with 5, presumably Phillips on the right?  Who plays left?

Which one of our forwards will play up top alone - neither JRod or Gayle have shown an ability to play the lone striker role.  Unless you'd bench the pair and put HRK up front?

I forgot Brunt from the midfield - I think that probably says it all.  Never been a CM and he's not going to start now he's 32/33.  Maybe in front of Gibbs and let him do all the running for him and sit-in to cover him?

For me, we have to play 5 in the middle as we get over run otherwise, ideally 3 at the back too as we simply don't have the forward to play 1.  The problem, as highlighted,  being we don't have a LCB.  The 3 at the back and fannying around at the back aren't connected.  SGM played 3 and he certainly didn't do so.  2 up top would allow Jrod and Gayle to see if they can work as a pair.

My biggest gripe is that we have to play at a much higher tempo, you don't have to have pace (although we have a few) to play quick football. Pass the ball quicker, get it wide early and go at teams.  I think, again, we don't have the drive from central midfield to do this.

We have a legacy from Tony fucking Pulis of midfielders all wanting to sit behind the play and not commit or move too far.

All of this is why we're better away from home.  We haven't yet adapted to being a team that's expected to dominate and be the aggressor to win, we're still in the underdog mode as if it's the PL.  The onus, especially at home, is on us to attack teams and get at them.  

So I think we have a good squad of individuals, on a par with pretty much any on the league, which is where some peoples criticism of BD comes in.  I don't believe they've been moulded into a team.  The squad is missing this ingredient and I'm not sure if BD didn't spot this or simply wasn't given the funds\freedom to do so.  Remember he was working without a DoF or a scouting network of any note for his first ever job.

There is plenty of flexibility in the squad. There are more that 1 way of playing with 4 at the back and the squad is perfectly set up to play a 4.2.3.1 - 4.4(diamond).2 or 4.3.3

The biggest problem with the way we set up under DM (4.3.3) was the lack of intensity and the insistence that the forward 3 did not really have to work backwards. We defended by funnelling back and filling gaps hoping to pinch the ball back and springing into attack. When it worked (primarily with Barnes in the team) it masked a lot of mistakes. When it didn't it looked horrendous. 

There is pace in the team at full back, with Phillips and now Murphy and Montero and to a lesser degree Gayle. The pedestrian way we played and almost 'within' ourselves was just ludicrous and ultimately cost DM his job. Whilst it is all about opinions I will  cannot be convinced that post January the group from 1 -18 on matchday should have gone on a run that got us automatic promotion.

We need a manager who is able to put 'round pegs into round holes' and get the best out of an extremely talented and not especially unbalanced squad (left footed centre half aside).

Exactly!

So you agree - a 5 man midfield.

In your 433 and wide players working back - who would do that role?  Wouldn't it be 451 off the ball and 433 on the ball?   I don't think we have the left sided winger\attacker who will track back an get up front quickly - who would you suggest for this role?  When we're 451 who will lead the lead, I've seen nothing from JRod or Gayle to suggest they have the skill set to do this.


You're agreeing again - we play too slowly.

Not a million miles apart, I just happen to think making a team out of those individuals isn't as easy as you do.  

So Dekka, "Exactly" is a bit bollocks imo and doesn't really answer the questions as to who from the squad will play those roles.


What?? 

Where have I said a 5 man midfield. You are misreading and misquoting to suit your post. A 4.2.3.1 can as quickly move to a 4.4.2 especially with our squad. The obvious way being if JRod was the centre of the 3 behind Gayle, he could easily shift up the pitch leaving the wider of the 3 to play alongside the central m/f players. 

My reply to you wasn't made to be critical of you. It is obvious to all that go that we were painfully slow in our build up but what I would say is to say we can't play with a 2 (central) in midfield because 3 got overrun under DM is nonsense.

4231 is 5 in mindfield.  No?  Just a more attacking version of 451.

I can’t think of a 2 central midfielder partnership that has the legs and ability to get around the pitch.  Which 2 would you play?  

Maybe in a diamond we could get away with 4, but not sure which players.wouod also mean we’d be playing very narrow. We’d probably end up with full backs high up the pitc and the base of the diamond sitting between the split centre halves - a 3 at the back of you will.

I happen to think 3 at the back would solve more problems than the other formations.  3 or 4 at the back makes no difference to the suicidal football we’ve been playing.
Reply
Thought this was a thread from Percy . Not a debate on tactics.?
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: