Archie Battersbee
#11
(08-03-2022, 11:56 AM)petty sniper Wrote: when his mom was on sky news talking about a choreographed execution you have to start to worry about her grasp on the reality of the situation, and I speak as someone who has been through it

Exactly.  Decisions and situations like these require the highest form of clarity when it's the hardest thing to find.  Even moreso when you've got rich and powerful backers whispering in your ear to further their own agenda.
Reply
#12
I have so much sympathy for the parents. It was sudden and unexpected, and they're being fed false hope by a bunch of charlatans using them to make a quick buck.
Reply
#13
Having not followed the case

Despite all the opinions from experts

Why do they think he shouldn't have the life support switched off?
Reply
#14
(08-03-2022, 03:41 PM)Pipkins Wrote: Having not followed the case

Despite all the opinions from experts

Why do they think he shouldn't have the life support switched off?

Think it all boils down to Faith vs Science. 

Family have religious views where they want Archie to "decide" to die, and are taking the fact he's still alive as his desire to fight, whereas the doctors are arguing he is only alive due to the machines, and that he won't "decide" to die as he's already dead.

Utterly horrible situation for the parents, I can entirely see why they are continuing this fight, but from what I've read, it's pretty conclusive that there's no way back from here and the equipment needs to be turned off Sad
Reply
#15
(08-03-2022, 04:21 PM)SW4Baggie Wrote:
(08-03-2022, 03:41 PM)Pipkins Wrote: Having not followed the case

Despite all the opinions from experts

Why do they think he shouldn't have the life support switched off?

Think it all boils down to Faith vs Science. 

Family have religious views where they want Archie to "decide" to die, and are taking the fact he's still alive as his desire to fight, whereas the doctors are arguing he is only alive due to the machines, and that he won't "decide" to die as he's already dead.

Utterly horrible situation for the parents, I can entirely see why they are continuing this fight, but from what I've read, it's pretty conclusive that there's no way back from here and the equipment needs to be turned off Sad

I'm relatively ignorant to this, thankfully so.

Presumably the doctors just wish to turn the ventilators off?  Then the Faith v Science argument will be settled as he doesn't have the capacity to breathe for himself.  If he does and he makes a recovery then their faith was justified.

How long breathing through a ventilator is reasonable for a clinically brain dead person?  I guess this is the argument, they want longer and the doctors disagree.
Trump is a Cunt
Reply
#16
(08-03-2022, 05:14 PM)CA Baggie Wrote:
(08-03-2022, 04:21 PM)SW4Baggie Wrote:
(08-03-2022, 03:41 PM)Pipkins Wrote: Having not followed the case

Despite all the opinions from experts

Why do they think he shouldn't have the life support switched off?

Think it all boils down to Faith vs Science. 

Family have religious views where they want Archie to "decide" to die, and are taking the fact he's still alive as his desire to fight, whereas the doctors are arguing he is only alive due to the machines, and that he won't "decide" to die as he's already dead.

Utterly horrible situation for the parents, I can entirely see why they are continuing this fight, but from what I've read, it's pretty conclusive that there's no way back from here and the equipment needs to be turned off Sad

I'm relatively ignorant to this, thankfully so.

Presumably the doctors just wish to turn the ventilators off?  Then the Faith v Science argument will be settled as he doesn't have the capacity to breathe for himself.  If he does and he makes a recovery then their faith was justified.

How long breathing through a ventilator is reasonable for a clinically brain dead person?  I guess this is the argument, they want longer and the doctors disagree.

In this US case, the child lasted 4.5 years.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jahi_McMath_case
Reply
#17
Squid Wrote:
CA Baggie Wrote:
SW4Baggie Wrote:
Pipkins Wrote:Having not followed the case

Despite all the opinions from experts

Why do they think he shouldn't have the life support switched off?

Think it all boils down to Faith vs Science. 

Family have religious views where they want Archie to "decide" to die, and are taking the fact he's still alive as his desire to fight, whereas the doctors are arguing he is only alive due to the machines, and that he won't "decide" to die as he's already dead.

Utterly horrible situation for the parents, I can entirely see why they are continuing this fight, but from what I've read, it's pretty conclusive that there's no way back from here and the equipment needs to be turned off Sad

I'm relatively ignorant to this, thankfully so.

Presumably the doctors just wish to turn the ventilators off?  Then the Faith v Science argument will be settled as he doesn't have the capacity to breathe for himself.  If he does and he makes a recovery then their faith was justified.

How long breathing through a ventilator is reasonable for a clinically brain dead person?  I guess this is the argument, they want longer and the doctors disagree.

In this US case, the child lasted 4.5 years.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jahi_McMath_case

Only in America, as we hurtle closer towards an americanisation of our country.

Maybe being over cynical but that case seemed to revolve around the damages award being restriced for death and not for deemed to be living.
Trump is a Cunt
Reply
#18
It's a terribly sad situation but as someone who always tries to find a positive i suppose it has given parents an opportunity to warn their kids about the dangers of these stupid social media challenges that have cost this lad his life.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: