Posts: 2,953
Threads: 67
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
12
(10-13-2022, 07:59 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: (10-13-2022, 07:13 AM)Johnnykayeengland Wrote: (10-13-2022, 05:49 AM)Pf1ster Wrote: Whether or not it’s Rowett, we are in a position where a “Pulis-style” 1-0 win has to be better than a “nice” draw or loss, surely?
Please let's not rewrite history.
Pulis lost more games than he won.
Every season.
And he probably drew more than either.
Erm he was managing Stoke, Palace and ourselves in the Prem of course he lost more games than he won. Pointless stat. Better record than any of our other managers bar Hodgson in the Prem over a sustained period. The wheels came off at the end for him, and the club but your argument is flawed. I was referring to his time with us.
It's the cliche of Pulis guaranteed getting you 1-0 wins that is not worth much. It leaves out the 1-0 and 3-0 defeats which outnumbered the former.
And his football was dreadful. With talented players.
Posts: 7,412
Threads: 124
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
11
Posts: 3,808
Threads: 49
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
3
(10-13-2022, 08:46 AM)B68Baggy Wrote: Don't think any Albion fan expects Brazil 70 or Pep ball, and historically we are a pretty pragmatic bunch. SGM is revered, particularly by my gen, for being able to win 1-0 at a canter, but that football had its own aesthetic, as at its best it was a team full of strength and leadership all over the park.
There was also an acceptance of Pulis ball for a year or so, yes it was anti-football but it got results in the PL until he lost his court case and started managing for a sweet pay off. Val ball was greeted with open arms by most whilst we were winning but it became painful once results fell off the cliff. Even our Uncle Woy, whilst a wonderful coach, was first and foremost a pragmatist with a side drilled to oblivion, but we got results and had some fantastic days.
In short, nobody really gives a tuppeny fk if your pragmatic football takes you to the top of the table. Had Val ball's XG been converted to points he'd have been lauded by all but a few purists. However, if your not getting results it can be utterly soul destroying. Can't even tell you why, but those last few months under TTITC were as close to giving up on football as I've ever been.
Billic and Moore both played exciting football at times but sections of the crowd still turned and the sack arrived. Bruce was given more time than deserved as the general way of playing was initially more "pleasing on the eye" comparative to Valball but most fans had worked out the team was poorly prepared and coached well b4 Gourmay acted. He may have managed 1000 games, but I've paid to watch a fair few over the last 30 odd years, and I knew it was all BS.
So, back to Rowett. On the whole, I don't think Albion fans are too fussed HOW we beat teams we should be beating and if Rowett came in, organised the side, started winning games and climbing the table, his past record or style of play would not be questioned. What I would say is that personality, background and style of football can impact on the amount of time a new manager is given to succeed, and the amount of support he gets from the terraces day one. Would Rowat's name be sung from the terraces on game day one? Probably not. Would Dyche's? Think that would be a yes.
For me, I'd be more than willing to give Rowatt a chance based around my, probably rose tinted, worship of SGM (I was a youth bought up on footballing scraps and misery) A pretty modest record on arrival he took things back to basics, made us hard to beat and strengthened positions of real weakness (two full backs and a CB were first on the shopping list if I remember right hmmmm). We lacked leadership so he took the Captains from our rivals and gave us a team who knew how to grind out a win. I'd take that again over some half arsed version of Tikka takka anyday. I used to know someone who had done some coaching at non- league level, he always said `There is no right or wrong way to win a match`.
Posts: 15,277
Threads: 273
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
57
(10-13-2022, 08:46 AM)B68Baggy Wrote: Don't think any Albion fan expects Brazil 70 or Pep ball, and historically we are a pretty pragmatic bunch. SGM is revered, particularly by my gen, for being able to win 1-0 at a canter, but that football had its own aesthetic, as at its best it was a team full of strength and leadership all over the park.
There was also an acceptance of Pulis ball for a year or so, yes it was anti-football but it got results in the PL until he lost his court case and started managing for a sweet pay off. Val ball was greeted with open arms by most whilst we were winning but it became painful once results fell off the cliff. Even our Uncle Woy, whilst a wonderful coach, was first and foremost a pragmatist with a side drilled to oblivion, but we got results and had some fantastic days.
In short, nobody really gives a tuppeny fk if your pragmatic football takes you to the top of the table. Had Val ball's XG been converted to points he'd have been lauded by all but a few purists. However, if your not getting results it can be utterly soul destroying. Can't even tell you why, but those last few months under TTITC were as close to giving up on football as I've ever been.
Billic and Moore both played exciting football at times but sections of the crowd still turned and the sack arrived. Bruce was given more time than deserved as the general way of playing was initially more "pleasing on the eye" comparative to Valball but most fans had worked out the team was poorly prepared and coached well b4 Gourmay acted. He may have managed 1000 games, but I've paid to watch a fair few over the last 30 odd years, and I knew it was all BS.
So, back to Rowett. On the whole, I don't think Albion fans are too fussed HOW we beat teams we should be beating and if Rowett came in, organised the side, started winning games and climbing the table, his past record or style of play would not be questioned. What I would say is that personality, background and style of football can impact on the amount of time a new manager is given to succeed, and the amount of support he gets from the terraces day one. Would Rowat's name be sung from the terraces on game day one? Probably not. Would Dyche's? Think that would be a yes.
For me, I'd be more than willing to give Rowatt a chance based around my, probably rose tinted, worship of SGM (I was a youth bought up on footballing scraps and misery) A pretty modest record on arrival he took things back to basics, made us hard to beat and strengthened positions of real weakness (two full backs and a CB were first on the shopping list if I remember right hmmmm). We lacked leadership so he took the Captains from our rivals and gave us a team who knew how to grind out a win. I'd take that again over some half arsed version of Tikka takka anyday.
This. So much this.
Posts: 7,994
Threads: 188
Joined: Jul 2019
Reputation:
37
10-13-2022, 09:14 AM
(This post was last modified: 10-13-2022, 09:15 AM by Bob Fossil.)
(10-13-2022, 09:01 AM)Ministry Of Silly Signings Wrote: (10-13-2022, 08:46 AM)B68Baggy Wrote: Don't think any Albion fan expects Brazil 70 or Pep ball, and historically we are a pretty pragmatic bunch. SGM is revered, particularly by my gen, for being able to win 1-0 at a canter, but that football had its own aesthetic, as at its best it was a team full of strength and leadership all over the park.
There was also an acceptance of Pulis ball for a year or so, yes it was anti-football but it got results in the PL until he lost his court case and started managing for a sweet pay off. Val ball was greeted with open arms by most whilst we were winning but it became painful once results fell off the cliff. Even our Uncle Woy, whilst a wonderful coach, was first and foremost a pragmatist with a side drilled to oblivion, but we got results and had some fantastic days.
In short, nobody really gives a tuppeny fk if your pragmatic football takes you to the top of the table. Had Val ball's XG been converted to points he'd have been lauded by all but a few purists. However, if your not getting results it can be utterly soul destroying. Can't even tell you why, but those last few months under TTITC were as close to giving up on football as I've ever been.
Billic and Moore both played exciting football at times but sections of the crowd still turned and the sack arrived. Bruce was given more time than deserved as the general way of playing was initially more "pleasing on the eye" comparative to Valball but most fans had worked out the team was poorly prepared and coached well b4 Gourmay acted. He may have managed 1000 games, but I've paid to watch a fair few over the last 30 odd years, and I knew it was all BS.
So, back to Rowett. On the whole, I don't think Albion fans are too fussed HOW we beat teams we should be beating and if Rowett came in, organised the side, started winning games and climbing the table, his past record or style of play would not be questioned. What I would say is that personality, background and style of football can impact on the amount of time a new manager is given to succeed, and the amount of support he gets from the terraces day one. Would Rowat's name be sung from the terraces on game day one? Probably not. Would Dyche's? Think that would be a yes.
For me, I'd be more than willing to give Rowatt a chance based around my, probably rose tinted, worship of SGM (I was a youth bought up on footballing scraps and misery) A pretty modest record on arrival he took things back to basics, made us hard to beat and strengthened positions of real weakness (two full backs and a CB were first on the shopping list if I remember right hmmmm). We lacked leadership so he took the Captains from our rivals and gave us a team who knew how to grind out a win. I'd take that again over some half arsed version of Tikka takka anyday. I used to know someone who had done some coaching at non- league level, he always said `There is no right or wrong way to win a match`. It's not just how you win, it's how you lose.
As Ministry says, winning trumps everything and keeps the dissenters muted. If, however, the results dry up, then the volume goes up and the writing is pretty much on the wall, this will be expedited, though, if the style of play is poor.
Basically, a failing coach playing decent football will get more rope than one who doesn't, but they'll both hang eventually.
Losing under any manager hurts like a bastard, but, losing under Pulis was like being dry bummed.
That's why, I believe, we really need to take our time on this and not make another royal fuck up of the recruitment process. There IS someone out there who can unite the fan base AND get results. They just might not live within 2 streets of Ron, or use the same takeaway!
Posts: 3,652
Threads: 119
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
7
Great post B68.
One question though…Tikka takka? Is The Vine our new official playing style partner?
Posts: 19,492
Threads: 824
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
60
(10-13-2022, 08:46 AM)B68Baggy Wrote: Don't think any Albion fan expects Brazil 70 or Pep ball, and historically we are a pretty pragmatic bunch. SGM is revered, particularly by my gen, for being able to win 1-0 at a canter, but that football had its own aesthetic, as at its best it was a team full of strength and leadership all over the park.
There was also an acceptance of Pulis ball for a year or so, yes it was anti-football but it got results in the PL until he lost his court case and started managing for a sweet pay off. Val ball was greeted with open arms by most whilst we were winning but it became painful once results fell off the cliff. Even our Uncle Woy, whilst a wonderful coach, was first and foremost a pragmatist with a side drilled to oblivion, but we got results and had some fantastic days.
In short, nobody really gives a tuppeny fk if your pragmatic football takes you to the top of the table. Had Val ball's XG been converted to points he'd have been lauded by all but a few purists. However, if your not getting results it can be utterly soul destroying. Can't even tell you why, but those last few months under TTITC were as close to giving up on football as I've ever been.
Billic and Moore both played exciting football at times but sections of the crowd still turned and the sack arrived. Bruce was given more time than deserved as the general way of playing was initially more "pleasing on the eye" comparative to Valball but most fans had worked out the team was poorly prepared and coached well b4 Gourmay acted. He may have managed 1000 games, but I've paid to watch a fair few over the last 30 odd years, and I knew it was all BS.
So, back to Rowett. On the whole, I don't think Albion fans are too fussed HOW we beat teams we should be beating and if Rowett came in, organised the side, started winning games and climbing the table, his past record or style of play would not be questioned. What I would say is that personality, background and style of football can impact on the amount of time a new manager is given to succeed, and the amount of support he gets from the terraces day one. Would Rowat's name be sung from the terraces on game day one? Probably not. Would Dyche's? Think that would be a yes.
For me, I'd be more than willing to give Rowatt a chance based around my, probably rose tinted, worship of SGM (I was a youth bought up on footballing scraps and misery) A pretty modest record on arrival he took things back to basics, made us hard to beat and strengthened positions of real weakness (two full backs and a CB were first on the shopping list if I remember right hmmmm). We lacked leadership so he took the Captains from our rivals and gave us a team who knew how to grind out a win. I'd take that again over some half arsed version of Tikka takka anyday.
Building a connection with the fans from the very beginning is crucial.
Pardew had his name sang because he gave the place a lift after the dour final months of Pulis, and similarly Bruce came in with a more optimistic outlook which was greeted by the fans with open arms.
For me, the manager who has given the place the biggest immediate lift was Slav... Those first 2-3months were fantastic and it felt like he could do no wrong. We need someone who can come in and do that unifying job again.
What I would also add is that a manager's pedigree or reputation can go a long way to doing this. Whilst Dyche and Rowett play similar football, Dyche has not only won promotion twice from this division, but he's done it with a smaller budget and much smaller club. He's also not only established that club in the PL, but taken them into Europe... anyone who can do that with Burnley deserves a lot of credit.
Rowett does not have anything like this success on his CV. He promoted Burton over a decade ago, but other than that he's done an unremarkable, functional job in the Championship. At least Dyche has shown he can improve and drag a club to well above their standing as a compromise for the poor football... Rowett hasn't done this.
Posts: 2,941
Threads: 57
Joined: Jan 2022
Reputation:
25
(10-13-2022, 05:49 AM)Pf1ster Wrote: Whether or not it’s Rowett, we are in a position where a “Pulis-style” 1-0 win has to be better than a “nice” draw or loss, surely?
It's not a binary choice - you make it sound like a team is more likely to win playing defensively than by being more adventurous. There is a happy middle ground to be found here.
If we're prepared to pay compensation, there are other managers I'd prefer us to be going for than Rowett such as Schumacher and Martin. If we end up with Rowett, it'll be difficult for me not to conclude that it's because Gourlay knows him from back down the line somewhere, rather than Rowett's abilities being the key factor.
I'm not really bothered how desperate Rowett is to get the job, I just want us to get the best person we can. Of course if he does want the job to be closer to his family, he ought to be straining every sinew to make sure he does well enough to keep the job if he gets it, but if his idea of doing that is to play dour football I won't be happy. We need someone who'll make the best use of Wallace, Diangana, Swift, Rogic, BTA, Grant and also Dike when he's fit. I don't think we have good enough defenders to play defensively, there's always a catastrophic mistake just waiting to happen.
We have players who can frighten the opposition to death when used properly and are on song (both of these being linked of course) and I see that as being our best route up the table.
Posts: 1,735
Threads: 36
Joined: Sep 2022
Reputation:
5
(10-13-2022, 08:46 AM)B68Baggy Wrote: Don't think any Albion fan expects Brazil 70 or Pep ball, and historically we are a pretty pragmatic bunch. SGM is revered, particularly by my gen, for being able to win 1-0 at a canter, but that football had its own aesthetic, as at its best it was a team full of strength and leadership all over the park.
There was also an acceptance of Pulis ball for a year or so, yes it was anti-football but it got results in the PL until he lost his court case and started managing for a sweet pay off. Val ball was greeted with open arms by most whilst we were winning but it became painful once results fell off the cliff. Even our Uncle Woy, whilst a wonderful coach, was first and foremost a pragmatist with a side drilled to oblivion, but we got results and had some fantastic days.
In short, nobody really gives a tuppeny fk if your pragmatic football takes you to the top of the table. Had Val ball's XG been converted to points he'd have been lauded by all but a few purists. However, if your not getting results it can be utterly soul destroying. Can't even tell you why, but those last few months under TTITC were as close to giving up on football as I've ever been.
Billic and Moore both played exciting football at times but sections of the crowd still turned and the sack arrived. Bruce was given more time than deserved as the general way of playing was initially more "pleasing on the eye" comparative to Valball but most fans had worked out the team was poorly prepared and coached well b4 Gourmay acted. He may have managed 1000 games, but I've paid to watch a fair few over the last 30 odd years, and I knew it was all BS.
So, back to Rowett. On the whole, I don't think Albion fans are too fussed HOW we beat teams we should be beating and if Rowett came in, organised the side, started winning games and climbing the table, his past record or style of play would not be questioned. What I would say is that personality, background and style of football can impact on the amount of time a new manager is given to succeed, and the amount of support he gets from the terraces day one. Would Rowat's name be sung from the terraces on game day one? Probably not. Would Dyche's? Think that would be a yes.
For me, I'd be more than willing to give Rowatt a chance based around my, probably rose tinted, worship of SGM (I was a youth bought up on footballing scraps and misery) A pretty modest record on arrival he took things back to basics, made us hard to beat and strengthened positions of real weakness (two full backs and a CB were first on the shopping list if I remember right hmmmm). We lacked leadership so he took the Captains from our rivals and gave us a team who knew how to grind out a win. I'd take that again over some half arsed version of Tikka takka anyday. What a fantastic post. Couldn't agree more.
Posts: 480
Threads: 7
Joined: Sep 2022
Reputation:
7
10-13-2022, 11:07 AM
(This post was last modified: 10-13-2022, 11:14 AM by B68Baggy.)
(10-13-2022, 09:23 AM)SW4Baggie Wrote: Building a connection with the fans from the very beginning is crucial.
Pardew had his name sang because he gave the place a lift after the dour final months of Pulis, and similarly Bruce came in with a more optimistic outlook which was greeted by the fans with open arms.
For me, the manager who has given the place the biggest immediate lift was Slav... Those first 2-3months were fantastic and it felt like he could do no wrong. We need someone who can come in and do that unifying job again.
What I would also add is that a manager's pedigree or reputation can go a long way to doing this. Whilst Dyche and Rowett play similar football, Dyche has not only won promotion twice from this division, but he's done it with a smaller budget and much smaller club. He's also not only established that club in the PL, but taken them into Europe... anyone who can do that with Burnley deserves a lot of credit.
Rowett does not have anything like this success on his CV. He promoted Burton over a decade ago, but other than that he's done an unremarkable, functional job in the Championship. At least Dyche has shown he can improve and drag a club to well above their standing as a compromise for the poor football... Rowett hasn't done this.
Totally agree regarding Slav, was totally gutted by his sacking at that point. And absolutely on Dyche, by far the better option! But I used Dyche only as a comparison, i'm not backing a Rowett type appointment over Dyche, I just don't think we've got a gnats chance of a coach of his quality coming here!!
We are in a relegation battle in the championship whilst having a management team that is at best unprofessional, and owners who extract money rather than invest. Why would Dyche come here when PL sacking season is just around the corner.
If timing had worked in our favour, he might have considered West Brom the year after relegation, but we are now shopping in a different market consisting of dead beats, experienced youngish managers with moderate success and inexperienced young managers from the lower divisions on the up. I'd love to be proven wrong and see Gourmay pull a real rabbit out the hat like Forest did, but have zero expectation. I'm just praying that Colin wants to enjoy his retirement and refuses to take Gourmays call!!!
|