More Lai’s
#41
(09-13-2022, 09:12 PM)MrFizz Wrote: There was meant to be some sort of 'summit' of great minds in The Vine before the Burnley game. Haven't heard anything since.

We don't seem to have one voice as a fanbase, and having something like that seems to help in mobilising and organising protests etc.
I never got the memo for that one.  IQ too low I guess!

My second back of a fag packet suggestion is to create and issue a large number of red scarves with "please leave" written in Mandarin.   Said scarves would then be held up en masse at every home game when the teams exit the tunnel before kick off and the crowd would remain completely silent.   The eerie and frankly alien situation where we are there but completely mute would surely generate media attention and coverage of the issue that would hopefully spread and influence the outcome we want.    Team can be roared on and supported as normal once they start to announce the line ups.
Reply
#42
All very sad indeed as I believe we're one of the few in the area to own our own ground. Eg. Don't Wolverhampton Council own the Wolves ground etc?

This isn't going to go away, unlike the former chairman who sold our club for an stupidly inflated price only for us to be relegated the same season.  Fair enough, his club and his money but this Chinese fella is just trying to recoup on his huge losses and on a business level who could blame him. Remember he has no affinity to the Albion and the area like we all do. The alarm bells were surely ringing when a supposed billionaire has to scrimp 5m out of us to prop up another business failure.

Protests should happen BTW because the alternative is to say nothing. And what's the point in that?

The obvious Endgame is an unlikely promotion or years of stagnation and hoping for better.

Negatives a plenty but we still have a great club to support and we'll come good again.
Reply
#43
(09-13-2022, 08:34 PM)Everything Zin Wrote: Theft is illegal. Paying shareholders a dividend out of accumulated profits is not illegal and is absolutely normal for most businesses. People may be upset about it but the money in "shareholders' funds" belong, as the name suggests, to shareholders.
Paying dividends is not "asset stripping".

100% correct.  The distributable reserves on the balance sheet belong to the shareholders (including the 12% minority shareholders).  When he bought the club he also acquired 88% of those distributable reserves.  Indeed one could say that the existence of those reserves helped to justify the high price that he paid, because he could always access those reserves. Paying a dividend out of those distributable reserves is not an issue - provided that the company is still solvent immediately after paying the dividend.  

In fact there is nothing to stop a dividend being paid and Lai opting NOT to use the dividend to repay his loan.  They are two separate transactions.  Of course if he did that then “asset stripping” would indeed be a more accurate description.
Reply
#44
(09-13-2022, 09:06 PM)Tom Joad Wrote:
(09-13-2022, 08:34 PM)Everything Zin Wrote: Theft is illegal. Paying shareholders a dividend out of accumulated profits is not illegal and is absolutely normal for most businesses. People may be upset about it but the money in "shareholders' funds" belong, as the name suggests, to shareholders.
Paying dividends is not "asset stripping".

Neither is selling The Hawthorns to a separate business illegal. Would you approve of that too?

If he does that, no. But he hasn't, yet. And where did I say I approve of the dividend (even if some of it will come my way)?
Reply
#45
(09-13-2022, 10:08 PM)Pragmatist Wrote:
(09-13-2022, 08:34 PM)Everything Zin Wrote: Theft is illegal. Paying shareholders a dividend out of accumulated profits is not illegal and is absolutely normal for most businesses. People may be upset about it but the money in "shareholders' funds" belong, as the name suggests, to shareholders.
Paying dividends is not "asset stripping".

100% correct.  The distributable reserves on the balance sheet belong to the shareholders (including the 12% minority shareholders).  When he bought the club he also acquired 88% of those distributable reserves.  Indeed one could say that the existence of those reserves helped to justify the high price that he paid, because he could always access those reserves. Paying a dividend out of those distributable reserves is not an issue - provided that the company is still solvent immediately after paying the dividend.  

In fact there is nothing to stop a dividend being paid and Lai opting NOT to use the dividend to repay his loan.  They are two separate transactions.  Of course if he did that then “asset stripping” would indeed be a more accurate description.
If the fucking idiot didn’t do his due diligence in the first place he has no one to blame but himself. I only care about the future of West Bromwich Albion. As far as I am concerned all bets are off. As a fan base we need to do everything within our power to protect it
Reply
#46
(09-13-2022, 10:13 PM)johntoewba Wrote:
(09-13-2022, 10:08 PM)Pragmatist Wrote:
(09-13-2022, 08:34 PM)Everything Zin Wrote: Theft is illegal. Paying shareholders a dividend out of accumulated profits is not illegal and is absolutely normal for most businesses. People may be upset about it but the money in "shareholders' funds" belong, as the name suggests, to shareholders.
Paying dividends is not "asset stripping".

100% correct.  The distributable reserves on the balance sheet belong to the shareholders (including the 12% minority shareholders).  When he bought the club he also acquired 88% of those distributable reserves.  Indeed one could say that the existence of those reserves helped to justify the high price that he paid, because he could always access those reserves. Paying a dividend out of those distributable reserves is not an issue - provided that the company is still solvent immediately after paying the dividend.  

In fact there is nothing to stop a dividend being paid and Lai opting NOT to use the dividend to repay his loan.  They are two separate transactions.  Of course if he did that then “asset stripping” would indeed be a more accurate description.
If the fucking idiot didn’t do his due diligence in the first place he has no one to blame but himself. I only care about the future of West Bromwich Albion. As far as I am concerned all bets are off. As a fan base we need to do everything within our power to protect it

Who says he didn’t do his due diligence?  He overpaid, but willing buyer/willing seller.  As at 30 June 2016 there were distributable reserves of £23m on the balance sheet so he bought the club knowing that he could take that money out as dividends (of which he’d get 88%), so he’d have factored that into the price he was willing to pay.

(09-13-2022, 10:32 PM)Pragmatist Wrote:
(09-13-2022, 10:13 PM)johntoewba Wrote:
(09-13-2022, 10:08 PM)Pragmatist Wrote:
(09-13-2022, 08:34 PM)Everything Zin Wrote: Theft is illegal. Paying shareholders a dividend out of accumulated profits is not illegal and is absolutely normal for most businesses. People may be upset about it but the money in "shareholders' funds" belong, as the name suggests, to shareholders.
Paying dividends is not "asset stripping".

100% correct.  The distributable reserves on the balance sheet belong to the shareholders (including the 12% minority shareholders).  When he bought the club he also acquired 88% of those distributable reserves.  Indeed one could say that the existence of those reserves helped to justify the high price that he paid, because he could always access those reserves. Paying a dividend out of those distributable reserves is not an issue - provided that the company is still solvent immediately after paying the dividend.  

In fact there is nothing to stop a dividend being paid and Lai opting NOT to use the dividend to repay his loan.  They are two separate transactions.  Of course if he did that then “asset stripping” would indeed be a more accurate description.
If the fucking idiot didn’t do his due diligence in the first place he has no one to blame but himself. I only care about the future of West Bromwich Albion. As far as I am concerned all bets are off. As a fan base we need to do everything within our power to protect it

Who says he didn’t do his due diligence?  He overpaid, but willing buyer/willing seller.  As at 30 June 2016 there were distributable reserves of £23m on the balance sheet so he bought the club knowing that he could take that money out as dividends (of which he’d get 88%), so he’d have factored that into the price he was willing to pay.

And as at 30th June 2021 the distributable reserves had risen to £34.2m.  All of that is theoretically available to shareholders as dividends (if cash flow permits). Of course he only has access to 88% of that.   Dividends could theoretically be paid out every year to pay out those accumulated reserves.
Reply
#47
I can't believe some are more concerned with displaying they know what a dividend is than noticing the club is being denied money by it being diverted to the owner. Yes, it is a limited company, but it is more than that to the community and supporters. Also, a companies' funds being taken out to prop up other spurious enterprises is asset stripping by definition, however legal it may be.. As shareholders then, you will probably be aware that Lai originally tried to take millions out of the club prior to Xmas 2020 but was challenged by other shareholders? Lai knows he overpaid, he knows he won't get 200M back and I guess he is extracting what he can, when he can. (Legal or possibly otherwise, i.e. the attempted sale of Periera).
Reply
#48
(09-14-2022, 07:48 AM)Tom Joad Wrote: I can't believe some are more concerned with displaying they know what a dividend is than noticing the club is being denied money by it being diverted to the owner. Yes, it is a limited company, but it is more than that to the community and supporters. Also, a companies' funds being taken out to prop up other spurious enterprises is asset stripping by definition, however legal it may be.. As shareholders then, you will probably be aware that Lai originally tried to take millions out of the club prior to Xmas 2020 but was challenged by other shareholders? Lai knows he overpaid, he knows he won't get 200M back and I guess he is extracting what he can, when he can. (Legal or possibly otherwise, i.e. the attempted sale of Periera).

This is the problem with billionaire (lol) owners who, quite probably, don't actually give a shit about football and, again probably, don't understand the cultural importance of a football club.  As far as they're concerned, they have bought a business - including all assets - and they can dispose of those assets as they see fit, like any other business case.  

Imagine being a shareholder of ANY other business and not wanting a dividend?
Reply
#49
"billionaire"

a pedantic correction, I doubt this guy is in that category (maybe in Vietnamese dong) and I wonder what the source was of the money used to purchase the club
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: